" I have yet to see anyone (other than our trolls and the usual maximalists in the industry) arguing that it's fair to extradite him"
What I find really sad is that from what I know of Kim Dotcom, I would bet he really has broken laws he should stand accountable for.
Having said that though, I do not think he should be extradited because the DOJ can't present a solid case and instead have botched up just about everything they could. They have used excessive force, tried to destroy evidence, and even tried preventing him from having legal counsel. So they managed to go after what should have been easy case, and managed to make Kim look like a saint next to how screwed up the DOJ is.
Re: So... To all pirates who think 6 Strikes can't work...
All I have to say is, Yikes, where did you learn about networking?
" a VPN will NOT help you: they're monitoring by both amount and TYPE of traffic, and as I've said torrenting is easily detected."
VPNs encrypt the traffic so the ISP cannot see what it is. That is the very point of a VPN and they are used WIDELY by businesses. So you can't block VPNs and you can't tell what is in a VPN. So how then is torrenting easily detectable?
Even moving on from that massive fail as to what the ISP can tell about VPNs. Torrenting is perfectly LEGAL. It is by far the best way to get Linux distributions. There are tons of legal torrents, so just "torrenting" is no cause to kill a connection.
Of course all that does not even begin to address your total epic fail about how the ISP can block people. Hijacks your browser? Really?
I fully agree with you on that point. Only thing I would add is to say that it is not just the copyright system. I really think the entire US legal system is due for a restart. The system has too many patches.
I look at it kind of like computer code. You start off making a program and as you find bugs you patch them and ratchet up the point numbers. After a while though you have to break down and work on V.2 where you rewrite all your code and clean it up.
Re: "marketing" to industry types means "get money in return", Mike.
"The only forum where "give away and pray" is taken seriously."
You know, it is kind of funny you should say that. There have actually been a few studies about this "give away and pray" method. A prime example is the common car wash as a fund raiser. You will actually make more money if you setup offering "free" car washes and asking for donations than if you try and charge a set price.
See, this is exactly the kind of thing that has to be stopped. People going all crazy and thinking for themselves, coming up with different ways to say the same thing.... Its madness, it must be stopped!
Ok, so let me get this straight. In your twisted world innocent people get punished for crimes they did not commit, BUT YOUR FINE WITH THAT, because well.... that is part of having justice.
Just because their are flaws in the justice system does not mean we have to accept them. We have every right to complain when innocent people are punished. THAT IS NOT JUSTICE, and if it is happening then our JUSTICE system is broken and needs fixing.
I actually wonder if any car thief has been charged with that yet.... A lot of the new cars now have the fancy computer controlled ignitions where you no longer use a key. So I would think you could probably get slapped with a computer hacking charge for defeating that system and cranking the car.