Japanese Academics Issue The Tamest 'Emergency' Statement Over Proposed Copyright Amendment

from the take-a-breath dept

Recently, we discussed a proposed change to Japanese copyright law that would make literally all downloading of copyrighted material a criminal matter, rather than a civil one. This change would be fairly bonkers for an entire host of reasons. It has the potential to clog up the criminal courts with the same kind of minor copyright infringement cases that clog up America's civil courts. It would put a decisive chill on the sharing culture that brought the internet to its current state to begin with. And it would further the culture of ownership and protectionism already far too common across the globe.

And, as states an "emergency statement" issued by nearly a hundred Japanese academics, it would possibly criminalize the kind of personal copying that facilitates research, education, and personal growth.

In an ‘Emergency Statement’ signed by 87 academics, researchers, lawyers, and other experts, the government is urged to think again about the scope of the proposed legislation. Under the current proposals, the group believes that private copying could be rendered illegal, even to the extent of outlawing screenshots for private use.

“We believe that the limitation on the right of reproduction for private use purposes has the function of restricting the freedom of information gathering in the private domain. It is a legal foundation that supports the intellectual and cultural activities of individuals, and even Japanese industry,” the signatories write.

The group believes that the proposed legislation has been rushed through in a very short time (five meetings in three months), without carefully considering the consequences. They want the authorities to think again, to protect the public interest.

It's as timid a statement as could be offered. And it's one that essentially amounts to, "Whoa, guys, take a breath, because you don't know what you're about to do." Given the timeline on which this has occurred, it's a wholly reasonable request as well, given the enormous stake the public has and its nearly complete lack of a seat at the legislative table. The chill on both expression and research that this cluster-bomb law would have can't really be overstated, as the kind of personal copying that it would seek to criminalize has become essential to both.

And, to be clear, these academics aren't exactly against enforcing copyright laws generally, either.

Importantly, those calling for the proposals to be considered more closely appear to be broadly in favor of tightening up the law to protect rightsholders. However, there are serious concerns over the potential for collateral damage when even snippets of text could be criminalized.

To that end, they suggest amendments to the proposals to mandate that it’s only a crime to reproduce copyright works when the act causes real financial damage to content owners, in the case of those who pirate whole movies, music, manga publications, books, and so on.

If you're looking for a silver lining in all of this, perhaps one can be found in this being a perfect litmus test for how government that bows to moneyed interests will react to the most modest of requests against those interests. In other words, the academics in this case are essentially asking that the law eventually do only 90% of what it originally aimed to do.

If the Japanese government can't be bothered to take even that request seriously, then perhaps the public should give up on it entirely.

Filed Under: copyright, criminal copyright, japan

Reader Comments

The First Word

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. icon
    Stephen T. Stone (profile), 21 Feb 2019 @ 11:28pm

    Re: Re: Re: Re:

    The tone of posters here like "we've already explained this to you" is ridiculously haughty, presuming nonexistent intellectual superiority.

    It’s also the truth. I am among several other commenters, regular or otherwise, who have explained simple points of argument to you time and time again, only to watch as you intentionally ignore those explanations and act as if you never saw them. If you feel insulted by me or anyone else telling you that “we’ve already explained this to you”, that sucks for you. But a truth being harsh does not stop it from being the truth.

    Pirates have forced the hands of governments by stealing entire works. If you don't like that they have indirectly caused all these problems, you should take that up with them.

    I will take it up with governments who seek to punish and restrict lawful activities and creative works by tightening copyright laws, since their actions will not reduce or wipe out piracy by any significant margin.

    Anyone who came here to claim losses to piracy would just be ignored or called a liar.

    If someone claims losses that do not exist — potential losses are not actual losses — they should be ignored. If someone claims losses and offers no proof of those losses, they should be called a liar until they can offer said proof.

    their work is important enough to steal, they actually make things, rather than take them

    Copyright infringers such as Jim Sterling and Lindsay Ellis make video essays. Would you call what they do “stealing”?

    The more people are sympathetic to piracy, the more draconian the remedies are going to be.

    I sympathize not with “pirates”, but with the legit customers who face undue burdens from copyright restriction systems such as DRM that “pirates” do not face. After all, if a DRM server for a specific videogame goes down, a “pirate” can still play that game because their version lacks that restriction, but the paying customer is shit out of luck.

    And if you push for draconian remedies to copyright infringement, best be careful of your own ass — because you never know if the punishment you set out will be visited upon you.

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter

Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Insider Shop - Show Your Support!

Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads


Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.