The FCC Knows Trump's Social Media Order Is A Joke, But Fecklessly Pretends Otherwise

from the do-not-upset-dear-leader dept

We’ve mentioned at great length how Trump’s executive order to more heavily “regulate” social media is an unworkable joke. It attempts to tackle a problem that doesn’t exist (“Conservative censorship“) by attacking a law that actually protects free speech (Section 230), all to be enforced by agencies (like the FCC) that don’t actually have the authority to do anything of the sort. You can’t overrule the law by executive order or regulatory fiat, nor can you ignore the Constitution. The EO is a dumb joke by folks who don’t understand how any of this works, and it should be treated as such.

Instead, most press coverage of the move is still somehow framed as “very serious adult policy,” despite being little more than a glorified brain fart.

The FCC also knows the order is unworkable garbage that flies directly in the face of years of espoused (government hands off) ideology by Ajit Pai, Brendan Carr and friends. And yet, terrified of upsetting dear leader, Pai issued a totally feckless statement on Monday stating the EO would be pushed through the rule-making process, pretending as if this was all just ordinary, sensible tech policy:

This is, you’ll recall, the same guy who spent the last eight years insisting that fairly modest consumer protections governing telecom monopolies (net neutrality, privacy) was a vile example of “government run amok.” It’s the same guy whose entire policy platform revolves around the idea that hands off, limited government oversight universally results in near-mystical outcomes. The order to have the FCC regulate social media giants runs in stark contrast to nearly everything Pai professes to believe, including his adoration of free speech (since eliminating 230 would all but guarantee less of it). And yet he’s completely unwilling to make so much as a cautiously critical peep.

Even if Pai’s worried that he’ll just be replaced by Carr (whose somehow even worse about intellectual consistency) for showing the slightest shred of backbone, there are ways that Pai could express his disdain for this order without upsetting King Donald (perhaps just use big words). But Pai does nothing of the sort. He’s completely selling out everything he believes in to make Donald happy. Not only that, he attempts to frame the idea that we should shut down an idiotic assault on free speech before wasting everybody’s time as itself an attack on free speech.

As a result we’re wasting agency time and taxpayer resources (during a pandemic no less when 42 million Americans lack broadband, something actually under FCC authority) to pursue an inherently dumb and dangerous idea.

Now we move on to the next step in pretending this is real policy: opening the FCC comment system to 45 day of public comments. Except as we saw with the net neutrality repeal (in which the telecom industry used fake and dead people to support terrible and unpopular policy), the FCC doesn’t actually do much to prevent fraud or abuse. So anybody eager to see Silicon Valley saddled with additional regulatory oversight (like its ad competitors in telecom or K Street political operatives) are going to stuff the ballot box with nonsense, taking us further down the rabbit hole of pretending Trump’s EO is serious adult policy making.

In short we’ve got a garbage, unworkable proposal being shuffled through elaborate NTIA and FCC policy making system at taxpayer expense during a crisis, all “supported” by people too afraid of Donald Trump to show even the faintest hint of consistency or backbone. In other words, just another ordinary Monday in Washington.

Filed Under: , , , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “The FCC Knows Trump's Social Media Order Is A Joke, But Fecklessly Pretends Otherwise”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

This should be a non-starter, but was easily predictable

"Today, the @FCC’s Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau will invite public input on the petition for rulemaking recently filed by @CommerceGov regarding #Section230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996.Today, the @FCC’s Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau will invite public input on the petition for rulemaking recently filed by @CommerceGov regarding #Section230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996."

I can’t wait. 90% of the public comments will have to be redacted due to (ahem) unseemly language. The other 10% will be in favor of the FCC whipping out their regulatory baton, though they all originated at the same email address.

Then, so soon as the FCC begins whatever agenda they imagine is appropriate, they will be sued, and it will take a decade or so for it to get to the Supreme Court who will finally, reluctantly, impose 1st Amendment controls over the FCC’s antics.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: This should be a non-starter, but was easily predictable

I can’t wait. 90% of the public comments will have to be redacted due to (ahem) unseemly language. The other 10% will be in favor of the FCC whipping out their regulatory baton, though they all originated at the same email address.

Or they’ll be one hundred word-for-word identical copies of the same letter, just sent with different postal return addresses in the header. Basically, the same sort of nonsense we’re used to when the FCC gets on its high horse about something like "Parents Television Council" vs. FOX "Married By America" – a long list of orchestrated, identical complaints directed (in many cases) against affiliate stations in locations where the supposed complainants can’t actually receive them.

ECA (profile) says:

All laws for all people.

Why then make something specific to 1 thing.
If we enforce this, can we take it to be for everything??
Lets try it against the corps..(not the internet ones)
Lets try it against the gov..

