Your Encryption Key Is Protected By The Constitution?

from the can't-incriminate-yourself dept

In an interesting case up in Vermont, a federal judge has ruled that someone accused of a crime cannot be forced to reveal his or her encryption key, as it would be a violation of the Constitution's 5th Amendment, saying that an individual cannot be forced to self-incriminate. In an age where encryption is becoming increasingly popular, expect to see other cases of this nature. It seems likely that a case like this one (if not this one itself) will eventually wind up before the Supreme Court to determine whether or not someone can be forced to give up his own encryption key. Where it gets tricky is the question of whether or not the key itself incriminates the person. As the article notes, a person can be forced to give up a key to a safe that contains incriminating evidence, which many say is analogous to this situation. In the meantime, though, we've already seen cases where people are presumed guilty just because their computers have encryption software installed -- so, it may not matter whether or not the key is provided when the presence of PGP alone is viewed as incriminating.

Filed Under: constitution, encryption, encryption key, fifth amendment, pgp


Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread


  1. icon
    slimcat (profile), 17 Dec 2007 @ 8:37am

    The rule makers

    President George W. Bush said of our Constitution: "It's just a goddamn piece of paper." Google it yourself.

    Those in charge make the rules and the rule benefit only those in charge. One day, hopefully, this will come to an end.

    -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
    Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Linux)

    mQGiBEdbHE0RBADEEtnxrVLK9ocQonX8zVP4hUejy/C89RnuHLL7dXDF35XqEt1b
    lVsuvzG7YTX2aFqZNkQ v1nZO8InpwT3KXrADzbGb6otkSo4vA8C0fq+IqNi2KJ9R
    FYtGKDvFnvp90iAn1fDqT7jXiNkKpDdp9CPBsHbIHS/XgpAiZqdCD eaXOwCg6uvt
    2ZJhPyNNPzWuux63zx5HZXsEAIb6CXLwch38vsDt8Big4XRWpBOUtUTQZlxd6XSt
    U9pdSY0WBnzFjtA4ahSnZ aLoHjs5/kyjv1z/H1MuDstcZ8AnkoINWnT1ozviPiup
    T8mWS15NYCSj46Oqc/ztrNeyhPFOhXg6ZxNEY/4zM9vqSz+F+pIZu0F OVKKFdVVq
    w/YCBACHWjrtl2uAmVhbOCRc9hQz9sNbkk9F+OWgKcrEJliXmCcXDQRfhQ3JN1FH
    EleuapuUFTV7Wke+IkNjP5C fwRWmIQTgWKpHPOef1K6YgRr+bhPJjXMiRjXRuBUm
    OvngPsbZgb0MS2Ajy/3bmLMUijKZmNjrlmyPC1eYjWSbJXRh17QpUm9ia W4gU21p
    dGggKGdlbnVzZSkgPGZ1ZWdvNDUxQGdtYWlsLmNvbT6IYAQTEQIAIAUCR1scTQIb
    IwYLCQgHAwIEFQIIAwQWAgMBA h4BAheAAAoJEDyNrB0qhmTxT3UAnRs/tDQi8KFQ
    DAeBDYN1UzcenWvJAKCKsgrsCg0/QoGFTmYht7eipK3aD7kBDQRHWxxQEAQ AlYAr
    WXRkbfMgmWI3UljoMSQpkGB0x3ZPqjC/gExzrXVlGeTBm3C40mg0oFZrNHKlWMCi
    smt3oVyEwOrP9ngeUnunk2PddxK dznw9gRGQjzByDgXwd2oQtJiL94l5Jy76KZfX
    bHdPZl8Y67thCgSMCO4pvWKZuAkllW8EvXFv7XsAAwUD+gOJKZsHPpCXCtPi7 1Fy
    Fe6+NyHZI1Sb/cXIQtCShHeciKihuDIcUqCyEEqFEBzm5f8H6Axny01tUe0Y/01Z
    wDuTVJB2wTIHO9G0JAuSuUWsD3Pgc wX8ALMhm+9eoym4vcaI9WY3zg7hQiijH1p2
    2+4QKvHNvcJ7VW6tVAja4/UYiEkEGBECAAkFAkdbHFACGwwACgkQPI2sHSqGZPG R
    ZwCdH73m8BnlmJM8BsSwKNLFR69+g+0AmwaFSaIQOSAqCtyzTM0KuTCW0OsT
    =NlOY
    -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here



Subscribe to the Techdirt Daily newsletter




Comment Options:

  • Use markdown. Use plain text.
  • Remember name/email/url (set a cookie)

Follow Techdirt
Techdirt Gear
Show Now: Takedown
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Advertisement
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads

Close

Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.