Boys And Girls Club Backtracks After Folks Ask Why It's Helping A Cable Monopoly Lobby The FCC

from the fake-plastic-enthusiasm dept

Last month we noted how the Boys and Girls Club was one of several organizations cable giant Charter (Spectrum) was using to lobby the FCC in a bid to kill off merger conditions affixed to its 2015 merger with Time Warner Cable. Many of those conditions actively protect consumers from monopoly price gouging (a 7 year temporary moratorium on arbitrary and unnecessary usage caps, for example). Other conditions worked to expand broadband into less affluent areas. Despite the conditions actually helping, you know, boys and girls… the club’s letter opposed them.

In a letter to the FCC, the Boys and Girls Club insisted that a recent $5,000 donation by Charter to the organization helped it weather the COVID-19 storm, and that “lifting these conditions will level the playing field for Charter while having zero impact on the online video marketplace.” But after activist and reporter Phil Dampier pointed out that wasn’t true (garnering local press attention), both the Boys and Girls Club and Charter appear to have quickly pivoted to damage control mode.

In a statement to a Rochester, New York NBC affiliate, the Club acknowledges that after getting a big donation they signed off on a letter to the FCC that was written by Charter — without reading it:

“The Niagara Falls Boys & Girls Club received a request and prepared letter from Charter Communications affirming their charitable gift of $5,000 to support our summer programming. After quick review of the letter we submitted it. Unfortunately, upon closer review we see that the last paragraph of the letter states that we support ‘Charter?s petition to sunset merger conditions.’ It was never our intention to officially support anything. The Niagara Falls Boys & Girls Club does not take a stance either way. We thank Charter Communications for their support of the youth development services we provide to Niagara Falls children.”

Whoops-a-daisy! I not only accidentally lobbied the FCC on behalf of a local cable monopoly, I supported policies that actively harm the entire stated mission of our organization! Charter, for its part, issued a statement that fails to acknowledge much of anything, then tries to brush aside the gross quid pro quo as a “misunderstanding”:

“Charter has supported the life-changing work of the Boys & Girls Clubs across the state for many years and we regret this misunderstanding. As an inherently local business with more than 10,000 employees in the state, we strengthen the communities we serve through employee volunteerism, in-kind support and technology, and philanthropic giving. We work in partnership with hundreds of local leaders and organizations, such as the Niagara Falls Boys & Girls Club and the 1,400 young people whose lives they enhance each year, and will continue to do so.”

That’s a non-answer and a dodge.

A wide variety of groups take telecom cash to repeat whatever they’re told, whether it’s rural school associations, the U.S. Cattlemen’s Association, civil rights advocacy organizations, or even balloonist clubs. Sometimes entirely fake groups are created. Sometimes existing groups are “co-opted” to varying degrees to support bad policy. It was a common tactic in the net neutrality repeal. Hell, it was a major AT&T tactic in its bid to block the 1984 break up of AT&T.

For lobbyists the overall goal is simple: to create the illusion of broad support for bad ideas the actual public — including these target groups’ actual constituents — otherwise oppose. One time out of twenty the press notices (reporting on unsexy but important merger filing minutiae doesn’t generate many ad impressions), and everybody involved pretends it was just some accidental oversight. Because it’s legal, nobody does anything. Rinse, wash, repeat.

Filed Under: , , , ,
Companies: boys and girls club, charter, charter spectrum

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Boys And Girls Club Backtracks After Folks Ask Why It's Helping A Cable Monopoly Lobby The FCC”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
WarioBarker (profile) says:

So…instead of "Yes, we supported Charter’s desire to price gouge its customers.", it’s "I failed to read the part of the Charter-made letter immediately above where my signature went and as a result accidentally supported Charter’s desire to price gouge its customers."

That’s already a terrible excuse, but looking at the letter again, part of the signature goes right through part of the text that supports Charter’s desire to price gouge its customers. So yeah, I smell bullcrappery.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

That's uh, not helping

While it’s nice that they are backtracking after the public scrutiny the fact that they just admitted that so long as you slip them a few grand they will sign whatever you put in front of them unread isn’t exactly making them look any better, not to mention raises the question of how genuine their positions on other topics in the past have been.

If they are that quick to sell themselves to the highest bidder I can’t help but suspect that it’s not the first time they’ve done so, though I imagine it’s probably the first time it’s blown up in their face so publicly, something I imagine their genuine supporters are considering when it comes to future support.

