Have Drone Will Travel: Slow-Moving Regulators Force Innovation Overseas

from the letting-innovation-fly-away dept

Drones are leaving the U.S. for greener pastures, according to several media outlets (e.g., WSJ and Bloomberg).  In response to slow-moving U.S. domestic policy on commercial drone use, innovators are moving abroad, to jurisdictions where regulations have been updated to delineate when drones may be used in the commercial context.  (Keep in mind, we are not talking about fixed wing Predator drones with Hellfire missiles, but aircraft that are already available commercially with much of the same technology already incorporated into our mobile phones.)  Besides smaller companies actually moving abroad to places where they can sell their wares, even the likes of Google and Amazon have moved their drone testing to Australia and India, respectively.

Making matters worse, export control policies are poorly targeted, and prevent some drones made with widely available technology built in the United States from being sold overseas.  In fact, according to the Wall Street Journal, 3D Robotics — a San Diego-based company that specializes in drones with video capability — was only allowed to resume selling some of its products in a number of countries because the drones were manufactured in Mexico:

Export rules prompted 3D Robotics to temporarily halt shipments to 44 countries this spring. It has since secured a new classification from the U.S. Commerce Department, in part because it manufactures its drones in Mexico, allowing it to resume foreign sales.

And for those inclined to view this as a minor development in a niche market, at least one study predicts that allowing commercial drone use in the United States could create 100,000 new jobs and $82 billion in economic impact over the course of the next decade.

A lot of smart people have already said a lot of smart things about the drone situation, so I won't delve too deeply into the nuances of streamlining commercial drone policy making.  Clearly, there are good reasons why commercial drones can't take to the sky without some rules, but it is imperative that regulators move efficiently to establish a framework where, for example, a real estate agent or a surveyor can survey a property with a drone (in the same way it is currently legal for a non-commercial user to fly an off-the-shelf drone in her backyard).  That is not happening now.  According to the Department of Transportation's own Inspector General, the FAA is likely to miss its Congressionally mandated deadline in coming up with rules that allow for the expansion of commercial drone use.

There's a general point here worth expanding on: even if a country does everything right, creating a fertile environment for research, investment, and innovation (aka the hard stuff), innovation will nevertheless move overseas if outdated regulations impede the lawful sale or use of a product or service.  It does not matter if the United States has the brightest minds, best expertise and easiest access to venture capital; if you can't sell, test or export drones here, then we will see those jobs and that talent go overseas to more fertile ground.  In fact, this is already happening.  And even if the FAA eventually comes up with a workable set of regulations that allow commercial drone activity, in fast moving industries — where first mover advantage is enormous — bureaucratic delays can be terminal.

Take Japan in the 1990s.  Japan was a high-tech giant.  In the early 1990s, both the U.S. and Japan had companies interested in innovating in online search engines.  However, Japan's highly restrictive set of copyright laws meant that in order to index a website you had to get the website owner's permission first.  When there are a couple hundred or a couple thousand websites, this is feasible.  But clearly, this does not scale.  Fortunately for U.S. innovators, the U.S. had copyright "fair use" enshrined into law, which allowed transformative uses of copyrighted content.  This paved the way for U.S. search engine entrepreneurs, while the Japanese search sector never got off the ground.  Even though Japan eventually updated its copyright law to make search engines legal (in 2007!), it was too late.  As of today, U.S. search providers (Yahoo Japan and Google) have well over 90% of the Japanese search market.

The "crypto wars" of the 1990s are also a place to look for a parallel to the drone fight.  Until 1992, the U.S. government imposed very strict export controls on cryptography.  Although the export of strong encryption technology was viewed by many in the law enforcement and national security communities as detrimental to their missions, the rise of electronic commerce greatly increased the need for robust encryption in commercial products and Internet services.  What followed was a long drawn out battle in which encryption proponents focused on several key arguments, including the logistical problems with trying to prevent the export of programming concepts, the widespread availability of cryptography internationally and free speech concerns.  Another angle, which tied in with the ease of moving cryptographical research overseas, was that innovation in the U.S. would be harmed as much software engineering would be forced to move overseas in order to get around the onerous U.S. restrictions — restrictions that would have little actual effect on the worldwide availability of cryptography.  Jon Peha, a professor at Carnegie Mellon who would later go on to be the Assistant Director of the White House's Office of Science and Technology policy, outlined some of the competitiveness concerns in a paper he wrote on encryption policy in 1998:

Industry critics argued that the restrictions accomplished little, since 128 bit encryption without key escrow is already readily available outside the US. An April 1998 report from the Economic Strategy Institute concluded that the policies imposed at that time (i.e. the 1996 interim policy) would cost the US economy between 35 and 96 billion dollars between 1998 and 2002. Some US companies have overcome these limitations by purchasing foreign products or shifting development activities overseas. For example, in March 1998, Network Associates announced that it would begin contracting all encryption development to a Swiss company.

By 2000, U.S. restrictions were sufficiently relaxed and the sale of software with encryption technology in it was made significantly easier.  However, in certain situations export controls still apply, and the process for complying with them is still relatively byzantine.  (And, with the recent NSA scandal and the fallout, we might be heading towards the Crypto Wars II.)  To this day, there is still significant discussion on how the remaining export controls affect national competitiveness.  (See European Commission Document on Export Controls, page 7.)

