Boston Police Department Used Forfeiture Funds To Hide Purchase Of Surveillance Tech From City Reps

from the cops-are-upstanding-individuals-who-play-by-the-rules dept

Asset forfeiture is just cops going shopping for things they want. The analogy — one prompted by statements made by Sean McMurty, the head of a county forfeiture unit in New Jersey — works on multiple levels. McMurtry encouraged cops to seize stuff they wanted or needed.

Mr. McMurtry made it clear that forfeitures were highly contingent on the needs of law enforcement. In New Jersey, the police and prosecutors are allowed to use cars, cash and other seized goods; the rest must be sold at auction. Cellphones and jewelry, Mr. McMurtry said, are not worth the bother. Flat screen televisions, however, “are very popular with the police departments,” he said…

Mr. McMurtry said his handling of a case is sometimes determined by department wish lists. “If you want the car, and you really want to put it in your fleet, let me know — I’ll fight for it,” Mr. McMurtry said, addressing law enforcement officials on the video. “If you don’t let me know that, I’ll try and resolve it real quick through a settlement and get cash for the car, get the tow fee paid off, get some money for it.”

That’s direct shopping, utilizing law enforcement’s version of the five-finger discount. Take what you think you can use. Convert the rest to cash.

With cash in hand, cops can once again go shopping (albeit without the discount) for things they want. Even better, they can hide this shopping from the public and their oversight, stocking their cupboards with surveillance tech they don’t want the public to know about and make purchases that would never be approved by those holding the rest of their purse strings.

We’ve seen this happen (obviously months or years after the fact thanks to the secretive source of funds) in some of the largest police departments in the country. Both the Chicago and New York City police departments have used secret funds to buy surveillance tech. In Chicago’s case, the secret slush fund was powered by forfeitures. In New York, it was a fund the city gave explicit permission to the NYPD to spend as it wanted.

Now it’s the Boston Police Department being caught… well, not in the act, but, I guess, after the fact(?), thanks to local journalists.

[I]n 2019 the Boston Police Department bought the device known as a cell site simulator — and tapped a hidden pot of money that kept the purchase out of the public eye.

A WBUR investigation with ProPublica found elected officials and the public were largely kept in the dark when Boston police spent $627,000 on this equipment by dipping into money seized in connection with alleged crimes.

There are plenty of funds to work with. Law enforcement agencies and prosecutors in the state directly profit from forfeitures, encouraging cops to perform more seizures and district attorneys to initiate as many proceedings as possible. What’s supposed to be draining organized criminal enterprises of much needed cash is instead a slush fund for both entities. District attorneys get to buy what they want and cops get to do their own, off-the-books shopping to obtain controversial tech.

According to the documents obtained by WBUR and ProPublica, the only interaction the city had with this Stingray purchase was confirming there was enough in the forfeiture fund to buy it. When reached for comment, Boston city reps had no idea the Boston PD had bought itself a cell site simulator.

The Boston PD obviously knows it made this purchase but it isn’t talking. No comment from the BPD spokesperson. No comment from any PD official.

And this sort of secrecy will remain normal, at least for the immediate future. There is no mandated reporting on spending of forfeiture funds and nothing forcing the Boston PD to run all purchases past its city oversight, no matter what funds it’s spending. A proposed ordinance would change that, requiring explicit permission from the city to purchase surveillance gear but it’s not law yet.

But a better solution would be to end the practice of civil asset forfeiture, which allows law enforcement to take money from alleged criminals but without having to actually prove the person formerly in possession of the money was actually engaged in criminal activity. An acceptable stopgap would be to take the seized money out of law enforcement’s hands, as state rep Jay Livingstone suggests, and reroute it to a state general fund less likely to be abused or the source of secret purchases.

For now, law enforcement agencies are still free to spend off-the-books forfeiture funds on whatever they want. Until that incentive goes away, forfeiture programs will be still be heavily abused.

