by Mike Masnick
Thu, Jul 1st 2010 7:16pm
Glyn Moody points us to the news that the IEEE has put out a press release celebrating the Bilski ruling. This is reasonably upsetting many who find software patents abhorrent to those who believe in technological progress. The IEEE had been part of an amicus filing, where it asked the court for clarity, so it's a little surprising to celebrate this ruling, which provided no clarity at all. Instead, the IEEE claims it's happy that "The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 Monday that a new method of doing business can be patented, and that the ability to patent software should not be limited." Except the overall ruling was 9-0, not 5-4 (though, the majority binding part of the ruling was 5-4), and the majority ruling doesn't actually make it clear that the ability to patent software should not be limited. In fact, it skips over that question pretty much entirely. So it's not clear what the IEEE is celebrating other than that the court didn't actually address software patents.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Techdirt Podcast Episode 96: Death Knell For Software Patents
- Antitrust Suit Alleges Pharma Company Rubbished Its Own Product In Order To Stave Off Competition From Generics
- FTC Releases Big Report On Patent Trolls, Says The Patent System Needs To Change
- Prominent Pro-Patent Judge Issues Opinion Declaring All Software Patents Bad
- Stupid Design Patent Of The Month: Rectangles On A Screen