Windows 8's Arbitrary App Certification Rules Could Block Skyrim And Other Huge Games

from the arbitrary-guidelines-are-the-best dept

We have already mentioned that some game developers were having a hard time accepting Windows 8 as a viable gaming platform. The primary concern is with Microsoft's insistence on walling off its Metro UI and accompanying Windows Store. When a distribution system is walled off, new restrictions come along that limit the type of content that can be made available. As application and game developers learn more about the restrictions Microsoft plans to implement, their concern is growing.

Take for instance the recent discovery that Microsoft plans to limit the games made available through its Windows Store and Metro UI. In a broader piece on what a closed Windows 8 platform means for developers, Casey Muratori highlights one of the strict and ultimately contradictory restrictions on game content. Using the 2011 Game of the Year, Skyrim, as a hypothetical Windows 8 candidate, Casey asks the question, would it be allowed on the Windows store and Metro UI.
Because no software can ship on this future platform without it going through the Windows Store, the team that built Skyrim would have to send it to Microsoft for certification. Then Microsoft would tell them if they could ship it.

Do you know what Microsoft's answer would be?

I do. It would be "no".

This is not speculative; it is certain. Skyrim is a game for adults. It has a PEGI rating of 18. If you read the Windows 8 app certification requirements you will find, in section 5.1:

"Your app must not contain adult content, and metadata must be appropriate for everyone. Apps with a rating over PEGI 16, ESRB MATURE, or that contain content that would warrant such a rating, are not allowed."

And that's the end of it. No Skyrim for the Windows Store, unless of course the developers go back and remove all the PEGI 18-rated content.
Unfortunately, Casey does not highlight the contradictory nature of this arbitrary rule -- what if a game has both an M rating by the ESRB and an 18 rating by PEGI, as Skyrim does. What will Microsoft do? Will it block the game entirely, region-restrict it to only ESRB regions or make an exception to its own rule and allow it for all the world? These are the kinds of questions that frustrate developers. Apple has had its fair share of arbitrary enforcement of content restrictions and you would think that Microsoft would at least attempt to learn from that example.

To further highlight the problem with this restriction, Casey lists four games that are in competition to be 2012's Game of the Year. Of those four games, none would be allowed on Windows 8 for the same reason, they got an ESRB M rating and a PEGI 18 rating. Microsoft has set itself up to exclude some of the best selling games of the future. Hardly a way to attract the support of developers.

Filed Under: certification, closed platforms, games, restrictions, windows
Companies: microsoft

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. icon
    E. Zachary Knight (profile), 19 Oct 2012 @ 2:20pm

    Re: Do your job, Zachary

    An number of people have brought up your concerns, so I will address them here, since you seem to have a pretty good listing of problems with my story.

    5 minutes. That's all it would take to realize that 99% of what's listed in this "interview" isn't true.

    I read the entire linked source article and the Windows Store app guidelines. I would have thought that would be sufficient research. Guess I was wrong. Should have asked my critics too.

    1) Windows is not restricting app installations on computers to only the app store.

    True, but the Metro UI is the default upon logging in and what the majority of casual users will spend the majority of their time.

    They are restricting MetroUI apps, which is not where something like Skyrim would run.

    It is not where today's Skyrim will run, but what about tomorrow's Skyrim that wants to be sold in the Windows Store and run in the Metro UI?

    2) The 3D work done for Skyrim is completely incompatible with the ARM devices, meaning that it would NEVER EVER EVER run on an RT tablet anyhow.

    Who is talking about RT devices? This article refers to desktops and laptops. On top of that, what is to say that an RT game developer would not seek out an ESRB or PEGI rating?

    3) Yes, Microsoft has caused some confusion by calling everything this generation "Windows 8". That doesn't mean they're all the same product.

    I made no indication that the confusion was over what is or is not Windows 8. I pointed out the confusion of having a store with conflicting rules for inclusion. It just so happened that the examples were for a desktop computer.

    4) Claiming Windows 8 won't run anything outside the Windows Store is either intentional misinformation or willful ignorance.

    Did I make that claim? I don't think so.

    Glossing over that Skyrim (and in fact most apps) will never be a part of MetroUI is just negligence.

    Never is a strong word.

    5) Skyrim runs in Windows 7. That means it'll run in Windows 8. End of story.

    This isn't about Skyrim. This isn't about any one particular game. This is about arbitrary rule and restrictions that conflict with each other. The games were simply an example to show how arbitrary and contradictory the rules are. Sorry you missed that point.

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter

Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Shop Now: Techdirt Logo Gear
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads


Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.