Churning out smart engineers and cultivating venture capital is not enough to succeed in a competitive globalized world.  Policy bandwidth needs to be devoted to clearing unnecessary hurdles to commercializing and exporting the fruits of that innovation.  Although Europe's "innovation policy" is lagging the U.S., countries like Germany are ascending to the lead in drone innovation because people can actually use drones commercially and export them to other countries.  If a company cannot achieve the sales base necessary to scale their business, then they cannot continue to innovate.

Going forward, we should not just think of the other domestic policy fights in a vacuum.  Take Tesla, for example.  They are succeeding in producing commercially attractive electric vehicles where so many other companies have failed:  a public policy and economic triumph that has been nearly universally lauded.  Yet, they face sales bans or restrictions in over half of the states in the U.S based on a set of outdated and widely criticized auto dealer regulations.  As the company continues to scale, and as foreign markets grow and more consumers worldwide fall into the crosshairs of Tesla's salespeople, an unnecessarily restrained domestic market will only force the company to locate more infrastructure and talent overseas than they otherwise would in the first place.

In the Tesla and drone cases, we got the hard stuff right.  The United States fostered an innovative and dynamic economy that unleashed a wave on entrepreneurship and innovation.  Now, much like the situation in immigration policy where we are pushing some of our best and brightest minds overseas, slow moving regulators and policymakers are forcing some of our nation's most dynamic companies overseas as well.

Reposted from the Disruptive Competition Project


Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread


  • icon
    Richard (profile), 21 Oct 2014 @ 3:46pm

    The featured Parrot Drone

    We have some of these - they are no more than a novelty and borderline useless for anything practical.

    Quadcopters are easy to make and cheap because they move the complicated aspects of proper helicopters out of the mechanics and into the elctronice. Usually this is a good strategy - but not here because the side effects of doing this mean that they are unflyable in anything but perfect weather because of the lack of control authority. Since a proper collective pitch micro-helicopter can be purchased for around $100 nowadays ther is no reason to use a quadcopter. For many applications a fixed wing aircraft will be better.

    It puzzles me that calling a model aircraft a "drone" somehow makes it a new piece of technology. It isn't - it's just a model aircraft = and in the case of a quadcopter a pretty badly designed one at that!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

    • icon
      Richard (profile), 21 Oct 2014 @ 3:51pm

      Re: The featured Parrot Drone

      For information - here is an example of a proper commercial drone system - csaable of doing a wide range of work - and fully legal under UK (CAA) safety rules:

      http://www.westwalesmodels.co.uk/UAV

      reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

    • identicon
      Jack, 22 Oct 2014 @ 9:55am

      Re: The featured Parrot Drone

      This isn't about $100 quadcopters and micro-helicopters but a multi billion dollar industry. There is absolutely no reason a quadcopter can't have good control authority the same as a collective pitch helicopter - it's simply a matter of using the right high quality components. High RPM rotors and 3-axis gyros and accelerometers with some decent stability software will make any helicopter or quadcopter as stable as a rock even in adverse conditions. Sure, it'll cost more to do it in a quad or hex rotor, but the payload capacity will be much higher.

      There is a good reason the military uses multirotors and not micro helicopters in small applications like recon drones - for the size and weight of the unit, they have far better payload capabilities and are inherently more stable.

      reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

    • identicon
      Tim A, 25 Oct 2014 @ 7:15pm

      Re: The featured Parrot Drone

      I agree the Parrot AR.Drone is a bad example. It's nothing more than a way overhyped, overpriced, hard to control twitchy toy that produces horribly jelloed video that they seem to actually be proud of. Maybe the're immune to it since that's all they've seen... :-/ And using a mobile device with Wi-Fi to fly any aircraft real-time is a joke. About the only good thing is the control by map mode, but you're still limited to the crappy range of Wi-Fi.

      But I'm not sure where you're going with the rest of your comment. Basing it on the AR.Drone is pretty short sighted, because you clearly are aware that there is better based on your 2nd comment. And Daniel did mention 3D Robotics, which is leaps and bounds better.

      A $100 collective pitch helicopter isn't even going to lift a keychain camera. And why collective pitch anyway? It's not like the aerial photography platform needs to fly upside down. A 4 channel fixed pitch setup would be cheaper and just as effective.

      There are multirotor solutions starting only twice as expensive as the AR.Drone with infinitesimally better control and video stability and quality.

      And multirotors can hover, and with enough motors, like 6 or more, and the right flight controller, they can afford to lose one or maybe more and still make it back in one piece. And again, they're not that much more expensive than Parrot's toy.

      reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Anonymous Coward, 21 Oct 2014 @ 5:03pm

    Policy bandwidth needs to be devoted to clearing unnecessary hurdles to commercializing and exporting the fruits of that innovation.
    Don't be silly. If they actually solved problems, what would they be able to promise to fix in order to get elected?
    Actually creating jobs would be political suicide. You need to promise job creation, then preserve a state of widespread unemployment, to ensure that the public remains disgruntled in your favor.
    Fortunately, that's an easy matter. All you have to do is let a bunch of poorly-run megacorps pay your election bills for you, then just write whatever stupid laws they tell you to write while claiming that they'll "create jobs". The megacorps' small competitors all die pointless deaths, unemployment stays in the double digits, and the masses keep voting for anyone who uses the phrase "job creation". Piece of cake.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Ninja (profile), 22 Oct 2014 @ 2:11am

