Back in the summer of 2008, we wrote about the bizarre move by the FBI to arrest Kevin Cogill
, at gunpoint, for having posted a bunch of tracks from the as-yet-unreleased Guns 'N Roses album, Chinese Democracy
. Of course, as pretty much everyone knew, GNR (actually, Axl Rose) had been working on that album for over a decade, pretty much refusing to ever release it. It was the vaporware of the music industry. As we noted at the time, pretty much every album eventually gets leaked, and it tends to get those albums more attention. In fact, many labels purposely leak albums. Cogill received the album via someone who emailed him the tracks, he put them up on his music website, Antiquiet, in a streaming-only
format (so no downloading), and took them down about an hour later after the website got slammed with traffic.
And for that, you have a bunch of FBI agents show up at your door pointing guns at you? We couldn't understand why the FBI would be wasting taxpayer
money on this at all. At best, it seemed like it should have been a civil matter for Universal Music to take up.
Either way, as we noted, the leak (and subsequent arrest) appeared to actually act as a huge marketing boost
for the album's eventual release, and as the details of the criminal case against Cogill fell apart, prosecutors dropped the felony charges altogether, and eventually Cogill agreed to a plea deal
, which was two months of house arrest and that he would do a public service announcement (PSA) for the RIAA. And then the RIAA never made him
do the PSA, so instead he gave an interview talking about how people involved in file sharing can "get F'd in the A" by the RIAA.
It's been quite a few years since then... and Cogill -- statute of limitations now well behind him -- has decided to tell the full story of what happened
. It's worth reading, as you learn about the typical insanity of the FBI completely overreacting, being led around by the nose by RIAA and Universal Music people who were simply misleading or lying about things -- yet another crazy story of massive overreaction by the industry to anything that seems like "piracy." In fact, as the report notes, the "leak" (which again, was about an hour's worth of streaming on a website) helped get lots of attention for the album, and Universal Music actually used the hype from the leak to sign a massive deal with Best Buy to presell 1.3 million albums. In other words, no harm done by the leak... at all.
You should read the full account, but I wanted to call out a few key sections. Cogill was officially charged under 17 USC 506(a)(1)(c)
, which is a special tidbit in the law that provides criminal penalties for leaking something that hasn't been released yet (that's how the FBI could pretend this was a serious criminal matter). But, Cogill and his lawyer had a rather useful response in their back pocket:
For that statute to be applicable, the work would need to be demonstrably headed towards a public release, and for it to apply to me, the court would have to prove that I had reason to believe that it was in fact being prepared for commercial distribution. In other words, the US government would have to prove, in court, that Chinese Democracy was really coming. And no one at the RIAA or the label had informed the government that these songs had been lying around for 14 years. Only that they had cost $12 million. The government would soon come to realize the RIAA had given them a pretty shitty case.
Remember, at the time, this was the album that seemed to be perpetually postponed with no plans of release. Turns out, that kind of sunk the case -- but the FBI, as it's done way too often, simply took the word of the entertainment industry guys on things that turned out to be untrue (this is neither the first nor the last time that the RIAA has led the DOJ
on a wild goose chase, which the DOJ only discovered way too late). In fact, Cogill notes that once things got going, the situation was basically the DOJ trying to figure out how to extricate themselves from the disaster they'd gotten themselves into by buying the bullshit story the RIAA gave them.
David [Kaloyanides, Cogill's lawyer] made me feel invincible. He knocked out any talk of a felony copyright charge in the first round, and the entire battle from there on out became, more or less, a matter of the US government trying to save face by figuring out how to slap me with a misdemeanor. They had set out to string my body up for all would-be music pirates, but David and I shared a resentment for the fact that the government of this country that we love so much let a bunch of lobbyists do their homework for them. We were out to make a nuanced point about our disagreement with Johnny Law.
There are also a number of other bizarre asides, including wild goose chases from random other fans, including one who claimed to also have a copy of the album. Oh, and then there was this tidbit, which again undermined the case:
There was the copy of Chinese Democracy on 12″ vinyl that I bought at Amoeba Records in San Francisco, a bootleg. After the RIAA’s spotty discovery, it was a revelation to the government that any of these tracks had leaked before in any form. Let alone the facts that, first, not only were most of these tracks “out there” in some form for years, but second, that all but a couple could be casually purchased in a record store, here in our own backyard, far from a hot commodity or some underground secret.
And, as mentioned before, Universal's deal with Best Buy:
Chinese Democracy was finally released on November 23rd, 2008, exclusively at Best Buy, about 20 weeks after my leaks. That’s from no concrete plans, to going up on shelves. Pretty quickly, especially if we’re talking about the poster child for album delays. What did we know about that deal? Best Buy paid a large up front sum for the exclusive, at least seven figures, by all reports. We obtained evidence showing that the value of that exclusive was determined largely by the media hype my leaks had created. UMG had shown Best Buy charts of Google traffic for Chinese Democracy that started spiking in June, and was riding high. The iron was hot, so to speak. And before Best Buy got on board, the only heat source was the fire under my ass.
But there's also this: Cogill notes that he's never been in the "leaking" business, but rather a journalistic one. He covers the music industry and had written about how the album would leak, because all albums leak -- and because of that, someone sent him the leak. He posted about it from a journalistic standpoint, rather than because of any attempt to "leak" the album. And, from his account, for a while he didn't seem to realize just how insane the laws, law enforcement and our legal system are. Combine that with a clueless bunch of FBI agents easily pushed around by the RIAA, and you get this kind of insanity. The fact that Cogill had told the FBI repeatedly beforehand that if they wanted to arrest him to let him know and he'd show up... and they still showed up with guns drawn is just part of the insanity that happens when you have the kind of ridiculous claims from the RIAA, MPAA and the like about how these leaks are "destroying" their business... at the same time they're using them to their own advantage. Even the judge in the case couldn't understand what happened:
The judge was suprised that they arrested me at gunpoint. He actually said, “I don’t understand why this wasn’t a summons case, like I recommended.”
At some point, perhaps the folks at the DOJ are going to finally realize that when the MPAA and RIAA tell them crazy stories about "piracy" that they're exaggerated beyond belief. Until then, every time we hear about the stories where they screwed up royally -- such as with Cogill or Dajaz1 or Rojadirecta or Megaupload -- they just look completely clueless.