Todd Shore 's Techdirt Comments

Latest Comments (41) comment rss

  • Stingray Uber Alles! St. Louis Cops Drop Case Against Robbery Suspects Rather Than Discuss Use Of IMSI Catcher

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 27 Apr, 2015 @ 01:22pm

    Guilty plea withdrawn

    The person who had guilty has now withdrawn her guilty plea.

    It is interesting that the prosecutors office would give in to the political pressure to drop these charges when they can compel the officers to testify.

  • Awesome Stuff: Smartphone Proximity Locks For Your Car

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 18 Apr, 2015 @ 10:07pm

    With a signal repeater you can bridge the distance between phone and car so that "proximity" is several hundred feet and security protocols don't need to be broken if transmission delay isn't computed.

  • Linux Developer Who Issued Bogus YouTube Takedowns Threatens Techdirt With Legal Action For Publishing His 'Private Information'

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 12 Jan, 2015 @ 01:37pm

    Huh, a "Linux Developer" who doesn't appear to be familiar with whois.

    Please take a pillow into the closet and pound that tantrum out.

  • NSA Waited Until Christmas Eve To Release Details Of Its Illegal Surveillance On Americans

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 29 Dec, 2014 @ 07:36am

    In a 2012 case, for example, an NSA analyst “searched her spouse’s personal telephone directory without his knowledge to obtain names and telephone numbers for targeting,” according to one report. The analyst “has been advised to cease her activities,” it said.

    Did she have access to "her spouse's personal telephone directory" through the NSA?

  • Seattle PD Holds Hackathon To Solve Body Cam Footage Redaction Problem

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 24 Dec, 2014 @ 07:15pm

    If that is what you take out of what I said then one of us made a mistake. Maybe because there is a "not" in there. I think we agree.

  • Seattle PD Holds Hackathon To Solve Body Cam Footage Redaction Problem

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 24 Dec, 2014 @ 04:28pm

    "where the conditions were knowingly not met" is the key phrase. It means knowledge on the part of the person giving consent, not by the state official, though it will certainly be argued otherwise.

    Police have heard the "police may lie" too many times and they are getting into the habit of thinking that applies at all times.

  • Seattle PD Holds Hackathon To Solve Body Cam Footage Redaction Problem

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 24 Dec, 2014 @ 02:57pm


    If someone says, "Yes, you may enter my home IF you turn off your camera" in a case where a warrant would normally be required what is the procedure?

    Do they not enter? Do they turn off their camera? Do they enter pretending their camera is turned off and then deal with the lawsuit later? What happens if while in the home the person that gave them that conditional approval discovers that their terms are not met and forcibly removes the officer from the premises?

  • DailyDirt: Spoiler Alert… Santa Claus Ain't Real

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 23 Dec, 2014 @ 08:20pm

    No Santa... check
    No Tooth Fairy... check
    No Easter Bunny... check
    No God. Hmmm. Some people take longer than others.

    Telling your kids lies that they will eventually discover is never a good idea.

  • Sony Demands Twitter User Remove Posts Containing Images Of Leaked Documents

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 22 Dec, 2014 @ 02:13pm


    "Confidence is a great thing, but a private citizen generally finds his/her rights to be a bit diminished as compared to the press, rather than vice versa."

    "press" is not capitalized in the US Constitution. It is about the action, not the person or institution.

  • Nothing Changes: Cops Still Threatening Citizens, Breaking Laws To Shut Down Recordings

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 19 Dec, 2014 @ 05:24pm

    Re: Re:

    Cool. "Thrown in jail" is just another point in the conversation with the decade long legal public discussion popping up in press every few years that goes along with it. At some point, it WILL happen. Waiting...

    Do I have to be the ONE that adds that talking point? Am I just a pussy that is too afraid to push? Opportunity missing?

    Is this post is getting to be more and more just one more piece of evidence at some future trial? Does it matter if it is formed in the form of a question? If cops can lie, can the citizenry, especially when in "just" a blog? Or is a posting "absolute"?