    Some policies are bought by the sectors that benefited from the lack of them or at least because they were reasonable and fairly open. Copyright, Patents, the Auto dealers case... The US is letting legacy players burden their economy to the point it will eventually succumb to its own weight. If nothing is done to stop the Disneys and the likes of the world.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    textibule (profile), 22 Oct 2014 @ 3:41am

    I can only sigh. I have so been looking forward to looking out my window, seeing a clear blue sky dotted with drones doing all sorts of innovative things designed to make my life better. Now it looks like I'll have to move to India if I want to realize my dream.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Anonymous Coward, 22 Oct 2014 @ 7:50am

    After reading the article all I can say is, amen.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    David Wang, 24 Oct 2014 @ 8:05pm

    FAA needs to get it's act together

    If this is true, we really need to have the government get its act together. There is so much enthusiasm right now with quadcopters, it'd be a shame to see it wasted and curbed because of an inept government.

    --
    http://www.quadcopteracademy.com

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    yo whammy mammy zappa jimi joplin jones!, 19 May 2015 @ 3:30am

    I AM GREEN HORNET

    I GOT YO WAMMO TUPAC BRAIN CHIP YO YO!
    Batman verses predator issue one!
    FEE FIE FO FUM SEMPER PHI I'M ON POINT!

    SCOTT WALKER BANNED POTATOES!

    SO BOLO X RAY VISION !
    AND NAPALM STICKS TOO KIDS YO JUNKEY HINCKLEY HONKEY DRILL SARGENT!

    Google Telletubby union 76 MANY MORE Shrews !
    B.P. Boheemian ZURICH Code Blown!

    WHITE ROSE
    HELD DOWN RESISTANCE ON ANY SPEECH FORM!

    SOROS Hollerith I.B.M.
    FUROR DICTO PHONE!

    AND I WHITE WASH YO ALL TOO RUSH TOM SAWYER!

    APPLE OR INTEL SILICON Disc Drive HANUBU !
    I GOT HIGH STEPPER ANY TECH POSITION AND THATS NOT ALL !

    MIND CONTROL IS THAT STEEPED SERVED ARBIET ZIET BERLIN CODE SILICON AMAZON OLIVER STONE OR CIRRUS WILLIAM TELL BOHEEMIAN AUSHWITZ BONUS PIZZA SATTELITE NASA BUGGERY ALL OVER STAZI BERLIN OR INTEL ?

    MALAYSIAN OFFSHORE TELLETUBBYS ALSO !?
    NAFFTA CRASS DARPA AND NASA !?

    ON SCREEN CAPTAIN!

    With soros fiat coupons for Grey Skull Poop ON!

    AND CHECK OUT MILTON THE MUENSTER
    Rome OR Rammstien GERMAN FUROR STAZI BENZIEN POWERED Drones!?
    AND ALL OF THESE GASOLINE POWERED DRONES!

    YO HUBBLE SCOPE GOT YOUR PLUTO ANAHIEM CODE EXPOSED TOO BELKAN STAZI AND ROMAN AUSTRIAN ALP Matterhorn SNOWDEN EXPOSED YO !

    ALPINE NOSTRO BONER N.S.A. BUGGER INTEL NIXON ON HARRIS BUGGER PHONES JONES WATERGATE ON!

    CHANNEL FIVE!

    LATE
    NITE CARSON MADONNA
    OR THEODORE ROOSEVELT INVESTIGATED TOO THE DIME!
    BEYOND HITLERS DEAD NEW YORK TIMES!

    NOW P.B.S. DRONE THREAT ON THEE AMERICAN PUBLIC
    I'M GONNA OWN THAT
    COOKIE MONSTERZ DAMAGE DONE
    BAGISIM & BAG !

    ALSO EXPOSED SAMBO TELLETUBBY NORDIC HOWARD JOHNSONS BALTIC SEA REAGEN
    OR CLINTON OFFSHORE INTEL NAFFTA AND ARBIET GATE SAUDI OPEC !

    MOST Any Goon GOT Hitler,
    PRE MADONNA FREE SPEECH FORM ARBIET AND ZIET!

    DARWIN AND THULE FUROR LANGUAGE SPRANGLE AND ORWELL THEN DUMB DOWN & DANGLE!

    Turns out he was the FUROR AND Father of Drones,
    ADOLPH HITLER !

    IS THAT YOU MADONNA ARGENTINA EVA PERONE
    YOU CAN EAT FUROR CRASS
    THULE
    HILLER
    OR HIMMLER
    RELGION
    KAISER
    BELKAN
    FUROR
    VATICAN
    CAKE!

    More primitive but then that was the best
    AN GRIFF EXPOSED ROMAN NOMAD HANUBU CULT ONLY RATZI SWISS CANNIBAL PREDATOR PROVEN RACIST PATHAGRIS Technology of Its Cult FUROR HOOK NOSE U BOAT Belkan Days...

    Only Peter Sellers Gestapos Knows!
    STEVE MARTIN CHARLIE CHAPLIN!
    JACK COUSTEAU AND CARPO!

