Patton Oswalt Explains That There Are No More Gatekeepers In Entertainment

from the well-said dept

For years, we've argued that the role of middlemen in the entertainment industry has been changing drastically. Most were built up on the basis of being gatekeepers: choosing who would get to go out and perform to the world, and using that gatekeeper status to (1) put themselves (the middlemen) in the center of everything and (2) demand nearly all ownership and profits from the results. But the new world is one in which gatekeepers are obsolete. The natural limits of things like broadcast television or movies are fluttering away thanks to the internet and all the technology that allows anyone to be a creator. That doesn't mean that middlemen aren't necessary any more. They absolutely are. But their roles are as enablers, not gatekeepers. They have to put the content creators back in the center and accept that they don't have full control, and they don't get to keep 85 cents of every dollar earned.

Famed comedian Patton Oswalt took to the stage at the "Just for Laughs Comedy Conference" in Montreal recently and made this point brilliantly in the form of two "letters." (Thanks to Pickle Monger for calling this to our attention.) The first letter was to fellow comedians -- more or less telling them to take control over their own career. They had to stop looking for the gatekeeper to come along and pick them, and take charge. Here's just a snippet, but the whole thing is worth reading:
[Following a brief description of his very successful career] But if you listened very carefully, you would have heard two words over and over again: “lucky” and “given.” Those are two very very dangerous words for a comedian. Those two words can put you to sleep, especially once you get a taste of both being “lucky” and being “given.” The days about luck and being given are about to end. They’re about to go away.

Not totally. There are always comedians who will work hard and get noticed by agents and managers and record labels. There will always be an element of that. And they deserve their success. And there’s always going to be people who benefit from that.

What I mean is: Not being lucky and not being given are no longer going to define your career as a comedian and as an artist.
The second letter addresses the gatekeepers quite directly. Again, a snippet, though you should read the whole thing:
You guys need to stop thinking like gatekeepers. You need to do it for the sake of your own survival.

Because all of us comedians after watching Louis CK revolutionize sitcoms and comedy recordings and live tours. And listening to "WTF With Marc Maron" and "Comedy Bang! Bang!" and watching the growth of the UCB Theatre on two coasts and seeing careers being made on Twitter and Youtube.

Our careers don’t hinge on somebody in a plush office deciding to aim a little luck in our direction. There are no gates. They’re gone. The model for success as a comedian in the '70s and '80s? That was middle school.
He goes on to talk about how they can stop being gatekeepers and start actually helping (first by being "fans") but then goes on to point out why the gatekeeper role is gone in a very simple fashion:
We can just walk away.

You know why we can do that now? Because of these. (Oswalt holds up an iPhone)

In my hand right now I’m holding more filmmaking technology than Orson Welles had when he filmed Citizen Kane.

I’m holding almost the same amount of cinematography, post-editing, sound editing, and broadcast capabilities as you have at your tv network.

In a couple of years it’s going to be fucking equal. I see what’s fucking coming. This isn’t a threat, this is an offer.
It's an offer so few gatekeepers have been willing to take up.

I think it's great that Oswalt is saying this stuff. For the last few years, as Louis CK has revolutionized various parts of the comedy industry (as we've detailed here), it's been interesting to see how other comics have reacted. I keep hearing about how comedians want a "Louis CK deal," -- which is a deal like the one that Louis got for his show on FX (where he basically has full control over every aspect of the product). The problem, of course, is that no one else wants to give out such a deal -- and even if other comedians got it, many wouldn't know what to do with it. Because of that, I've heard some suggest that there isn't much to learn from Louis, since his situation is one of a kind.

I think Oswalt is much more on the right track, though. Of course, the answer isn't just in "getting the Louis CK deal" or even just copying exactly how he released his last comedy special. It's in recognizing the larger point of Oswalt's keynote: that the old rules and old gatekeepers are meaningless. You can forge your own path, and whereas you used to have to work within the confines of the system, nowadays you have lots of options. Every opportunity is there.

Filed Under: comedy, entertainment, gatekeepers, louis ck, luck, make your own, patton oswalt

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. identicon
    Anonymous Coward With A Unique Writing Style, 1 Aug 2012 @ 4:38am


    "So why hasn't he made another Citizen Kane then?

    Simple. He isn't Orson Welles.

    This dwelling on the progress of hardware is a red herring.

    Gatekeepers aren't holding anyone back. Lack of talent is.

    I can go to Home Depot and buy the same tools used to make fine furniture. Does that suddenly put me in the same league? Of course not.

    It's not the tools, it's the carpenter.

    It's not the gadgets, it's the artist."

    He isn't Orson Welles. But he's making a point, that technology has advanced enough for the next Orson Welles to have an easier time of things solo than with one of the gatekeepers.

    If this dwelling on progress is a red herring, why all the effort to fight and hold it off?

    Since you didn't put who you'd be in the same league of we cannot say. However, just because you can't doesn't mean someone else can't. I know a man who can do exactly that and make the same furniture you find in exceptionally pricey stores. He has the talent and ability. I also happen to have a friend who's father is quite literally a crackhead who can do the same thing. Both are insanely talented individuals when it comes to woodworking. Does it put them in the same league? As each other, yes. As a "professional"? I guess that's more subjective but I'd say yes.

    As for the "it's not the tools, it's the carpenter" bit, I find it interesting you say that. Yet, I'm all but certain that you're one of the same ACs who in other threads will blame Megaupload for this or that and websites for this or that and call for their destruction and the destruction of technology that allows for things like that to be created. Yet when people point out it's not the tools it's the wielders of them that are the problem you'll do some hand waving and go on some kind of rant about something else.

    It's a damn shame you ACs all use the same moniker. Makes it real nice and easy to say, "Nuh uh. I never said that. It must've been some other AC."

    As for "it's not the gadgets, it's the artists", bullshit. I've heard of a few bands that were AWFUL (which is purely my opinion) and who had no musical talent whatsoever (again, my opinion). Yet the "gadgets" and tools like GarageBand allowed them to do enough to become famous. Since it's super early and I haven't had my caffeine yet I can't think of the name of the one band in particular who I know this is true for, but as soon as I do I'll update with another comment.

    Sorry to say, you're just being dismissive. Again, if it's no biggie then why the need to knock Patton Oswalt or take shots at others you don't even know ("lack of talent is" "it's the carpenter" etc)? That says to myself and others quite a bit. You be afraid. And the gatekeepers be so to.

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter

Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Insider Shop - Show Your Support!

Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads


Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.