Nassau County Executive Vetoes Bill That Would Punish People For Making Cops Feel Bad

from the but-an-underlying-problem-remains dept

Good news in Nassau County, New York. The stupid law that turned not being sufficiently deferential to cops (or other first responders) into a quasi-hate crime has been rejected by the head of Nassau County’s government, accompanied by a message to the stupid legislators who passed it. (via Michael Vario)

Nassau County Executive Laura Curran on Tuesday vetoed a bill to give police and other first responders the right to sue under the county Human Rights Law when they face “discrimination” from protesters or others.


In her veto letter to lawmakers, Curran acknowledged the “genuine concern” of community members “that the law would intimidate free citizens from engaging in peaceful demonstrations without fear of retaliation.”

Citing an opinion from state Attorney General Letitia James, Curran pointed out the obvious: the new bill — which criminalized “harassing” first responders (but really mostly cops) — didn’t have a chance in hell of surviving a constitutional challenge, especially when it tied increased legal penalties to acts occurring during “riots” (even if the person charged was not actually rioting).

Curran continued: “There is no consensus among elected officials and the public that this current legislation is necessary, carefully crafted and without negative consequences.”

Well, there was enough of a consensus the bill was passed by a margin of 12-6. That the consensus is wrong about the bill’s necessity and the quality of the craftsmanship is the larger problem and it indicates there will be similar proposals in the future, especially since local law enforcement can’t seem to be disabused of the notion that a career choice isn’t an immutable characteristic worthy of protection from discrimination.

Of course, police unions are still complaining about this completely expected turn of events.

“First responders are sometimes treated as second class citizens, Jennifer,” Nassau PBA board member Thomas O’Reilly told CBS2’s Jennifer McLogan. “We feel very hurtful about that. We thought this was a good bill.

Odd that a cop rep would admit to “feeling hurtful” about events that didn’t go their way. Seems inadvertently revealing.

But notice that the only first responders unions complaining are those representing cops. People have no problem with EMTs and firefighters — first responders who almost never subject people to excessive force or rights violations. The whining from the Police Benevolent Association continues:

“We shouldn’t be spit on. We shouldn’t have water thrown on us. We shouldn’t be intimidated and harassed and people blowing smoke in our face,” O’Reilly said.

OH MY GOD. How do your officers even cope with actually dangerous criminals, who are capable of far more than making them feel wet or otherwise mildly uncomfortable?

The bigger problem is a law already on the books which will encourage legislators who think the PBA makes good points to keep plugging away at expanding protection of police officers at the expense of the rights of the people they serve.

The Legislature in 2019 extended protections against discrimination in housing, employment, and public accommodations to veterans and first responders.

That’s the foot that will remain in the legislative door until that one finally comes off the books. As long as it remains, it will be exploited by opportunists who somehow believe cops just don’t have enough power or protections.

Filed Under: , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Nassau County Executive Vetoes Bill That Would Punish People For Making Cops Feel Bad”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: So glad I got the extended warranty...

Actually, I agree. People shouldn’t throw waters on others (except maybe in a mutually agreed water fight), spit on others or blow smoke in their faces. Just as they shouldn’t fire tear gas grenades at peaceful protesters, fire rubber bullets at reporter’s faces, forcefully eject people from a church grounds that the local clergy don’t want ejected, illegally force their way into buildings and attack and injure the police who are only trying to do their jobs – I could go on, but I’m sure you get my drift.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

Re: Re: It was a glass house but nary a wall is left standing

In general I’d agree but having a bloody police union complain that their members are being ‘intimidated and harassed’ because people are throwing water on them and blowing smoke in their faces is like listening to a person you just watched punch someone in the face simply because they felt like it and who has a long history of assaults complain about how hurtful it is when people call them names like ‘violent thug’.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
David says:

Re: So glad I got the extended warranty...

Frankly, a police officer who needs more protection against intimidation than the general populace most definitely has chosen the wrong job for themselves. That’s sort of like a florist with hay fever complaining about plants in his workspace.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

"even if the person charged was not actually rioting"

Because its easier to just label a group & then treat them like a monolith where the blame is shared by all, even if they did nothing.

Something something PBA PR hacks screaming not all cops, while claiming everyone at a BLM march was armed and trying to kill cops.

"“We feel very hurtful about that. We thought this was a good bill.”"

Bitch you have QI, stop crying. You literally can murder someone on the street, in front of cameras & witnesses and STILL somehow manage to walk away… boo hoo hoo you can’t sue when someone calls you a fscking pig.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Coward says:

“First responders are sometimes treated as second class citizens, Jennifer,”

Which universe is that in? Did you just leak over from some parallel dimension or what? Here’s a tip: Stay here, where cops are zeroth-class citizens (who don’t even consider themselves civilians!). They have loads of extra rights, excessive powers, and almost no responsibility whatsoever. Enjoy!

“We shouldn’t be spit on. We shouldn’t have water thrown on us. We shouldn’t be intimidated and harassed and people blowing smoke in our face,” O’Reilly said.

Hey, no one should have to suffer that. But welcome to Earth, and welcome to one of many professions which pose a generally higher risk of coming into contact with such behavior. (When we aren’t totally lying about how much that actually happens, or specific incidents of those things happening.)

