Universal, YouTube Collaboration To Be Run By Someone Who Sees The Bigger Picture

from the a-good-first-step dept

At the beginning of March, I questioned the wisdom of Universal Music and YouTube teaming up to create a separate site just for Universal Music, called Vevo. While I thought it could be interesting, it really depended on the execution, and the early talk about it seemed to miss the point. That is, it said that YouTube would supply the "technology" and Universal would supply the music. Of course, what that's missing is that much of the value in YouTube isn't in the technology (which many others have replicated), but in the community. So, if Vevo was to get anywhere, it would need to recognize that fact, rather than simply looking at YouTube as a tech vendor.

At the end of March, in a totally separate post, I wrote about my surprise at seeing my fellow keynote presenter at the Leadership Music Digital Summit, Rio Caraeff of Universal Music, present a reasonable vision for where the music industry needed to be: getting away from selling "music" and in creating better, more valuable experiences that simply can't be replicated by file sharing. This was in stark contrast to what Universal Music's own CEO had been saying for years. While Caraeff admitted that it was still a struggle to get this message through to everyone at Universal, he believed in it strongly.

That's why it's noteworthy that Caraeff has now been put in charge of the Vevo project. I'm still not convinced it's anything more than a boondoggle that will go nowhere quickly, but putting Caraeff in charge of it immediately makes it a much more interesting project to follow. The real question is what he does with it, and whether the bosses back at Universal Music actually give him enough free reign to let him turn the site into what it needs to be. I wish I could be optimistic, but given the major record labels' track record in dealing with such things, I still think the chances are pretty slim.

Filed Under: music, rio caraeff, videos
Companies: google, universal music, vevo, youtube

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. identicon
    TheUsualGuyWhoThinksMikeIsADipshit (aka YouAreWron, 11 May 2009 @ 5:54pm

    somewhat actually agreeing with mike

    I disagree with your notion of a "community" on youtube. The commenting on youtube is retarded and unusable. The value that youtube has (which other sites don't) is that youtube has ANYTHING you want. If you can't find something on youtube or google, there's a 95% chance or more that it simply doesn't exist. However, these labels want to create their own walled gardens, when they only have 20% market share or less. Who wants to go to a site that has only 20% of the videos you want? Most people have a hard time naming what song is playing... now you want them to know the artist too?

    As we've seen with the AP syndication vs aggregators issue, the problem is that having even lead-ins from other sites destroys content creators' business model because people don't stick around in the incredibly small walled garden. Much of the content industry has survived off of forced bundling, and the web (and especially aggregators) breaks that. I would say that universal music should be accessible from youtube searches, which would then take you to the vevo domain, but what value is vevo adding? Merely adding the content isn't enough because there are 24839429 other music videos right in line even if every universal artist was taken off youtube. That's WHY Warner and AP bitch and complain about Google running content. They realize that Google adds a ton of value, and that's why they're too afraid of taking their content off completely.

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter

Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Insider Shop - Show Your Support!

Essential Reading
Techdirt Insider Chat
Recent Stories

This site, like most other sites on the web, uses cookies. For more information, see our privacy policy. Got it

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.