Filed Under: , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Boston Police Department Used Forfeiture Funds To Hide Purchase Of Surveillance Tech From City Reps”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
18 Comments
That One Guy (profile) says:

Re: Re:

That’s where evidence laundering comes into play, get the evidence from an illegal source and then claim that you got it from a legal one and since judges are very hesitant to call out police for corruption or abusing the court system like that and are willing to take police at their word odds are very good that such a trick will work.

Bergman (profile) says:

Re: Re:

Whether they’ve used it as evidence or not, simply switching it on would be interception of electronic communications – a felony unless they have a warrant. Remember, the law enforcement exemptions to interception, eavesdropping and wiretap laws only activates when a warrant is issued. Without that warrant, doing those things is just as illegal for police as it is for any other citizen.

cattress (profile) says:

But they defunded us poor cops! Wahhhh!

Seriously, for all the non-existent defunding that cops, their mobs, er unions, and the Republicans have been crying about, you don’t hear a peep about using those slush funds to cover the safety and protective equipment they need so desperately, salaries, healthcare, fallen officer family support (whatever they can dig up to pull at any reasonable person’s heartstrings) that they say they can’t afford (let alone de-escalation training, basic training for recognizing and handling someone in a mental health crisis, domestic violence prevention in their own homes, and their own mental healthcare that many legitimately need). Nope, can’t find any of those necessary things with their stolen play time money they secretly squirrel away, they need more tax dollars to keep robbing, raping, and killing the people, or they just might "let" the "criminals" do that themselves.
It’s like stealing cash from your spouse in secret, then smacking them around for accusing you, snatching the rest of their cash and heading to Vegas with your friends while they eat ramen noodles with the kids, that they cooked at the neighbors since the power is shut off.

Scary Devil Monastery (profile) says:

Re: But they defunded us poor cops! Wahhhh!

"It’s like stealing cash from your spouse in secret, then smacking them around for accusing you, snatching the rest of their cash and heading to Vegas with your friends…"

Well, if your actions mean you get money, a power trip and a vacation without consequences there’s plenty of motives to perpetuate such behavior after all.

Raymondjoype (user link) says:

О чем писать в блог 141 тема для стат?

Systematically visiting the four hands massage for clients, you guarantee himself excellent sexual relaxation.
The energy massage inSoho it today skill give away bliss. The Soapy massage – on the influence on clients is meant practically unlimited available opportunities actions on bodily, and consequently, and psychoemotional state of health friends.
Sensitive touch rasprekrasnoy girls will flow through your body, dipping in depth boundless the ocean pleasure. In the quiet slip, donating your skin kisses, prelestress envelops the warmth of one's body. You will be surprised at, which sea bliss today it is possible to feel fromnude massage in Midtown.
Dear gentlemen!
In school sensual massage women will hold erotic 4hands massage. Similar swedish massage, as in principle, and relaxation, influences on some area human body, this give a chance male gain strength.

<a href=https://penzu.com/p/8bde7df1>Как создать свой блог в интернете и сделать его популярным</a>
[—-]

Raymondjoype (user link) says:

Лучшие платформы для создания блог

Systematically visiting the four hands massage for clients, you guarantee himself excellent sexual relaxation.
In school sensual massage women will hold erotic 4hands massage. Similar swedish massage, as in principle, and relaxation, influences on some area human body, this give a chance male gain strength.
The energy massage inSoho it today skill give away bliss. The Soapy massage – on the influence on clients is meant practically unlimited available opportunities actions on bodily, and consequently, and psychoemotional state of health friends.
Sensitive touch rasprekrasnoy girls will flow through your body, dipping in depth boundless the ocean pleasure. In the quiet slip, donating your skin kisses, prelestress envelops the warmth of one's body. You will be surprised at, which sea bliss today it is possible to feel fromnude massage in Midtown.
Dear gentlemen!

<a href=https://telegra.ph/erotic-massage-outcall–perfect-relaxation-with-erotic-massage-11-11>Blogger com Чтобы создать свой собственный блог потребуется</a>
[—-]

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...