HideOnly 2 days left to get your copy of the CIA's declassified training game by backing CIA: Collect It All on Kickstarter »
HideOnly 2 days left to get your copy of the CIA's declassified training game by backing CIA: Collect It All on Kickstarter »

Highly-Dubious Spiritualist Making Highly-Dubious Claims Loses Highly-Dubious Defamation Lawsuit Against Critic

from the cool,-refreshing,-Trivedi-brand-'bottles-o'-bullshit' dept

Mahendra Trivedi is a hell of a guy. Just ask him.

Mahendra Trivedi is recognized throughout the world for the discovery of his unique ability to transmit an extremely powerful and all-encompassing form of energy. The revolutionary impact of this energy is called The Trivedi Effect® .

[You can tell it's an extra-special energy because it has a registered trademark.]

Trivedi can simply stand near a bottle of water, transfer some of his powerful energy, and sell this bottled water to you at a presumably healthy markup. Among other things, the energized water can supposedly go full Lazarus on your flora.

But that's not all. Not only can Trivedi energize stuff to make it do other stuff, he's also quite the human specimen.

Research done on various aspects of his physiology has confirmed unique differences in his body, such as variations in body temperature ranging between 95 and 68 degrees Fahrenheit. His breathing pattern shows minimal movement in his diaphragm (which is physically impossible). An MRI of his brain reveals that he has the largest pituitary fossa ever found in a healthy person known to date. More so, an EEG found that his brain is in an alpha state when he is simply "normal.“ According to modern medical science, Mahendra Trivedi‘s physiological conditions contradict everything we know about science, the human body and the power of consciousness.

"Contradicting everything we know about science" is a pretty good summation of Trivedi's goods and services. According to information gathered by the Skeptic's Dictionary, Trivedi has staked a claim to any number of miraculous actions.

...Mr. Trivedi began to ask why this energy is limited to humans. He felt that if this energy is real, it must work everywhere. It must enhance the abilities, properties, and productivity of crops; transform bacteria, viruses and fungi; convert cancer cells into non-cancer cells; and make metals, chemicals, and polymers stronger. Due to his skeptic nature, he started scientific research. With help from the most sophisticated technology available to science under controlled conditions; [sic] he began to discover the proven impact of this energy’s characteristics, behavior, limitations and abilities. He thought that if this energy could change the structure of an atom, then nothing was impossible for this energy. He has compiled a remarkable track record of success, including nearly 4,000 well-documented scientific studies on his ability to profoundly affect matter down to the level of the atom.

4,000 well-documented scientific studies? Who could argue with that? Well, anyone who wants to, apparently.

I am sorry to say that I have been unable to locate even one of these 4,000 studies that has been published in a reputable scientific journal. Many are published in predatory open access journals.

And, even under the complete lack of scrutiny provided by pay-for-play "scientific journals," the studies Trivedi claims back up his miracles have nothing approaching scientific methodology contained in them. One claiming Trivedi was able to introduce bacterial mutations simply by waving his hand over some Petri dishes is deftly summed up this way by a slightly more sympathetic blogger at "Integral World."

No attempt even to recognize, let alone engage with, these issues is made in the paper. It's basically just, this is what we found, believe it or not.

Nothing says "science" quite like the conclusion, "There's no explanation for this, so Trivedi must be a miracle worker."

This alone would make Trivedi a target of mockery and skepticism. Add to that the fact that he's faced multiple labor-related lawsuits alleging abusive behavior and you have a magnet for criticism. Unfortunately for St. Paul blogger Dennis Lang, Trivedi can't handle having his long string of dubious claims and equally-long string of abuse allegations discussed in public. Lang has been on the receiving end of two defamation lawsuits by Trivedi -- both targeting Lang's reporting on claims made by former employees of Trivedi's.

Trivedi did manage to obtain a default judgment against Lang back in 2012. The judgment has nothing to do with the merits of his case and everything to do with the inexplicable behavior of the judge awarding it. Here's Mike Moseby of Minnesota Lawyer recounting the leadup to Lang's most recent legal battle with Trivedi.

It may have come in 2013, when Lang received a call from another Trivedi-nemesis — the former partner of the organization’s current CEO. The caller informed him that a judge in Arizona had just entered a default verdict and Lang was officially $59 million in the red.

But the peak silliness may have come on June 14, 2013, when a local attorney working for Trivedi — Kelly Hadac of the St.Paul firm HDK — sought to enforce that $59 million default judgment in Minnesota.

Fortunately, the judge in Minnesota found this judgment award unbelievably ridiculous and refused to uphold it.

As she reviewed the paperwork, Ramsey County District Court Judge Margaret Marrinan expressed bafflement — both at the size of the judgment and the fact that there was no accompanying memorandum from the judge.

“It’s a fill in the blank kind of order, isn’t it?” she said. “I guess I’m rather appalled that a court would do that.” According to a transcript of the proceedings, at other points, Marrinan referred to “the incredible laxness of the judge” as “way out west” and “not the way I do business.”

The judgment was vacated for lack of jurisdiction. Undeterred, Trivedi sued Lang again, this time in Minnesota. The end result was even worse.

If you say you’re a guru who has performed thousands of medical miracles around the world, it’s harder to say in court that you’re a regular guy.

That’s one of the takeaways from Ramsey County District Judge Robert Awsumb’s ruling last week that dismissed Mahendra Trivedi’s defamation lawsuit against a St. Paul blogger, Dennis Lang.

Awsumb’s ruling is a welcome victory for the First Amendment, especially for the vast majority of writers who have no institution to protect them from well-funded legal attacks intended to silence them. The judge ruled that Trivedi was a “limited purpose public figure,” which opens him up to public criticism with a stronger shield from lawsuits.

Trivedi tried to argue that he was not a public figure. The court found this assertion ridiculous.

Despite the extraordinary nature of the powers and abilities claimed by Trivedi and the Trivedi Entities, Trivedi states that he is "not nationally or regionally famous in the United States or elsewhere in the world."

He further states:

Even within the field of alternative medicine or energy transmissions, I am very much unknown in the United States and the rest of world. When I speak to individuals concerning the Trivedi Effect, I have to introduce myself and explain the nature of the Trivedi Effect. Unless the individual has been introduced to me by another mutual contact, the individual has never heard of me or the Trivedi Entities before. This was especially true i n 2011 and 2012 when I had only been i n the United States for a few years.

Nonetheless, in 2014 Trivedi stipulated that he was a limited purpose public figure for purposes of a related defamation lawsuit in Pennsylvania. [Trivedi v. Slawecki] In fact, the court's decision in Trivedi v. Slawecki is very similar factually to this case and involves similar issues.

Yes, the same person who boasts of "performing 70,000 medical miracles around the world" and made his "debut" alongside Deepak Chopra insists he's not a public figure… even when he's claimed otherwise to further an earlier defamation lawsuit (that he lost).

The court also points out that the nature of Trivedi's "business" invites more justifiable criticism than, say, a real scientist using real science might.

The court does not intend to consider or evaluate the accuracy or validity of Trivedi's claims or abilities. Nonetheless, the claims of being Jesus-like or Einstein-like are, by their nature, controversial claims likely to be challenged or refuted. To be sure, debate was occurring both on the internet through the PurQi.com blog and by research professor Slawecki at Penn State, who had publicly posted her summary of Penn State research questioning Trivedi's purported abilities. These claims, along with the self-proclaimed 4,000 scientific studies and publications in "170 publications in leading international, peer-reviewed scientific journals" put Trivedi and his enterprise directly into the global marketplace of ideas, obviously intended to reach a broad audience and attract interest in Trivedi and his enterprise. These vast claims of his personal powers propelled Trivedi and his entities into the public arena to affirm, debate, question and challenge his assertions, and in so doing, his character and credibility.

There's your "voluntary injection" into the public debate. Point: Lang. And lawsuit dismissed.

As James Eli Shiffner of the Star Tribune points out, this win is everyone's win, whether it's long-established journalistic outlets or hobby bloggers performing their own investigative work.

The ability to criticize public figures is a bedrock of free speech. With some public figures calling for new restrictions on that right, Awsumb’s ruling sends a message that it’s not only big media organizations that will have the court’s backing.

And if Trivedi thought suing critics would make his dubious claims and alleged abuse fade from the public eye, he's finding out (repeatedly) that his common sense is no more finely honed than his scientific skills.


Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread


  • icon
    Mason Wheeler (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 2:11pm

    Wow, this judge is totally awsumb!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Ehud Gavron (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 2:24pm

    The Judge called it...

    Now THAT is an Awsumb Ruling!

    E

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    That Anonymous Coward (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 2:28pm

    Can we strap him to a drone and fly him over the Middle East so he can use his energy to fix it all?
    Please????

    Comeon, the idea is as good as his powers...

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Mark Wing, 17 Jun 2016 @ 2:56pm

    But science knows so little, and his pituitary is so large...

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    That One Guy (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 4:11pm

    So incredibly powerful, and yet so flawed...

