Over the past few months, we covered the bizarre trial concerning Rahinah Ibrahim
and her attempt to get off the no fly list. In January, there was an indication that the court had ordered her removed
from the list, but without details. In February, a redacted
version of the ruling revealed that the whole mess was because an FBI agent read the instructions wrong
on a form and accidentally placed her on the no fly list, though we noted that some of the redactions were quite odd
However, earlier this week, the court finally released the unredacted version
, and we'll have a few things to say about the choice of redactions in a later post. But first, there were three main "reveals" from the newly unredacted version. The first
is that Ibrahim was actually put on multiple lists by mistake (and never for any clear reason) and was actually dropped from the no fly
list years ago (though the other lists created the same effective problem in barring her from being allowed to travel to the US). The second
is that the US government has a "secret exception"
to the requirement that there be "reasonable suspicion" to put someone in various terrorist databases, and that secret exception was later used on Ibrahim. And third
, that despite the implications from the redacted versions, the fully unredacted ruling shows that Ibrahim is still likely blocked from coming to the US for separate undisclosed reasons
, even though the government fully admits that she is no threat. All of these things were hidden by the redacted version.
Let's start with the first issue -- that Ibrahim was not just on the no fly list, but multiple other lists and databases. This all stemmed (at first) from that initial mistake from FBI Agent Kevin Michael Kelley. The yellow highlighted portions on this form were redacted in the original version, but now they're public:
As you can see, Agent Kelley was supposed to be checking which lists NOT to put Ibrahim on, and did the reverse of what he intended to do, meaning that she got placed on both the no fly list and
the Interagency Border Information System (IBIS). In the redacted version, all mentions of IBIS were redacted. Note that, from this, Kelley did
intend to put her on the Selectee list. Later, an unredacted portion reveals that at the time she was removed from that selectee list, she was added
to the lists the US gives to Australia and Canada (TACTICS and TUSCAN -- though no reason for that was ever provided). The court also notes that all the way back in 2006, a government agent requested that Ibrahim be removed from all lists, and she was removed from some, but not the others.
However -- and here's where it gets really
sketchy -- the government started putting her back into the terrorist screening database (TSDB). She was added back in 2007... and then removed three months later, for no clear reason. But then, in 2009 she was added back to the TSDB "pursuant to a secret exception to the reasonable suspicion standard."
Let's repeat that. In order to be put into the TSDB, the government is required to show a "reasonable suspicion" that the person is a terrorist. However, what this court ruling has revealed is that there is an unexplained secret exception
that allows people to be placed on the terrorist screening database even if there's no reasonable suspicion
, and the government used that secret exception
to put Ibrahim back on the list.
Later in the ruling it notes that the terrorist screening center knows Ibrahim is not a terrorist threat. This line was revealed back in February:
The TSC has determined that Dr. Ibrahim does not currently meet the reasonable
suspicion standard for inclusion in the TSDB.
However, the next
two sentences were redacted until now:
She, however, remains in the TSDB pursuant to a classified and secret exception to the reasonable suspicion standard. Again, both the reasonable suspicion standard and the secret exception are self-imposed processes and procedures within the
The ruling also makes it clear that Ibrahim has not been on the actual no fly list (even if she is on other lists) since 2005, and that she should be told this (and, indeed, to comply with the law, the government has now told her solely that she's not on the "no fly" list
and hasn't been since 2005). It also tells the government to search for all traces of her being on all such lists
and correct all of those that are connected to Agent Kelley's initial mistake
. However, it's not at all clear if this applies to the later additions to the TSDB, which was done for this secret and undisclosed exception, and might not
be directly because of Agent Kelley's mistake (though, potentially is indirectly because of that). In fact, a different unredacted section now says that the reasons why Ibrahim was denied a visa (which were revealed to the court in a classified manner) were valid
, and thus it appears that Ibrahim will still be denied visas in the future (unredacted portions underlined) -- and, indeed, as we explain below that has already happened:
The Court has read the relevant classified information, under seal and ex parte, that led to
the visa denials. That classified information, if accurate, warranted denial of the visa under
Section 212(a)(3)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(3)(B). (That
information was different from the 2004 mistaken nomination by Agent Kelley.) Therefore, under
the state secrets privilege, any challenge to the visa denials in 2009 and 2013 must be denied
Thus, it appears that while Ibrahim has been told she's been taken off the no fly list (and has been for nearly ten years), she's still not going to be able to travel to the US, because she's still in the TSDB for an unrevealed secret reason -- even though everyone admits she's not a threat. And, indeed, Ibrahim tried to apply for a visa to the US on Monday and was denied
(with the apparent reason -- if you read between the lines -- being that she is related to someone "engaged in a terrorist activity.")
Either way, what sort of country is this where there's a secret exception
to "reasonable suspicion" that will put you on a set of secret lists
that get you treated like a terrorist for wanting to travel?