Silverscarcat's Favorite Techdirt Posts Of The Week
from the stay-frosty dept
Hey, Techdirt readers. What's up? Yeah, looks like it's my turn to pick my favorite posts of the week. Lots of stuff was covered this week, so how about we get into it?
I've always been interested in various copyright laws, since I, like many fans, tend to use the "gray" area of copyright known as fanfiction and fanart. Really, it's just a good story or good artwork that can get me interested in a show easier than anything else.
And it's because of that that when I see stuff like SOPA, PIPA, ACTA and TPP that I get worried. Stuff that I and many others enjoy would suddenly no longer be protected by safe harbors that's afforded by the DMCA.
Which is why when I see the weak response that the White House puts out about their stance about ACTA, it's both worrying and angering. After all, the internet should be free and not limited because businesses can't innovate.
Speaking of things that can't innovate, the RIAA seems to think that making new laws will stop piracy. I think we need to get the RIAA and MPAA execs in a room and give them a full history of Prohibition and the results of that. Or maybe the war on drugs, which has done nothing to stop people from getting the drugs and instead just increased the prison populations.
Of course, when they realize that stakeholders are no longer able to fit in one room, maybe then they'll start to understand the internet a little more. This is the internet and information age, we're connected all over the world and people force businesses to increase their customer service or lose business.
Speaking of the internet, it's pretty sad that there's all these data caps on information. What? Does information that comes from the government taste better than the information from Google and Wikipedia?
I used to watch the Simpsons a lot when I was younger, so when I see that Fox News is making an idiot out of itself, I can't help but think of Kent Brockman going "This just in, flying birds are attacking ugly pigs, more at 11, but first, a word from our sponsor."
Speaking of television, it saddens me that television is slowly starting to die off. Television could do so much better if they would put better shows on the air. I admit, the most popular shows on the air are stuff like Survivor and American Idol, and you wouldn't believe how long it took me to remember the names of those shows. The problem is, while they're the most popular, how often do you hear people the next day talk about the shows at work? You don't. Give me good shows like Avatar the Last Airbender, Transformers Prime, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Star Gate SG1. Sure, you don't have people talking too much about them the next day, but they are, in my opinion, way more engaging. That doesn't mean I don't watch reality-like shows, I love Mythbusters, Ninja Warrior, Storage Wars and Pawn Stars after all, but there's no forced drama there, like there is in most reality TV series.
When I saw that copyright might just be to keep Hollywood from competing with itself, it does make me think a little. After all, who wants to compete with themselves. It's like if you cloned yourself and you and your clone went after the same person. Boy, wouldn't that be awkward.
Speaking of cloning yourself, imagine how complicated death will become when we can easily clone ourselves or transfer our minds into robot bodies. By the way, if we can do that before Stephen Hawking dies, I recommend that he gets to be the first in a robot body so we can clone him a new one.
Ironically, the day after that came out and I thought about it, it looks like some SciFi writers are thinking the same thing.
You know, if the government taxes stuff, does that mean that piracy is now legal in Germany? After all, you can only tax stuff that's legal, right? And if piracy isn't legal in Germany, then why are people getting taxed for it? That makes no sense to me.
I couldn't think of anything for this next one, but, just call Congress, call them now, get this passed somehow. Hey, that rhymes.
While Congress might be out of touch with the internet, it looks like the White House really can't understand anything, not that it's surprising, since when do politicians know anything about technology. I bet Mr. Rogers could have gotten Congress to stop trying to lock down the internet like he did with the Betamax and the VCR before.
Until next time, stay frosty.


Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
This was because the PEOPLE didn't want it to be illegal.
WELL...
Technically speaking, people *DID* want it to be illegal, at first.
However, people soon found out that their scapegoat of alcoholism being all of the problems of society was a falsehood and the fact that you had to now DEAL with them instead of being able to drink to try and forget them, even for a little bit, caused real issues.
So now, people wanted alcohol to get away from problems, but it was illegal, so they started to make their own.
And that was how organized crime came into being in the 1930s.
Once alcohol was legal again, though, most of the organized crime either went away or moved onto something else.
Huh... I wonder if that should be applied to marijuana or something.
Something to think about.
Re:
And AJ has left feeling superior to everyone even though he lied his way through all the comments!
Find out what happens next time on Techdirt, the ongoing chronicles!
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
So says the dumbass troll, huh?
I'm just calling it like I see it, AJ.
No matter how many times we've told you that this isn't about weakening copyright, but rather about letting owners have control of their items, you just put your fingers in your ears and go "NO! IT'S WEAKENING COPYRIGHT! DEBATE ME, MIKE! WHY YOU RUN AWAY LIKE A COWARD?!"
