by Mike Masnick
Tue, Feb 9th 2010 9:01pm
Back at the end of last year, we wrote about how some had noticed that DigiProtect, one of a group of companies that purposely puts files online to see who downloads them, and then threatens them with "pay up or we'll sue" letters, was potentially in trouble in Germany for not following the law. German law says that you can't base "legal costs" on a contingency like winning. Yet, DigiProtect's agreement is that it only gets paid if it can collect on the pre-settlement letters. That goes against the law. And, now, a court has agreed, and found that DigiProtect can't ask for legal fees in Germany unless it can actually prove what those real fees are. The court did offer DigiProtect an out: open your books and show what the real costs are, and how they are paid. DigiProtect refused to do so. This basically cuts out pretty much all of the massive profits DigiProtect and others brag about.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Terrible Ruling In Germany: Digitizing The Public Domain Creates New Copyright
- Europe Is About To Create A Link Tax: Time To Speak Out Against It
- Two Separate Copyright Rulings Around The Globe May Finally Clear The Copyright Way For Sampling
- US Court Dings Digiprotect On Mass Lawsuit Filings; Worries About Pressure On Those Sued To Settle
- Are There More Copyright 'Pre-Settlement' Groups Setting Up Shop In The US?