    The V-1 were nothing more Than pilotless Drones,
    ONLY YAMOGOTO AND YOKO ONO AND DEAD BRANDO KNOW!

    Only perry mason knew they were sent to kill anyone and everyone
    ....in that case everyone was AMAZON

    "collateral damage"
    And KINDLE intended WILLIAM TELL APPLE GOT Target SNOWDEN INTEL AT AMAZON INTEL CULT DRONE KRAFTWERK A MODEL THULE RATZI PEENAMUNDE CODE AND ZIBITS
    2001 TWIN TOWERS
    IN The same time. WITHIN ANY CENTURY
    ..seems in that regard we're better than
    ADOLPH Hitler NOT!

    ONLY The Same clover!
    A bootleg moon rover idea....murder at a distance and murder of innocent people whether you planned to or not....NASA and just like ADOLPH Hitler,
    WIEMAR HOOK NOSE EXPOSED!

    SO THOSE SO ARBIET GATED BILL GATES AND OFF SHORE INTEL NAFFTA SOME CALLED SHAKE SPEAR LANGAUGE ON MARS ORSONS RACISTS CALLED RACISTS TOO
    HAWKIN
    EARTH
    MANKIND!

    ALSO DEFINED AS DONT ASK DONT TELL
    WAR CRIMINALS PROVEN KAISERS AND INDIFFERENT IN JUST CEASER STUCKA STUCK IN ROMAN CONCENTRATION PROVEN ARBIET ZIET ROMAN ADD DEATH CAMP ARBIET ZIET
    RATZI CYANIDE
    CAP PASTORS
    GET RAM INTEL BRAIN CHIP UP ANUL TOO BRAIN~!

    CONTACT GRAVITY OR MISSION IMPOSSIBLE
    EXPOSED IN CRASS ROMAN BELKAN THULE DRONE THREAT RELIGION!

    AND WE ALL started out as Innocent BORN People
    Whom all would have preferred to get on with their lives!
    ALSO raise their al jaffey any chaplin families...

    They are not the
    "mad Islamists"
    OR STAZI Bacon Cult Drone Nose OF Pigs And Rats!

    Also no government makes them out to be are the insane ones!

    And while we!~
    The Logans Runners
    Have our Families and SILICON BRAIN CHIPPED Children Safely Tucked Mad Max Away AND LETS PRETEND?
    DEFLATE FOOTBALL !
    OPERATION!

    AND DONT ASK DONT TELL ONLY
    CLINTONS
    ORDERS!?

    SECRET
    OBAMA
    MEETINGS
    AND
    FOR These pigs and rats still find it necessary to range the world killing innocent people...only now they kaiser proven only rat brained chipped your future almost creating fabricating people clones will actually bomb our ships in a Gulf of Tonkin...That was then the President's word alone that we had been attacked was enough...but today is today and just saying we have been attacked won't do....pearl harbor again today we need someone to ROBOT DRONE attack us...and that has been our BERLIN KAISER POLICY C.N.N. PUBLIC FUROR DRONE THREAT
    CODE ASK WEATHER MAN BOB DYLAN!
    MARINE OCEAN DESALINISERS FROM ATLANTIS TAXES CAPTAIN NEMOS!
    SAVED A PLANET DROUGHT
    FROM OCEAN SPOUTS!

    Ever since WOODSTOCK ONE!
    IRON BUTTERFLY
    Steppenwolf!


    AND In the end WOLF Hitler turned out to be the Greatest enemy any people ever had!

    Destroy any country that anyone ever had...
    And the same fate awaits us....
    You can't escape this kind of Karma...Dogma!

    YA just can't
    Suge knight run over any Dog OR WEB SITE BAN ANY FREE SPEECH YOU LIKE !

    YAHOO GOOGLE BOOK FACE ALL THESE ARE DREADNAUTS!
    ZHIEGHIESTED BUGGERS
    OR KUBRICK OR ZOETROPE EXPOSED!

    TAKE ON PHIL K. DICK! NIBIRU AND HANUBU
    BRADBURY ON YOUR LEFT RIGHT AND CENTER !

    EXPOSED GREEN SCREEN
    INTEL GOT YO PHONE!

    NO ONE MUST KNOW WHAT YOU SEE AND HEAR!

    DO YOU WANT TOO KNOW A SECRET DAVE HULL A TICK!
    K.R.L.A. FIFTH BEATLE!?

    AND I AM WOLF MAN JACK!

    Zonder Commandoe Krause ALL YOU HOMOS!

    Even intel matrix Dragon
    ON SNOWDEN!

    BANTAM NUEROMANCER BUGGER YO HOUSE HARRIS BUGGER YO NIXON BLUE NUTS!
    DEFLATE YO QUEER TRANS BALLS PLAY JOHN JOLMSE DYKE JOHN BOEHNER PROVOS PORNOS & DONT ASK DONT TELL JONES!

    ONLY CLINTONS KNOW
    REAGEN MERKEL MIEN KAISER TUCHLER OBER KOEHLER FUROR?

    MIEN SPIELBERG E.T. STEVEN SPIELBERG WENNER BLOOMBERG MILDENSTIEN
    BLADE RUNNER BLOMBERG S.S. OR KAISER ZIBITS S.A.
    AMAZON DRONE AN GRIFF HENDERSON
    NURNBERG ZONDER COMMANDOES?