But if you would care for wider public support when you are treated abusively, try doing a better job, in the spirit of the story we’ve created around "serve and protect", and stop being so goddamned abusive of the public, and in ways the public could never be abusive toward you. Also, stop ignoring covering for, and defending unto the end, cops, and cop behaviors and culture which engender such abuse, if you are "one of the good ones". (I realize it is hard to stand up against them when the whole system of bastards is arrayed against you, even if you are on the inside.) But your near the top, on the PBA board, so…

David W says:

Defamation of a civil servant

In Germany, this already exists, but the civil servants (including police & first responders, as well as council and federal services workers) can’t sue, it is an offence and you face court and a fine.

It used to be a very big thing, but nowadays, many police officers will let small slights slide, but anyone being really obnoxious can find themselves being issued with a ticket. If you say something in the heat of the moment, then apologise straight away, you will probably get away with it. But be stroppy and keep calling the official a tosser etc. and they will probably issue you with a ticket.

Attacking police, spitting, shoving etc. comes under assault, AFAIK.

David says:

Re: Re:

Well, do the retail workers carry guns? I guess the principal difference is that the retail worker depends on your cooperation to get your money while the cop gets it upfront. The retail worker does one-off jobs to serve you while the cop is hired and gets a salary.

Maybe you should rethink your hiring strategy.

Ceyarrecks (profile) says:

How typical that there are those who do not want the Mall Cops to cry/whine/whimper/tantrum when their feewings are hurt,…

Considering king David, you know, that man after God’s own heart, was NOT "protected" from feeling bad when he had killed whatshername’s husband so he could continue screwing her,…

Consider also it is our realization of the wrongs we do, that bring us to STOP doing those wrongs.

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Coward Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Older Stuff
09:32 Why Moderating Content Actually Does More To Support The Principles Of Free Speech (76)
09:30 Trumpists Admit That Their Own Social Media Platforms Aren't Much Fun When They Can't Use Them To Own The Libs (79)
15:36 On Elon Musk And Free Speech (164)
12:12 The 'Culture Of Free Speech' Includes Criticism Of Others' Speech; Get Over It (284)
13:30 Cops Who Sued Journalist For Reporting On Their Poor Handling Of A Rape Case Lose Their Defamation Lawsuit (40)
10:48 Jehovah's Witnesses Abusing Copyright Subpoena Process To Unmask Critics (16)
15:35 Devin Nunes Loses Appeal Of SLAPP Suit Against Liz Mair (16)
13:33 First Amendment Group Tells Appeals Court University Officials Shouldn't Have Access To Qualified Immunity (15)
09:32 Appeals Court Smacks Down Unconstitutional Injunction Obtained By A Lawyer To Silence Someone Who Left A Negative Review (13)
10:45 Senator Klobuchar's Next Unconstitutional Speech Control Bill: The NUDGE Act (37)
09:30 EARN ITs Big Knowledge 1st Amendment Problem (40)
13:31 Court (For Now) Says NY Times Can Publish Project Veritas Documents (43)
10:49 Terrible Vermont Harassment Law Being Challenged After Cops Use It To Punish A Black Lives Matter Supporter Over Her Facebook Posts (14)
10:43 UK Government Refreshes Its Terrible 'Online Safety Bill,' Adds Even More Content For Platforms To Police (43)
09:37 Court Grants Qualified Immunity To Officer Who Told Couple To Take Down Facebook Post About Off-Duty Cop Who Shot Their Dog (18)
10:50 Tenth Circuit Tells College Administrator That Ordering A Student To Stop Talking About An Instructor Clearly Violates The First Amendment (27)
06:07 Small Alabama Town's Overzealous Traffic Cops Also Monitored Internet Traffic To Threaten Critics Of The Corrupt PD (43)
10:53 Explainer: The Whole Spotify / Joe Rogan Thing Has Absolutely Nothing To Do With Section 230 (56)
10:56 Governor Inslee Wants To Jail Politicians Who Lie? What Could Possibly Go Wrong? (39)
10:41 Georgia Sees Florida & Texas Social Media Laws Go Down In 1st Amendment Flames And Decides... 'Hey, We Should Do That Too' (65)
13:40 Harrison Greenbaum Latest Trick: Having Paul Levy Respond To Criss Angel's Thuggish Legal Threat (10)
12:12 Small Nebraska Town Pays $16,000 To Resident It Attempted To Sue Into Silence (19)
11:18 Pennsylvania Court Reverses Student's Expulsion Over A Snapchat Post, Reminds School Students Still Have Rights (27)
09:35 Sculptor Of Pillar Of Shame Announces It's Now Public Domain So That Anyone Can Make A Copy, As Chinese Authorities Seek To Destroy It (14)
09:23 Klobuchar's Silly Letter To Facebook Raises 1st Amendment Issues And Only Gives Ammo To Misinfo Peddlers That Facebook Is A State Actor (27)
10:40 Confused Judge Grants Project Veritas' Prior Restraint Against The NY Times (67)
09:31 Robert Reich Loses The Plot: Gets Basically Everything Wrong About Section 230, Fairness Doctrine & The 1st Amendment (95)
11:58 No, The Arguments Against Florida's & Texas' Content Moderation Bills Would Not Block All Internet Regulations (27)
09:33 Canada Strikes Again: Allows Lawsuit Against Twitter To Proceed Over Speech Of Twitter Users (43)
09:20 Rep. Thomas Massie Seems To Have Skipped Over The 1st Amendment In His Rush To 'Defend' The 2nd (95)
More arrow