by Mike Masnick
Tue, Jun 12th 2012 4:03am
Back in 2009, we wrote about how anti-piracy organization FACT worked closely with UK law enforcement to have the guy who operated Filesoup arrested. At the time, we noted that it wasn't at all clear what he was doing that was illegal, as the site was merely a forum. Though some people did, in fact, use that forum for the sake of infringement, that shouldn't implicate the forum host. And, in fact, after about a year and a half, the courts dropped the case, realizing that the arguments the industry kept feeding law enforcement didn't add up to anything illegal. The court noted that the charges never should have been brought in the first place. Of course, that's small comfort to the folks who ran the site and had to go through this ordeal. The site has announced that it's shutting down, and the arrests and lawsuits were a big part of what killed it.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- As Expected Judge Upholds His Own Problematic Ruling Concerning Cox's Repeat Infringer Policy & The DMCA
- Bizarre Decision Keeps Hope Alive In Enigma Software's Defamation Suit Against BleepingComputer
- Appeals Court Rejects Revenge Pornster's Appeal; Another Bad Section 230 Ruling
- UK Court Dismisses Yet Another Bogus Criminal Lawsuit Against Torrent Tracker Admins
- Entertainment Industry Decides FileSoup Doesn't Have Enough Publicity; Has Owner Arrested