    I GOT
    ALIAS SMITH AND JONES
    HERALD EXAMINER GONE BUGGER BLUES SOME B.B. KING AL CAPONE
    WILD WEST AND NAT KING COLE
    JOURNEY TOO THE CENTER OF THE EARTH
    ALSO ROB CONRAD DEAD
    BABA BLACK SHEEP MOTHERS AND DYNAMOE !
    SO
    I OWN RE NAMED GRHAMINS VIA TONTO LONE RANGER AND SINCE HOPI DINO MAURO ROCKY RANGER OFFECHUS AND SERIES ONE !

    SILICON CHIP BIENZENE OR GASOLINE CULT FUROR DRONE!

    MIND CONTROL BLINKY!
    GOT SILICON TRON BRAIN CHIP ARBIET AND ZIET!

    AND THATS BLINKY TOM DOLE RIP CHORD HOLLYWOOD EVIN RUDE ALEX JONES KNOWS!
    I WALK THE LINE JOHNNY CASH!

    NIXON ANUL BUGGERY AND ANY JONES !?
    PORNO FOR PYROS
    TRIUMPH MOTOR CYCLES XENER DIODES ALSO !

    AND MARVIN GAYE IS GONE ALSO JOHN LENNON OR SALLY MANSFIELD
    ALMOST GOT DRONED OR BOMBED BY CULT OF FUROR DRONES!

    ALL OF ANTWERP DRONED
    OR A TWERP MCARTNEY KNOW TONY BLAIRS AN INSIDE JOB OR BOHEEMIAN GROVE TWERPS AND JONESES
    AND SOME CRAWFORDS AND FORD BUSHES BLACKWATERS BELL NIXONS BLACK COPTERS!
    DARK HORSES AND TROJANS
    MOJAVE AND TOP ONE PERCENT PROCTORS!

    SOME JOPLIN GOT JIMI AND THAT
    ZIET AND ZEET DISGUST AND YA GET YO AMERICA IDOL YOGURT JONES!

    AND RAM UP MONTELL OR WILIAMS MUENSTER INTEL ANUL BRAIN CHIP BERLIN SILICON CODER BOHEEMAIN GROVE UBER FUROR OBER BLOWN CRITICAL MASS
    OFF SHORE BLACK HOLE
    SPOCK !

    SCHRODERS TREASON ON SCREEN CAPTAIN!

    NASA!
    AH HA DARPA@!@

    LUCY KOBI ASHI BUGGER NOMAD AND SATTELITE!

    WAGNER GOT FUROR ARBIET AND ZIET!

    INTEL ROMAN CLANDESTINE
    EXPOSED BY PLUTO THE DOG AND SUPER MAN!
    AND
    COASTAL OCEAN DE-SALINSERS
    COMBAT DROUGHT CONDITIONS THROUGH POSIEDAN RESEVOIRS OF LOGANS RUN
    DEEP ATLANTIS
    SOONER THAN OKLAHOMA TEXAS COMBINED DUST BOWLS FOREVER!

    MORE THAN READOUTS ON DREADNAUTS OF KYOTO SUMMIT DROUGHT COMPUTERS!

    SOME INTELS JANITOR
    GOT YO ALL DEPENDIN ON SNOWDEN EXPOSED
    SPEED RACER SOME WACKY RACERS RACER X
    AND SPACE GHOST@

    NOT ERASURE HEAD!

    SPENCER DAVIS ONE FOUR TRACK I'M A MAN
    I OWN!

    BY ANY OLD LONDON RECORDS
    SNOWDEN
    EXPOSED

    THE END!

    JIM MORRISON!

    ^REPOP^

    SONG CREDITS:

    THEE INSIDE MAN
    MAHAT MA GHANDI!
    RAGNI HAIR
    EBB NITZER
    HEADGOD
    Treble and Clef!
    4 -10-10-4
    RECORDS STREETLIGHT!

    ROAD AND ICE TRUCKERS!
    THE MACHINE TIME MACHINE!
    TODAY FRESH FRESH TODAY !
    THE CYRKLE ,TYMES, THE THE
    BOURDON ERIC GETS WARHOL!

    GIANT GENTLE
    AND TIME!

    AND I GET ROLLING STONE CULT OF DRONES EXPOSED
    OFF THE WALL!

    WIRE TAP & SPINAL TAP! AND BUGGERY NIXON
    ALSO GOT TIME MAGAZINE!

    THE SIXTH SENSE!
    AND AUDREY HEPBURN ON A PHONE ON TIME!
    FOR
    TEN CENTS!

    NOTE: YOUR NOT THE ONLY ONE TERRESTRIAL THAT GOT THIS!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    yo whammy mammy zappa jimi joplin jones!, 19 May 2015 @ 4:17am

    I AM GREEN HORNET

    I GOT YO WAMMO TUPAC

    BRAIN CHIP YO YO!
    FEE FIE FO FUM SEMPER

    PHI I'M ON POINT!

    SCOTT WALKER BANNED

    POTATOES!