Even with the Constitution, backing free speech. They wish to limit it?
Wasnt there a comment by ‘He who knows less’ about Libel laws? Where he thinks he should be right and everyone else WRONG??

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Rishanp (user link) says:

asian brides

Events wheat berry,what is in a on from West Midlands

Taxpayers to foot the bill to change 10 parking machines including at Worcestershire station used by Gloucestershire and Warwickshire Railway steam trains

‘Worst ever KFC experience’ reviews on Worcestershire’s lowest rated eating venue and takeawayWorcestershire

This KFC and its fried chicken has 1 star review rating on Tripadviser at bottom of all places to eat for Worcestershire

Kidderminster Harriers v West Ham ticket: <a href=>hot viet girl</a> How to see great FA Cup matchWorcestershire

Kidderminster Harries pulled off a huge FA Cup upset by beating champion side Reading

Tragedy as woman’s body employed in canal near KidderminsterWorcestershire

A member of the public spotted the woman in the water at Wolverley and raised the alarm

Pretty Worcestershire village that lured Led Zeppelin’s Robert Plant leaving Black CountryWorcestershire

Led Zeppelin’s Robert Plant entire neighborhood Poundland owner Steve Smith after growing up in Tipton and Halesowen

Jim Davidson show in Midlands may well be axed over ‘racism’ concernsWorcestershire

Evesham councillors supposedly received ‘verbal concerns’ over his risque material

Child, 12, bitten in Kidderminster park by masked bike thief who hit him in the faceWorcestershire

The hooded male hit the boy in the face

The court cases that shocked heathrow and the Black Country in 2021West Mercia PoliceMurderers, Rapists, Drug dealers and domestic abusers were all jailed this year for horrifying crimes

Top rated West Midlands restaurants to try in 2022WorcestershireDiners have been taking to Tripadvisor to rate among the best restaurants in the region

everything required to know about 11 major laws coming in 2022 and why you should follow the rulesWorcestershireNew laws in 2022 will cover crime, Protesting, Covid, business banking, mid-air, Driving and others

Five ways Worcestershire is set to change in 2022 as major projects take shapeWorcestershirestyles across Redditch, Bromsgrove, Worcester, Bewdley and Droitwich are all coming make a point

11 pretty winter walks to savor from Clent and Sutton to Bromsgrove and Sandwell WorcestershireWorcestershire, Birmingham and the Black Country have many pretty places to go for a stroll over the festive period and burn off all the Christmas caloriesAladdin’s cave Redditch petrol station off M42 that still sells cassette tapes and cheap fuelWorcestershireRedditch petrol station store, Off M42 at Branson’s cross punch, Is as an Aladdin’s cave of unique and retro items

WorcestershireThe hidden hotel celebs love near M5 with ‘best views’ of Malvern hills and Cotswolds

England footballer Jamie Vardy and comic Andy Parsons have enjoyed stunning Malvern views when staying in Tewkesbury Park hotel near M5

Family’s tragic appeal to find Janet Edwards, 66, Who faded one month agoWorcestershire

West Mercia Police has created a huge search operation in Herefordshire for 66 year old Janet Edwards.

Rishofa (user link) says:

how to tell if a vietnamese woman likes you

discover To Make Your Next Date A Hit

Many people around the world have interesting stories to tell to their friends when it comes to dating. Some stories would be so humorous that they can draw peels of laughter when narrated. To have a flourishing date, It is essential that one is clear headed about the aim of the date.

The modern days have seen many innovations in every field. The same could apply to dating. conventional methods of dating like personal ads, Dating site web-based exposes you to dangerous situations or people. Telephonic interviews with a prospective date help you overcome this case.

2)plumbing service relating to your prospective date’s background, Their job, place, Habits and significant other status. These questions give you info about your date so that dangerous situations might not arise in the future. You also know the person better.

3)your first dating schedule should be simple and short. A first date must last for duration of an hour or three hours at the most. Such a dating plan would be failsafe besides giving you a choice of not prolonging a date that is not going anywhere.

4)The dating location need to be chosen carefully. it should be chosen with mutual agreement. The location so chosen should be public yet intimate as a crowded one would not be of great help. A nice conversation is a precondition for a successful date.

5)Ensure your precautions. Always inform a close family friend about your dating plans. These include the position of the <a href=>chineseladydate</a&gt; date and your date’s contact information. This is absolutely essential as crimes such as date rape are on the rise.

6)A pledge should be made for trying the date to reach your goals. this is accomplished by sharing the financial burden by both the partners. Not ensuring mutual trust and respect creates hard ambiances, Which are obstacles to a rewarding date.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »