'Anti-Propaganda' Ban Repealed, Freeing State Dept. To Direct Its Broadcasting Arm At American Citizens

from the 'our-top-pre-approved-story-tonight...' dept

The US government has a bit of a PR problem at the moment, thanks to Ed Snowden's leaks and a decade-plus of general antipathy towards its constituents' rights and liberties growing out of its War on Terror.

Fortunately, the government now has a chance to aim its official version of today's news at US citizens, thanks to the repeal of a so-called "anti-propaganda" law earlier this month.

For decades, a so-called anti-propaganda law prevented the U.S. government's mammoth broadcasting arm from delivering programming to American audiences. But on July 2, that came silently to an end with the implementation of a new reform passed in January. The result: an unleashing of thousands of hours per week of government-funded radio and TV programs for domestic U.S. consumption in a reform initially criticized as a green light for U.S. domestic propaganda efforts.
The Broadcast Board of Governors, which produces programming like the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe, has been prevented from aiming its programming at Americans since the 1970's when the Smith-Mundt Act (which authorized the State Dept. to communicate with foreign audiences via many methods, radio being one of them) was amended to prohibit domestic dissemination of the BBG's broadcasts. This was done to distance the State Department's efforts from the internal propaganda machine operated by the Soviet Union.

Now, the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012 (part of the National Defense Authorization Act) has repealed the domestic prohibition, allowing the government's broadcasting to be directed at/created for Americans for the first time in over 40 years.

BBG spokesperson Lynne Weil says these efforts aren't simply pro-government hype machines.
"They don't shy away from stories that don't shed the best light on the United States," she told The Cable. She pointed to the charters of VOA and RFE: "Our journalists provide what many people cannot get locally: uncensored news, responsible, discussion, and open debate."

A former U.S. government source with knowledge of the BBG says the organization is no Pravda, but it does advance U.S. interests in more subtle ways. In Somalia, for instance, VOA serves as counterprogramming to outlets peddling anti-American or jihadist sentiment. "Somalis have three options for news," the source said, "word of mouth, Al-Shabaab or VOA Somalia."
As Weil points out, this will bring a new level of transparency to the BBG as communicating to Americans is no longer prohibited. If nothing else, transcripts of BBG programming will be easier for Americans to get ahold of. A court ruled in 1998 that the limitations of the Smith-Mundt Act exempted the Voice of America from releasing transcripts in response to FOIA requests.

Another possible plus is the fact that the BBG will provide a free, "local" news source for immigrant populations.
The agency wants to reach diaspora communities, such as St. Paul Minnesota's significant Somali expat community. "Those people can get Al-Shabaab, they can get Russia Today, but they couldn't get access to their taxpayer-funded news sources like VOA Somalia," the source said.
These positives aside, the thought of a state-run news agency being allowed to direct its efforts at Americans is still uncomfortable. Despite claims of independence, it's hard to believe the source is 100% trustworthy when its stated purpose is to run flack for the State Department in foreign nations. (Of course, the mainstream media outlets haven't shown much reluctance to regurgitate talking points, which almost makes the BBG's efforts seem redundant.)

While the BBG may provide a less-biased source of news for many foreigners (or at least provide a different bias), the purpose of its broadcasts to its new American audience is less clear. The fact that the State Department is behind the effort doesn't do much to allay fears that the BBG will become a tool of domestic propaganda. The State Department's reaction to the leak of diplomatic correspondence by Wikileaks was to block its employees' access to the site (or any site containing the word "Wikileaks") and demand the digital documents be "returned." How will a state-run press react to developments like these? Will it be forced to play by the department's rules, no matter how illogical, or will it be able to deal with them in a more forthright manner?

In a time where the administration seems to be forced to play defense with increasing frequency, it's hard to believe it won't be willing to exploit this addition to its PR arsenal.

Hide this

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

Filed Under: domestic propaganda, propaganda, state department, us government, voice of america

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. icon
    drifter (profile), 23 Dec 2016 @ 11:10am

    media ownership

    Who Runs the Media?

