Those Who Don't Understand The Value Of Free Information Are Doomed To Fail

from the creative-destruction,-romer-style dept

I've obviously been writing quite a bit about both the music industry and the news industry lately -- as there are tremendous similarities between the two industries -- a point highlighted by Tim Lee, who (at the same time) notes that the one difference is that "piracy" isn't a problem for the news business (though, those who incorrectly blame Google for the downfall of journalism might argue otherwise). Tim's point (and it's one I agree with) is that the basic factors hitting both industries are really the same, and the "piracy" excuse is something of a near total red herring. It's actually the overall dynamics of a changing market when the main output becomes digital.

Lee's piece is a response to James DeLong's article decrying the death of newspapers which pins it on all of us fools who claim that "information wants to be free." DeLong, you may recall, was a bigshot at the Progress & Freedom Foundation -- a DC think tank that has long advocated ever more draconian copyright measures. And, he's effectively doing the same thing here: saying that newspapers will only survive if they charge for every little thing. This is, once again, the same incredibly wrong advice that he spewed out to the entertainment industry for years -- and look where that got them?

The similarities actually remind me of the one time that I actually got to meet DeLong, nearly three years ago, at a Cato Institute symposium on copyright, where I first laid out the details of why "free" isn't a problem in economics, and how it should be a part of the business model, if you follow through on the basic economics. It was actually on the flight to that event, reading a book about the history of the number zero that I realized just how difficult it was for many to get past the zero. It was as if, the second they came across zero, their brain popped out an error and they stopped thinking. It leads to ridiculous claims like "if I give it away for free, I won't make any money!" That's not true if you look at the larger economic ecosystem, understand the economics of information or infinite goods, and recognize how they can play into the overall economic model.

While DeLong was there that day and heard me speak on this, it's pretty clear that he didn't get the message. Instead, he's continuing to focus on how to implement artificial scarcity, believing that markets only work when everything has its price -- and that price isn't zero. But this is a huge mistake from a business perspective. If you understand where the zero fits into the business model, then there are plenty of business models that work great. The problem with the recording industry is that they've never believed the zero fit anywhere. The problem with the newspaper industry is that it recognized the zero, but forgot to figure out where the rest of the business model fit. Instead of figuring that out, reactionaries like DeLong are moving backwards and trying to just ignore the zero again. Unfortunately that's what breaks the model even worse. Ignoring the reality of where a zero fits into a business model is a simple recipe for failure as it tries to go against fundamental economics.

No one has ever said that "everything must be free" (though, angry copyright system defenders repeatedly pretend that's what we are saying). All we've said all along is that it's important to recognize that in the information economy, it makes plenty of economic sense for certain things (i.e., "infinite goods") to be free (that's where the zero goes) and then the scarce goods are what you charge for. The trick is enabling a business model where the infinite goods make the scarce goods you control more valuable. This is absolutely possible for any business -- and, in fact, failing to understand how you do this will most likely doom your overall business.

We'll be talking about this and much more at the Free! Summit in a couple months, and we hope you can join us. However, we have to admit that early interest in the event has been overwhelming, so we've already had to shut down the open registration and opened up a waiting list. We're working hard to see if there are ways we can accommodate a much larger audience (if you have any ideas, let us know -- or if you're interested in sponsoring a live web feed, please let us know), but if you were thinking of going, at least get on the waiting list early.

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  1. identicon
    Ima Fish, 5 Mar 2009 @ 12:05pm


    "If you kill a 10 billion dollar a year industry"

    Maybe you can explain why the government should give a monopoly to support a 10 billion dollar a year industry. Why shouldn't the government step out of the way and let the market sort it out?

    "the music industry loses twice, not only do they not make a sale of music, but they also have the intrinsic value of their product reduced to zero and corrupted to make someone else money."

    Where it written that anyone has a right to make money or to have an intrinsic value on their product enforced by government fiat?!

    I'll answer that, it's copyright and patent law. Once again get rid of those and let the market sort it out.

    "If they didn't have to pay for that movie (because they downloaded it from a P2P site) who is actually paying to have that movie made?"

    First, as the economy is declining, the movie industry's sales are increasing.

    But more importantly, where is written than any person selling a product has a right to paying costumers? If people are not willing to pay, then the market fails. It's happened plenty of times in the past and will happen plenty of times in the future.

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Use markdown for basic formatting. HTML is no longer supported.
  Save me a cookie
Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Shop Now: I Invented Email
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads


Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.