So, really, AJ, you're the dumbass troll.
All of your points have been countered and you just keep replying with the same lies.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
No, you're just such a dumbass troll that he's done arguing with you because you'll just go, like you're doing now, "LALALALALALALALALALALALA!!! I CAN'T HEAR YOU!!! WHY YOU NO DEBATE ME?! LALALALALALALALALALALALALALA!!!!" with your fingers in your ears.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
Oh, and one more thing, buskahosa...
But there is no RIGHT to fair use, only a privilege.
that's a flat-out lie!
Copyright is the privilege, not Fair Use. Fair Use is the right and is how creativity fucking works!
But you'll just ignore what I say like you ignore everything else that counters your little world, won't you?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
It protects DRM which protects copyright.
hoo hoo hoo!
that is Wrong! Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, WRONG!
DRM does NOT protect copyright. DRM is a POS that entertainment industries put up so that people couldn't make legitimate copies of their CDs, DVDs, or Video Games because the publisher didn't want that.
In fact, AJ, DRM specially controls how content is used. There is *NOTHING* about DRM related to copyright OTHER than the DMCA.
So, go back to your MPAA masters and tell them that DRM may just be outlawed soon.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
Those are stupid arguments, AJ.
Stop using stupid arguments.
if you throw a brick at someone or something, you cause harm, thus your rights interfere with someone else's rights to live. In that case, your rights are trumped.
So, AJ, kindly, use some fucking common sense for once in your miserable life.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
I'm sorry, no, wait, I'm NOT sorry at all, that clause really is total B.S. and goes against nature.
If you own something, you can DO WHAT YOU WANT WITH IT!
The first sale doctrine, the Supreme Court's ruling on the matter of buying something and then re-selling and doing what you want with it, states that copyright law does NOT trump a person's right to do with property as they please.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
You know, most of us are rolling our eyes at you.
Because, honestly, AJ, if you buy something, shouldn't you *OWN* the thing?
And, according to the First Sale Doctrine, which TRUMPS copyright law, once you buy something, you can do what you WANT to it, no questions asked.
Re: Re: average_joe
I think gerbils could be taught to understand better.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
What copyrights are being weakened, buskahosa?
Just because it'll allow me to use MY property that *I* legally purchased the way *I* want to and not the way *THEY* want me to doesn't mean that it weakens copyright.
If I buy a cellphone, a PS3, or a 3DS right now, they are region/service locked and breaking that lock is against the law, even if I legally purchase a game/service from another region/service provider so that I can play/use the game/service.
I'm pretty sure that's wrong.
Or did you miss the case where the Supreme Court slapped down the textbook publisher and said first sale doctrine trumps your copyright?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
Pah! You have no problem with the DMCA?
How about all the legitimate Fair Uses that get taken down daily? How about the fact that the DMCA doesn't allow me to buy a phone from Sprint, then, when my contract runs out, run it on, let's say Straight Talk for how I want because it's locked onto Sprint.
There's nothing about copyright in that, buskahosa.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
How so?
By making it LEGAL to take your stuff and make it work the way you want it to so you can use it for legitimate stuff?
Like say, if I wanted to Jailbreak a Nintendo 3DS so I could import Japanese games, how is that taking rights away from Nintendo?
So...
If he has/had a website that had infringing stuff on it, he wouldn't care if it got taken down for no reason then, right?
but I think a more apt thing is this...
If someone at his home had something that was given to them, even if it was legally bought, from someone else, his house was raided, everything confiscated by some military then his house burned down while he can only watch in horror...
Well, at least he'd know how Kim Dotcom feels.
Re:
I know this is just another brainless FUD piece
And you and your masters would know that, since you perfected that art decades ago, wouldn't you?
I'll tell you why...
People hate change.
Re: Prenda Fall down
the hole
Re: Re:
Did you just compare rape to copyright?
...
Whenever I see "arguments" like that, it just sickens me.
So...
Web 3.0 will be a broadcast medium instead of user generated?
Meanwhile, the Neo Internet will come out and be even harder for government to control.
Damnit, we need a new internet.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
The problem is, when the primaries come up, well...
Ron Paul was the most moderate of all of the R candidates last election...
Bets that Democrats registered as R's and voted for Romney?
And don't forget that many R's register as Dems to vote for the man/woman least likely to win against their candidate at times.
You basically have a situation where both sides are sabotaging each other just to get a few points and screw the country over.
Moderates can't win because of that situation.