by Mike Masnick
Wed, Mar 16th 2011 3:00am
We recently wrote about an attempt by one of the growing number of mass P2P pre-settlement lawsuit lawyers, John Steele, to file a reverse of defendant class action lawsuit to try to get around the issue of misjoinder in combining a bunch of totally unrelated individuals in a single lawsuit. Typically, of course, class action lawsuits involve a class as the "plaintiff" not the defendant. It's not unheard of to have a defendant class action, but it is rare. Either way, the judge doesn't seem to be buying it. In a recent hearing the judge noted that the whole thing felt like a fishing expedition, and barred the court from issuing any subpoenas until an adversarial hearing was held. It's unclear who will represent the still anonymous "class," but hopefully the judge takes a note from another court and brings in experts like Public Citizen and the EFF.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Torrent Madness: UK Cybercrime Official Argues That File Sharing Is A Gateway Drug To Crime
- Team Prenda Gets Hit Hard With Contempt Sanctions For Lying To Court
- Prenda Lawyer's ADA Shakedown Efforts Running Into Resistance From Public, Judges
- Team Prenda Has A Very Bad Day In Court... And You Can Watch It All
- Warner Bros. And Rightscorp Argue That Copyright Trolling Is Protected By The First Amendment