New York Residents Unprotected, Served Up To Criminals By NYPD Employees

from the YEAH-BUT-WE'RE-THE-ONLY-GAME-IN-TOWN dept

Yeah, it’s real easy to sit back and second guess the hard work of law enforcement officers. Secure and safe in our warm homes, far away from the mean streets and thin blue line separating us from the criminal apocalypse, we have it easy. As one of the NYPD’s unions pointed out, citizens like us are clueless. We’ve (and I’m directly quoting here) “grown up on the nipple of what’s easy.” We “have no clue what a NYPD officer does,” and yet we criticize and disparage them.

Then one day — after years of criticism and disparagement and [re-reads tweet] nipples — we’ll find we need them. “Evil will be at our door,” as the NYC PBA says. When that happens, we cop-haters will call for help. We will finally recognize we need them. After all, when all hell breaks loose, who else is going to respond to our calls for help and… um… sell our personal info to insurance scam artists?

Six current and former NYPD employees, which included one cop and five 911 operators, were arrested by the feds as authorities smashed a massive $18 million New York insurance fraud operation, the Daily News learned Thursday.

Police Officer Yaniris Deleon was taken into custody in Manhattan while on duty Wednesday after federal agents surrounded her with assault weapons drawn, sources with knowledge of the case said.

[…]

Deleon, five 911 operators and a supervising 911 operator allegedly provided the medical insurance scammers with names, phone numbers and confidential information about car accident victims. The runners then reached out to the victims and steered them toward clinics that would bill medical insurance companies for treatments and procedures they didn’t need.

This is fantastic news for first responders and New York’s Finest. Not so much because it makes some “bad apples™” look bad, but because it shows them there’s a faster route to extra cash than timecard abuse.

If you give people in power access to a lot of personal info, they will abuse this access eventually. It’s not an “if.” It’s a “when.” Not everyone will abuse this access as much as these government employees did, but a wealth of personal data just a couple of clicks away is a very tempting target. Especially when it can significantly boost the income of the underappreciated heroes keeping the city safe.

According to this report, these employees made about $4,000 a month from feeding personal info to scam artists. It also says operators were promised about $24-30,000 “off the books” for continued supply of contact info, so it’s unclear how much any of the arrested employees actually made assisting scammers. However, this selling of personal data allegedly dates back to 2014.

But the officer and 911 operators were only making pennies on the dollar. The middle men were making themselves millionaires.

The scammers received about $3,000 a referral to attorneys and shady doctors, according to court papers. The group made about 6,000 successful referrals over the last five years, netting about $18 million, officials said.

The names, addresses and contact numbers for about 60,000 car accident victims were steered to the scam artists over the last five years, officials said.

Oh my. This is going to lead to a whole lot of litigation. Government employees misusing their power and access to serve up citizens to scam artists is the sort of abuse that can’t be handled solely through prosecution. The government may go after the involved employees and everyone on the non-government side who benefited from this arrangement, but plenty of residents are going to be legitimately pissed that the government they were told to trust sent them off to undergo unnecessary medical procedures.

Maybe this set of prosecutions will act as a deterrent. Or maybe it will just be seen as the exception to the rule, and abuse of access will continue at its normal pace. Whatever the result, at least more citizens will be aware how much damage the government can do with all the information it demands we relinquish in exchange for government goods and services.

And they’ll see how much of this “thin blue line” crap is self-righteous bullshit. The blue line doesn’t stand between civilians and evil. It stands between cops and accountability. Because if anyone took accountability seriously, this sort of thing would be far rarer than it is. It only becomes common when few people are worried about the potential downsides of abusing their positions. And when it’s common practice, that’s when people start getting caught.

Filed Under: , , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “New York Residents Unprotected, Served Up To Criminals By NYPD Employees”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
20 Comments
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: power corrupts

"If you give people in power access to a lot of personal info, they will abuse this access eventually. It’s not an "if." It’s a "when."

NYC is bigger than many nations in the world and the NYC police forces are bigger than most nations’ armies — that’s a lot of centralized power for municipal government.

Of course this NYPD insurance scam is trivial in the lonnng history of NYPD corruption.
Two NY cops were recently convicted as Mob hit-men … as they worked full time on the NYPD Organized Crime Task Force.
The movie "Serpico" was based on true NYPD events.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Norahc (profile) says:

We "have no clue what a NYPD officer does," and yet we criticize and disparage them.

Besides stop and frisk, choke holds, shooting bystanders and cops, terrorism investigations and now kickbacks?

One wonders where they would have the time to do what they’re supposed to be doing.

Anonymous Coward says:

New York City has a special breed of hardcore criminal that few other cities have to deal with: violent, smart, fast, armed, in gangs, on a very limited number of streets, trains, bridges, tunnels, and waterways where one or two bad apples can ruin things for thousands of people an HOUR. That doesn’t even account for all the other criminals, mafia, etc.

The thin blue line is real.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

And a lot of cops are in that group of hardcore criminals as well as brutal human rights violators. If the job is too difficult, maybe change occupations. Of course we need police – do you imagine anyone disputes that? But they should operate within the law, and be subject to the same laws and rules as the rest of us.

ECA (profile) says:

lets do this..

When you have a child,
Which do you pay attention to…
The good they do,
The bad they do,
going to church and praying,
Learning all the nice rules to live by that dont work, or finding the ones that DO.. Legal or not..

think hard now..
WHO gives you the prizes and gifts…(wants something from you)
The ones that Only abuse you when you are bad..(want to correct you)
those that let you LEARN THE HARD WAY, on your own..(want you to learn the Hard/best ways..)

Think hard now.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...