    SO DEVO BOLO X RAY RAY

    VISION !
    ANY PINS AND NAPALM STICKS TOO

    KIDS YO JUNKEY

    HINCKLEY INTEL SAD SACK HONKEY YO NOT NO
    GENERALS OR DRILL

    SARGENTS!

    WITH ANY Google Telletubby union 76

    MANY MORE Shrews !

    B.P. Boheemian Code

    Blown!

    WHITE ROSE
    HELD DOWN ANY RESISTANCE

    ON ANY FREE SPEECH FORM!

    SOROS Hollerith I.B.M.
    FUROR DICTO PHONE!

    AND I WHITE WASH YO ALL

    TOO RUSH TOM SAWYER!

    APPLE OR INTEL SILICON

    Disc Drive THULE HANUBU!

    I GOT HIGH STEPPER ANY

    TECH POSITION AND THATS

    NOT ALL !
    MIND CONTROL IS THAT

    SERVED ARBIET ZIET

    BERLIN CODE SILICON

    AMAZON OLIVER STONE

    OR CIRRUS WILLIAM TELL

    BOHEEMIAN AUSHWITZ

    BONUS PIZZA SATTELITE

    NASA BUGGERY ALL OVER

    MA BELLE AND VIA INTEL ?

    MALAYSIAN OFFSHORE

    TELLETUBBYS ALSO !?
    NAFFTA CRASS DARPA AND

    HENDERSON GETS NASA !?

    With soros fiat coupons for

    Grey Skull Poop ON!

    AND CHECK OUT MILTON

    THE MUENSTER
    Rome OR Rammstien

    GERMAN FUROR STAZI

    BENZIEN POWERED

    Drones!?
    AND ALL OF THESE

    GASOLINE POWERED

    DRONES!

    YO HUBBLE SCOPE GOT

    YOUR PLUTO ANAHIEM

    CODE EXPOSED TOO

    BELKAN STAZI AND

    ROMAN AUSTRIAN ALP

    Matterhorn SNOWDEN

    EASTWOOD EIGER EXPOSED YO !

    ALPINE NOSTRO BONER

    N.S.A. BUGGER PHONE INTEL

    NIXON ON HARRIS BUGGER

    ANY PHONES JONES

    WATERGATE ON!

    CHANNEL FIVE!

    LATE
    NITE CARSON MADONNA
    OR THEODORE ROOSEVELT

    INVESTIGATED TOO THE

    DIME!

    BEYOND HITLERS DEAD

    NEW YORK TIMES!

    NOW P.B.S. DRONE

    THREAT ON THEE

    AMERICAN PUBLIC
    VIA C.N.N. TED TURNER ANDY COOPER BOHEEMIAN GROVE ALICE COOPER SLASH ALL NAZZ
    GETS NAZI KNOW!

    BILLION DOLLAR BENZIEN OR GASOLINE BABY STAZI TELLETUBBY DRONES !

    I'M GONNA OWN THAT
    COOKIE MONSTERZ

    DAMAGE DONE
    BAGISIM & BAG !

    ALSO EXPOSED SAMBO

    TELLETUBBY NORDIC

    HOWARD JOHNSONS

    BALTIC SEA REAGEN
    OR CLINTON OFFSHORE

    INTEL NAFFTA AND ARBIET

    GATE SAUDI OPEC !

    AMAZON REMOTE DRONE ONE POUND C-4 AND A CAP!
    CRASH LANDING JIMI HENDRIX!

    HIT EXPLOSION!
    DEAD DICK CLARK
    RICHARD CLARK 9-11!

    MOST Any Goon GOT Hitler,
    PRE MADONNA FREE

    SPEECH FORM ARBIET AND

    ZIET!

    DARWIN AND THULE FUROR

    LANGUAGE SPRANGLE AND

    ORWELL THEN DUMB DOWN

    & DANGLE!

    Turns out he was the

    FUROR AND Father of

    Drones,
    ADOLPH HITLER !

    IS THAT YOU MADONNA

    ARGENTINA EVA PERONE
    YOU CAN EAT FUROR

    CRASS
    THULE
    HILLER
    OR HIMMLER
    RELGION
    KAISER
    BELKAN
    FUROR
    VATICAN
    CAKE!

    More primitive but then that

    was the best
    AN GRIFF EXPOSED ROMAN

    NOMAD HANUBU CULT

    ONLY RATZI SWISS

    CANNIBAL PREDATOR

    PROVEN RACIST

    PATHAGRIS Technology of

    Its Cult FUROR HOOK NOSE

    U BOAT Belkan Days...

    Only Peter Sellers Gestapos

    Knows!
    STEVE MARTIN CHARLIE

    CHAPLIN!
    JACK COUSTEAU AND

    CARPO!

    The V-1 were nothing more

    Than pilotless Drones,
    ONLY YAMOGOTO AND

    YOKO ONO AND DEAD

    BRANDO KNOW!

    Only perry mason knew

    they were sent to kill

    anyone and everyone
    ....in that case everyone

    was AMAZON

    "collateral damage"
    And KINDLE intended

    WILLIAM TELL APPLE GOT

    Target SNOWDEN INTEL AT

    AMAZON INTEL CULT

    DRONE KRAFTWERK A

    MODEL THULE RATZI

    PEENAMUNDE CODE AND

    ZIBITS
    2001 TWIN TOWERS
    IN The same time. WITHIN

    ANY CENTURY
    ..seems in that regard we're

    better than
    ADOLPH Hitler NOT!