Anonymous Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

Re: That's uh, not helping

I am not so sure genuine supporters is the question. I think the question is what surreptitious concepts are being imposed (indoctrination) upon the boys and girls who attend their facilities? To be so blatantly stupid in what was surely to become a very public matter puts some question to the not so public (what do the kids know, can they recognize indoctrination?) but still stupid activities and lessons being taught. I have no evidence of such (I got my life saving certification at a boys club (the forerunners of the boys and girls clubs) and I don’t think I got such indoctrinated, or it didn’t take) but these days one has to wonder.

Anonymous Coward says:

My first thought reading the article is that it is a shame that the leadership is using the organization in such a way. If I were a parent/member I would be appalled and consider pulling my kids because of the clubs position on this. Then I got to the point in the article that said

"Unfortunately, upon closer review we see that the last paragraph of the letter states that we support ‘Charter’s petition to sunset merger conditions.’ It was never our intention to officially support anything. "

At that point I would just pull my kids out of the club because the leadership is so stupid.

Bartonvxu (user link) says:

shy asian brides

going out Site

Choosing what is important To You In A Dating Site

Social Issues <a href=>how to tell if a vietnamese girl likes you</a> Articles december 6, 2007

the particular has helped take dating to a level not seen before. It all starts with finding the best dating site for searching for potential partners. Here are 8 dating site ideas to help you find the best dating site.

Read entire ArticleOnline Dating Scams

Dating Advice subject matter October 17, 2008

There are reasons you should carefully check the dating site you’re going to join. It is especially true if the dating site of your choice is a brand new dating site and does not established client base. consequently I always recommend joining a larger dating site. Newly established dating site tend to attract a lot of scammers.

Read the Entire ArticleFree Dating Sites Versus Pay dating services

Dating Advice article marketing December 10, 2007


Difficult part of uniform dating is actually choosing a website to sign up

for the. before you jump in head first with

The first dating site that catches your eye you need know what you are waiting.

You may be drawn to a great designed site but basic fundamentals of the site areAlan Lim

Five approaches to Perk Up Dating Practice through a Dating Web Site

Dating Advice writing October 29, 2007

Dating through a dating web site can be an awfully maddening occurrence when the whole show turns out to be sour. how can you possibly make this dating experience worth of remembrance.

Rishxnz (user link) says:

how to tell if a chinese girl likes you

Everton player arrested on feeling of child sex offences has bail extended

This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our realization. You can unsubscribe at any time. more information

are grateful for subscribingWe have more newslettersShow meSee ourprivacy notice

A Premier League footballer who was arrested on suspicion of child sex offences last summer has had his bail extended just as before.

The Everton FC sportsman was once handed bail extensions twice by Greater Manchester Police.

After being arrested on Friday July 26, 2021, The footballer was out on police bail until april 19 2021. he did this extended to Sunday 16 January 2022, that might was extended to Wednesday 19 January.

Police have now confirmed due to extended for a third time, to the point April 17 2022.

Queen’s forgotten castle that she’s never lived in which Kate and William may move intoThe QueenThe castle is owned by the Queen and is found on the Windsor estate and it is reported that the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are keen to move into it.

Scots family rocked by double tragedy crippled by stock strain of funeralsCoronavirusElaine Stirling losther mum, Carol eight months before her lover, jones died.

‘We will never get justice’ Scots parents’ anguish as man they suspect murdered son diesJusticeStefan Sutherland’s body washed up on a beach near his house, 11 days after he was last seen visiting Stewart Dixon’s then residence.

Mum could only be ‘recognised by toes’ after horrific beating at hands of partnerDomestic violenceHelen Procter is sharing pictures of her horrific injuries in a bid to raise knowing of domestic violence.

Royal Alexandra HospitalTrainee doctor damaged ladies bowel during hysterectomy at Scots hospitalThe woman, in their own 40s, Had a hysterectomy at the Royal Alexandra hospital in Paisley, Renfrewshire, On present cards 14, 2020, to treat heavy periods.

Child sex abuseActivist champions Scots languageWest LothianWhitburn teacher and Scots language advocate, Laura orange, Is backing efforts by national charity ‘Nil by Mouth’ to obtain their story book into over 400 primary schools

Butchers scoop top awardWest LothianBoghall Butchers have won an award for a ‘Traditional Sliced Beef Sausage

Dr Hilary Jones unhappy with government’s decision to change the restrictions on Covid 19 as he warns people to be cautiousITVThe TV doctor admitted that it didn’t make sense <a href=>hot viet girl</a> to him as he warned the threat continues.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...