  • Nothing Changes: Cops Still Threatening Citizens, Breaking Laws To Shut Down Recordings

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 19 Dec, 2014 @ 04:58pm

    Too many lawyers suggest that you should just follow along with the LEO and worry about cleaning up the legalities later. As soon as the LEO violates someone's Constitutional rights or commits a felony then they are no longer in commission of their duty. I am waiting for the test case where a LEO pulls a firearm while violating someone's rights, they are shot dead by someone that has committed no crime, and we have a true test case. Heaven help the court that rules against the civilian.

  • FBI Director Continues His Attack On Technology, Privacy And Encryption

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 16 Oct, 2014 @ 02:55pm

    Law Enforcement thinks they are the law

    Law Enforcements sees themselves and what they do AS the law.
    Which is why they never can understand it when the citizenry criticizes law enforcement for itself acting above the law. The Government asks, "How can we be above ourselves? These wacko people even understand basic logic".

    This is the true problem with "governmemt entitlements". The government feels entitled. The courts certainly haven't helped with their "compelling interest" rulings. I do not ever recall seeing "compelling interest" in the Constitution, yet a LOT of case and legislative law has been built on it even around amendments that specifically include "Congress shall make no law".

  • FCC's Tom Wheeler Admits There Isn't Really Broadband Competition

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 04 Sep, 2014 @ 06:29pm


    As long as the FCC does carve outs for wireless then of course this is going to be the case. Quit making exceptions and make them operate on the same playing field. If we have to get wired providers to operate on a level playing field then local governments can always leverage their right of ways.

  • California Cops Seize Recordings Of Questionable Arrest, Claim They Have The 'Right' To Do So

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 15 Aug, 2014 @ 05:53pm

    Who has the absolute right and who has legislative uncertainty?

    They are going to end up flipping this on its head where the citizen is justified in resisting the suppression/violation of their rights. Now, the police will violate and worry about court cases later. Soon, it will be the other way around.

  • NY Times Says FCC Should Reclassify Broadband Under Title II

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 15 Aug, 2014 @ 04:09pm

    As more land lines disappear and VOIP services become the norm, not just from companies such as Vonage and other SIP providers, but from Verizon and AT&T as well...

    As services such as Skype and their competitors subsume traffic from traditional PSTN services...

    As Twitter, Facebook, and newer generation services become the communications means of choice...


  • DOJ Tells Court That Of Course It Can Go On A Fishing Expedition Globally For Emails Microsoft Stores Overseas

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 16 Jul, 2014 @ 03:55pm

    Records vs. Data

    They keep relying on the term records, as in Business Records, which is the normal meaning of that term. Data is quite another creature.

    This confusion of terms is on purpose to help the slope get slippyer.

  • US Has A 'Secret Exception' To Reasonable Suspicion For Putting People On The No Fly List

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 18 Apr, 2014 @ 03:05pm

    VISA for Citizen

    If she is a US citizen why does she need a VISA?

  • FCC Finally Starts Process To Dump NFL Blackouts

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 25 Dec, 2013 @ 10:09am

    NFL is standing alone

    The NFL's arguments are irrelevant. The FCC isn't concerned with the status of stadiums and their attendance. Their focus is on sports programming being available over the airwaves. The economics of the league itself are so stable that they themselves admit that they have a historic low in blackouts, effectively admitting that blackouts are not going to affect viability of the league and likely not the individual teams. That last is questionable and they like to point it out, but it doesn't matter. The amount of programming available to broadcast will not go down if the blackout is removed and that is the FCCs only mission in this affair.

  • How Trademark Law Can Finally Kill Dan Snyder's Racist Dreamworld

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 08 Nov, 2013 @ 06:30pm

    They should trademark "Washington BMFs" and pay Samuel L. Jackson to be their spokesperson.

  • Why Companies Should Start Regularly Reporting That They Have Not Received Secret NSA Orders

    Todd Shore ( profile ), 11 Sep, 2013 @ 10:02am

    Running log

    Create a running log, updated once per some interval, such as minute, 5 minutes, etc. If a log item is missing...

Next >>