Copyright Insanity: The Need To Get Licenses Just To Demonstrate A Legal Point

from the that-seems-problematic dept

Over at Against Monopoly, Alistair Kelman, points out yet another quirky problem with copyright law. He's discussing a book by Ron Rosen, who was the attorney for famed composer John Williams in fighting a copyright infringement claim saying that Williams copied a phrase in the score for the movie E.T.. The book is called Music and Copyright, and (according to Kelman) is quite a worthwhile read in thinking about some of the modern legal issues that will be faced thanks to mashups and other musical compositions that run up against copyright questions.

Kelman's one issue with the book, is that it would really be aided quite a bit by being able to hear the actual music in question, rather than just seeing the musical notation. So, the suggestion was, why did Rosen put up an online video lecture, playing the music samples so that people could better understand the issues at play. The answer, it turns out, is copyright law. Rosen wrote Kelman, noting:
"...about the need for aural examples, that is something we wanted to do for this edition, but as a new publication, the need for licenses and the budget foreclosed our doing so."
So even though this is a somewhat scholarly effort to look at these issues, apparently Rosen can't even demonstrate his points with music, because copyright forbids it, and requires hefty licensing fees. If ever there were a case where "fair use" should apply, this would seem to be it -- but I'm sure some would argue against that point since this book is a "for-profit" endeavor. Of course, whether something is commercial or not is only one of the four fair use factors, and it seems that if it's just a snippet of the music, a strong fair use case could be made (especially since it's hard to see how this could possibly harm the market for the music itself). However, as copyright system defenders love to point out on a regular basis, they see fair use as a "defense, rather than a right" and thus, the only way to prove that this is fair use would be to go to court -- something that is expensive and time consuming. What an unfortunate state of affairs.

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread


  1. identicon
    Gordon, 3 Jul 2009 @ 11:16am

    This whole "hefty" this has to go.

    It's unimportant to the story. AC is loving the fact that ppl are arguing it because it takes away from the real question.
    As AC stated
    -Sometimes you have to frame the question in another way.

    What would happen if I wrote a book on "the great movie music of the 20th century", and decided to include a CD with every copy of the book? All the great songs in one place, say 20 chapters as I look at the 20 great songs from the movies.

    I sell the book for, I dunno, $39.95. What part of that price is the CD?

    Put another way, if a company was selling a CD of the "20 greatest movie themes of the 20th Century", how much would they sell it for retail? Probably $19.95 or so.

    So my book is worth $20, and the music is worth $19.95

    Sort of makes sense that the people who SELL music would be a little upset if I am upselling my own work by giving away a "free" CD, no?-

    Now I don't know the facts about the music in question(as nobody replying on this blog does) but I would assume that he wouldn't need to use whole songs, so this post is thrown right out.

    The important question is still.....Why would he have to get licensing for 5-10 second snippets of songs just to show how the section of music in question is different or maybe even similar?

    Discuss

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Use markdown for basic formatting. HTML is no longer supported.
  Save me a cookie
Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Shop Now: Techdirt Logo Gear
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads

Close

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.