    Able to heal so many ills, and yet completely unable to heal himself from the massive damage of Mean Words. Truly, it is his Achilles heel.

    The funniest thing to me is that if even a small fraction of his 'miraculous' claims were supported by actual science then he would get all the fame he could ever dream of, and wouldn't have to 'introduce' people and tell them how famous and impressive he was. That he instead sticks to making grandiose claims and 'scientific' journals that will publish anything presented to them says all you need to know about how well he thinks his claims would stand up to actual testing.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Namel3ss (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 5:33pm

    Allow me to introduce you two.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Namel3ss (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 5:33pm

    Allow me to introduce you two.

    Trivedi Effect, meet Streisand Effect!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    techflaws (profile), 17 Jun 2016 @ 10:05pm

    But that's not all. Not only can Trivedi energize stuff to make it do other stuff, he's also quite the human specimen.

    Yeah, that's propably what made him forgo the money he could easily have gotten from successfully taking on the James Randi challenge.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Lazarus Flora, 18 Jun 2016 @ 12:40am

    Anna grams

    Dirt Vermin Ahead
    Remind Tv Airhead
    Diarrhea Mid Vent
    Tv Marinade Hider
    Harridan Met Dive
    The Drama Diviner
    Area Mind Thrived
    Vitamin Ad Herder
    Dead, Vainer, Mirth
    Diehard Vain Term
    Mr Herniated Diva
    Dreamer Hit Divan
    Avid Earned Mirth

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Anonymous Coward, 18 Jun 2016 @ 2:59am

    "Highly-Dubious Spiritualist Making Highly-Dubious Claims"

    That would be as opposed to "Mildly-Dubious Spiritualist Making Mildly-Dubious Claims" or even "Entirely-Credible Spiritualist Making Entirely-Credible Claims"?

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Bergman (profile), 18 Jun 2016 @ 6:26am

    If the Trivedi Effect is truly unique

    Then why does it need to be trademarked?

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

    • identicon
      Techanon, 19 Jun 2016 @ 7:21am

      Re: If the Trivedi Effect is truly unique

      Because he doesn't want his miracle water be confused or associated with other miracle waters (like, for example: homeopathy)?

      reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

      • icon
        John Fenderson (profile), 19 Jun 2016 @ 10:43am

        Re: Re: If the Trivedi Effect is truly unique

        I love that comparison. Although homeopathy is clearly and provably complete nonsense, at least there is a some relationship to a real effect (an actual biologically active molecule was, in fact, near the water at one point).

        Trivedi water doesn't even have that much going for it.

        reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

      • identicon
        I.T. Guy, 20 Jun 2016 @ 7:38am

        Re: Re: If the Trivedi Effect is truly unique

        Trivedi "stole" Peter Popoff's schtick. Pete's water will bring you riches in the form of mysterious checks that God has sent to you. And yet, they shut Ms. Cleo down. "Call me now." LOL.

        reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Monday (profile), 18 Jun 2016 @ 7:55am

    Anybody remember "Balls On Chin" Butters???

    Big Fossa. Big Pituitary. Too easy.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2016 @ 9:37am

    Disney needs to sue this asshole out of existence in EVERY state, as he's quite clearly trying to claim he's the original jedi, complete with jedi mind tricks, the ability to leap forty foot vertically and shoot 'energy' from his hands - oh no, wait! that means he's a Sith and needs to be destroyed by throwing him into a nuclear reactor!

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2016 @ 11:27pm

    So this guy tried to say "I have a company named after the energy I generate named after me, thousands of articles claiming on how mysterious and all-powerful I am, tons of people at my beck and call managing my public image... and at the same time I am magically not a public figure so I can't be criticized, ever"?

    Whatever-level logic right there, this one...

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • icon
    Monday (profile), 20 Jun 2016 @ 9:09am

    Don't forget the remark, "We all have it." So it's kinda like DNA... hmm

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

  • identicon
    Dennis Lang, 7 Jun 2017 @ 7:49am

    Mahendra Trivedi v Lang at Court of Appeals 5/1/2017

    Just found this article. Much appreciation for following the story.
    It's still going on. Trivedi appealed the above ruling. The Appellate Court upheld Judge Awsumb's Order on all points except one. Trivedi was not considered a "public figure" concerning allegations he sexually preyed on his teenage female employees. The ruling has now been petitioned to the MN Supreme Court for review of that point.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]


Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Use markdown for basic formatting. HTML is no longer supported.
  Save me a cookie
Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Shop Now: Copying Is Not Theft
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads

Close

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.