    ONLY The Same clover!
    A bootleg moon rover

    idea....murder at a distance

    and murder of innocent

    people whether you planned

    to or not....NASA and just

    like ADOLPH Hitler,
    WIEMAR HOOK NOSE

    EXPOSED!

    SO THOSE SO ARBIET

    GATED BILL GATES AND

    OFF SHORE INTEL NAFFTA

    SOME CALLED SHAKE

    SPEAR LANGAUGE ON

    MARS ORSONS RACISTS

    CALLED RACISTS TOO
    HAWKIN
    EARTH
    MANKIND!

    ALSO DEFINED AS DONT

    ASK DONT TELL
    WAR CRIMINALS PROVEN

    KAISERS AND INDIFFERENT

    IN JUST CEASER STUCKA

    STUCK IN ROMAN

    CONCENTRATION PROVEN

    ARBIET ZIET ROMAN ADD

    DEATH CAMP ARBIET ZIET
    RATZI CYANIDE
    CAP PASTORS
    GET RAM INTEL BRAIN

    CHIP UP ANUL TOO

    BRAIN~!

    CONTACT GRAVITY OR

    MISSION IMPOSSIBLE
    EXPOSED IN CRASS

    ROMAN BELKAN THULE

    DRONE THREAT RELIGION!

    AND WE ALL started out as

    Innocent BORN People
    Whom all would have

    preferred to get on with

    their lives!
    ALSO raise their al jaffey

    any chaplin families...

    They are not the
    "mad Islamists"
    OR STAZI Bacon Cult Drone

    Nose OF Pigs And Rats!

    Also no government makes

    them out to be are the

    insane ones!

    And while we!~
    The Logans Runners
    Have our Families and

    SILICON BRAIN CHIPPED

    Children Safely Tucked Mad

    Max Away AND LETS

    PRETEND?
    DEFLATE FOOTBALL !
    OPERATION!

    AND DONT ASK DONT TELL

    ONLY
    CLINTONS
    ORDERS!?

    SECRET
    OBAMA
    MEETINGS
    AND
    FOR These pigs and rats

    still find it necessary to

    range the world killing

    innocent people...only now

    they kaiser proven only rat

    brained chipped your future

    almost creating fabricating

    people clones will actually

    bomb our ships in a Gulf of

    Tonkin...That was then the

    President's word alone that

    we had been attacked was

    enough...but today is today

    and just saying we have

    been attacked won't

    do....pearl harbor again

    today we need someone to

    ROBOT DRONE attack

    us...and that has been our

    BERLIN KAISER POLICY

    C.N.N. PUBLIC FUROR

    DRONE THREAT
    CODE ASK WEATHER MAN

    BOB DYLAN!
    MARINE OCEAN

    DESALINISERS FROM

    ATLANTIS TAXES CAPTAIN

    NEMOS!
    SAVED A PLANET DROUGHT
    FROM OCEAN SPOUTS!

    Ever since WOODSTOCK

    ONE!
    IRON BUTTERFLY
    Steppenwolf!


    AND In the end WOLF Hitler

    turned out to be the

    Greatest enemy any people

    ever had!

    Destroy any country that

    anyone ever had...
    And the same fate awaits

    us....
    You can't escape this kind

    of Karma...Dogma!

    YA just can't
    Suge knight run over any

    Dog OR WEB SITE BAN

    ANY FREE SPEECH YOU

    LIKE !

    YAHOO GOOGLE BOOK

    FACE ALL THESE ARE

    DREADNAUTS!
    ZHIEGHIESTED BUGGERS
    OR KUBRICK OR ZOETROPE

    EXPOSED!

    TAKE ON PHIL K. DICK!

    NIBIRU AND HANUBU
    BRADBURY ON YOUR LEFT

    RIGHT AND CENTER !

    EXPOSED GREEN SCREEN
    INTEL GOT YO PHONE!

    NO ONE MUST KNOW WHAT

    YOU SEE AND HEAR!

    DO YOU WANT TOO KNOW

    A SECRET DAVE HULL A

    TICK!
    K.R.L.A. FIFTH BEATLE!?

    AND I AM WOLF MAN JACK!

    Zonder Commandoe Krause

    ALL YOU HOMOS!

    Even intel matrix Dragon
    ON SNOWDEN!

    BANTAM NUEROMANCER

    BUGGER YO HOUSE HARRIS

    BUGGER YO NIXON BLUE

    NUTS!
    DEFLATE YO QUEER TRANS

    BALLS PLAY JOHN JOLMSE

    DYKE JOHN BOEHNER

    PROVOS PORNOS & DONT

    ASK DONT TELL JONES!

    ONLY CLINTONS KNOW
    REAGEN MERKEL MIEN

    KAISER TUCHLER OBER

    KOEHLER FUROR?

    MIEN SPIELBERG E.T.

    STEVEN SPIELBERG

    WENNER BLOOMBERG

    MILDENSTIEN
    BLADE RUNNER BLOMBERG

    S.S. OR KAISER ZIBITS S.A.
    AMAZON DRONE AN GRIFF

    HENDERSON
    NURNBERG ZONDER

    COMMANDOES?