    Viacom - Sumner Redstone, Chairman Emeritus, former CEO is Jewish
    Viacom - Philippe Dauman, President, CEO and Chairman is Jewish 
    Viacom - Shari Redstone, Vice-chairwoman isJewish
    Viacom - Owns BET, Nickelodeon, MTV, VH1, Logo TV, Comedy Central, Palladia, Spike, and Epix
    News Corp - Rupert Murdoch Exec Co-Chairman former CEO is a Zionist (some say he’s Jewish).
    News Corp - Owns The Times, The Sun, Dow Jones & Company, The Wall Street Journal
    News Corp - Owns HarperCollins, Fox Entertainment Group (owners of the 20th Century Fox film studio and the Fox Broadcasting Company)
    21st Century Fox - Rupert Murdoch Exec Co-Chairman former CEO
    Fox News - Rupert Murdoch
    Fox Entertainment Group - Rupert Murdoch
    News Corp - Rupert Murdoch Exec Chairman
    Walt Disney - Robert Iger President and CEO isJewish
    Walt Disney Motion Picture Group - Orin Aviv Pres of production is Jewish
    Comcast - Julian Brodsky Co-Fonder is Jewish
    Comcast - Ralph Roberts Co-Fonder is Jewish
    Comcast - Brian L. Roberts CEO and Chairmane isJewish
    Comcast - David L. Cohen Exec VP is Jewish
    Comcast - Stephen B. Burke Exec VP is Jewish
    CNN Worldwide - Jeff Zucker, President is Jewish
    CNBC - Mark Hoffman CEO and President isJewish
    NBC - Stephen B. Burke CEO is Jewish
    NBC - Robert Greenblatt Chairman is Jewish
    NBC - Jeff Gaspin Former Chairman is Jewish
    CNN Worldwide - Jeff Zucker, President is Jewish
    CBS - Leslie Moonves, President is Jewish
    CBS - Shari Redstone Vice-chairwoman is Jewish
    CBS - Sumner Redstone Chairman Emeritus
    CBS - Sumner Redstone, former owner is Jewish
    Vox - Ezra Klein, Editor-in-Cheif is Jewish
    Screw - Al Goldstein, Publisher and Pornographer is Jewish
    Variety - Steve Gaydos, Executive Editor is Jewish
    Variety - Peter Bart, Co-Editor-in-Chief is Jewish
    Chicago Tribune - Sam Zell, Owner is Jewish
    Los Angeles Times - Sam Zell, Owner is Jewish
    The New York Times- Ochs-Sulzberger family, majority shareholders are Jews
    The Washington Post - Donald E. Graham, CEO and Chaiman is Jewish
    Daily News - Mortimer Benjamin Zuckerman, Owner is Jewish
    The New York Post - Rupert Murdoch, Owner isJewish
    Wall Street Journal - Rupert Murdoch, Owner isJewish
    U.S. News and World Report - Mortimer Benjamin Zuckerman, Owner is Jewish
    DreamWorks - Stacy Snider, Co-chairman and CEO is Jewish
    DreamWorks - David Geffen, Co-chairman isJewish
    BBC Television - Danny Cohen, Director is Jewish
    MGM - Harry Sloan, Chairman and CEO is Jewish
    CW - Dawn Ostroff, President of Entertainment isJewish
    Warner Brothers - Barry M. Meyer, Chairman and CEO is Jewish
    Warner Brothers - Alan F. Horn, President and COO is Jewish
    Warner Brothers - Jeff Robinov, President of Productionis Jewish
    Warner Brothers - Martin Shafer, Chairman and CEO of
    Castle Rock Entertainment is Jewish
    Warner Brothers - Bruce Rosenblum, President of Television Group is Jewish
    Warner Brothers - Peter Rot, President of Television Production is Jewish
    Warner Independent Pictures - Polly Cohen President is Jewish
    Fox Filmed Entertainment - Thomas Rothman, Chairman and CEO is Jewish
    Sony Picture - Michael Lynton, Chairman and CEO is Jewish
    Regency Pictures - Arnon Milchan, Chairman isJewish
    USA Network - Toby Graff, Senior VP of Public Affairs is Jewish
    Showtime - Matthew C. Blank, Chairman and CEO is Jewish
    Showtime - Robert Greenblatt, President isJewish
    Universal Studios - Jeff Shells Chairman isJewish
    Universal Studios - Rowan Conn, CFO is Jewish
    Universal Studios - Adam Fogelson, Chairman isJewish
    Paramount Pictures - Brad Grey, CEO and Chairman is Jewish
    Paramount Pictures - Jesse L. Lasky, co-founder, a Jew
    Paramount Pictures - Adolph Zukor, co-founder, a Jew
    Paramount Vantage - John Lesher, Co-president is Jewish
    Paramount Vantage - Nick Meyer, Co-president isJewish
    RCA - Owns NBC - David Sarnoff Founder isJewish
    Tribune Company - Eddy W. Hartenstein, President and CEO is Jewish
    And the list goes on and on and on…

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter

Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Insider Shop - Show Your Support!

Essential Reading
Techdirt Insider Chat
Recent Stories

This site, like most other sites on the web, uses cookies. For more information, see our privacy policy. Got it

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.