    I GOT
    ALIAS SMITH AND JONES
    HERALD EXAMINER GONE

    BUGGER BLUES SOME B.B.

    KING AL CAPONE
    WILD WEST AND NAT KING

    COLE
    JOURNEY TOO THE CENTER

    OF THE EARTH
    ALSO ROB CONRAD DEAD
    BABA BLACK SHEEP

    MOTHERS AND DYNAMOE !
    SO
    I OWN RE NAMED

    GRHAMINS VIA TONTO

    LONE RANGER AND SINCE

    HOPI DINO MAURO ROCKY

    RANGER OFFECHUS AND

    SERIES ONE !

    SILICON CHIP BIENZENE

    OR GASOLINE CULT FUROR

    DRONE!

    MIND CONTROL BLINKY!
    GOT SILICON TRON BRAIN

    CHIP ARBIET AND ZIET!

    AND THATS BLINKY TOM

    DOLE RIP CHORD

    HOLLYWOOD EVIN RUDE

    ALEX JONES KNOWS!
    I WALK THE LINE JOHNNY

    CASH!

    NIXON ANUL BUGGERY

    AND ANY JONES !?
    PORNO FOR PYROS
    TRIUMPH MOTOR CYCLES

    XENER DIODES ALSO !

    AND MARVIN GAYE IS

    GONE ALSO JOHN LENNON

    OR SALLY MANSFIELD
    ALMOST GOT DRONED OR

    BOMBED BY CULT OF

    FUROR DRONES!

    ALL OF ANTWERP DRONED
    OR A TWERP MCARTNEY

    KNOW TONY BLAIRS AN

    INSIDE JOB OR BOHEEMIAN

    GROVE TWERPS AND

    JONESES
    AND SOME CRAWFORDS

    AND FORD BUSHES

    BLACKWATERS BELL

    NIXONS BLACK COPTERS!
    DARK HORSES AND

    TROJANS
    MOJAVE AND TOP ONE

    PERCENT PROCTORS!

    SOME JOPLIN GOT JIMI

    AND THAT
    ZIET AND ZEET DISGUST

    AND YA GET YO AMERICA

    IDOL YOGURT JONES!

    AND RAM UP MONTELL OR

    WILIAMS MUENSTER INTEL

    ANUL BRAIN CHIP BERLIN

    SILICON CODER

    BOHEEMAIN GROVE UBER

    FUROR OBER BLOWN

    CRITICAL MASS
    OFF SHORE BLACK HOLE
    SPOCK !

    SCHRODERS TREASON ON

    SCREEN CAPTAIN!

    NASA!
    AH HA DARPA@!@

    LUCY KOBI ASHI BUGGER

    NOMAD AND SATTELITE!

    WAGNER GOT FUROR

    ARBIET AND ZIET!

    INTEL ROMAN

    CLANDESTINE
    EXPOSED BY PLUTO THE

    DOG AND SUPER MAN!
    AND
    COASTAL OCEAN

    DE-SALINSERS
    COMBAT DROUGHT

    CONDITIONS THROUGH

    POSIEDAN RESEVOIRS OF

    LOGANS RUN
    DEEP ATLANTIS
    SOONER THAN OKLAHOMA

    TEXAS COMBINED DUST

    BOWLS FOREVER!

    MORE THAN READOUTS ON

    DREADNAUTS OF KYOTO

    SUMMIT DROUGHT

    COMPUTERS!

    SOME INTELS JANITOR
    GOT YO ALL DEPENDIN ON

    SNOWDEN EXPOSED
    SPEED RACER SOME

    WACKY RACERS RACER X
    AND SPACE GHOST@

    NOT ERASURE HEAD!

    SPENCER DAVIS ONE FOUR

    TRACK I'M A MAN
    I OWN!

    BY ANY OLD LONDON

    RECORDS
    SNOWDEN
    EXPOSED

    THE END!

    JIM MORRISON!

    ^REPOP^

    SONG CREDITS:

    THEE INSIDE MAN
    MAHAT MA GHANDI!
    RAGNI HAIR
    EBB NITZER
    HEADGOD
    Treble and Clef!
    4 -10-10-4
    RECORDS STREETLIGHT!

    ROAD AND ICE

    TRUCKERS!
    THE MACHINE TIME

    MACHINE!
    TODAY FRESH FRESH

    TODAY !
    THE CYRKLE ,TYMES,

    THE THE
    BOURDON ERIC GETS

    WARHOL!

    GIANT GENTLE
    AND TIME!

    AND I GET ROLLING

    STONE CULT OF DRONES

    EXPOSED
    OFF THE WALL!

    WIRE TAP & SPINAL TAP!

    AND BUGGERY NIXON
    ALSO GOT TIME

    MAGAZINE!

    THE SIXTH SENSE!
    AND AUDREY HEPBURN

    ON A PHONE ON TIME!
    FOR
    TEN CENTS!

    NOTE: YOUR NOT THE

    ONLY TERRESTRIALS

    THAT GOT THIS!


    ANY SUPERMAN ALWAYS LEAVES TWO COPYS!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]


Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Use markdown for basic formatting. HTML is no longer supported.
  Save me a cookie
Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Shop Now: I Invented Email
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads

Close

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.