Broward County School Board Gets Hit With Anti-SLAPP Suit After Trying To Punish Paper For Exposing Its Redaction Failure

from the could-be-a-costly-unforced-error dept

Last week, the Broward County School Board went after a Florida newspaper, claiming it should be held in contempt of court for publishing information the school district didn’t properly redact. The Sun Sentinel obtained a copy of the Parkland school shooter’s educational records as the result of a public records suit. Certain information was redacted — or at least was supposed to be — to comply with state and federal privacy laws.

What was delivered to the Sun Sentinel by the district had black redaction bars covering two-thirds of the document. Unfortunately, the redactions were merely cosmetic. Anyone with a copy of the PDF could select the “redacted” text in the PDF and paste it into a text editor to see what was supposed to have been withheld. The school board screwed up, making it possibly liable for privacy law violations, but it went to court claiming it was all the Sun Sentinel’s fault anyone’s privacy got violated.

The Sun Sentinel has now responded — both with an editorial middle finger and a filing in court. (h/t Brittany Wallman) If everything goes the Sun Sentinel’s way, not only will it not face contempt charges (there’s been no ruling on the motion, so it appears the judge doesn’t believe closing barn doors post-livestock exodus qualifies as an emergency), but might collect some cash from the school district for trying to silence the paper.

From the motion [PDF]:

In a rush to deflect from its own negligence in publicly disclosing the CEN (Collaborative Educational Network) report at issue in a wholly unsecured format, the School Board now seeks to have this Court find the Sun Sentinel in contempt for exercising their First Amendment rights to truthfully report on a matter of the highest public concern: the exact nature of the special educational services the School District provided (or notably failed to provide) to Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School (“MSD”) shooter Nikolas Cruz—who now stands charged with multiple counts of capital murder. On their face, neither the civil court’s operative July 26, 2018 order (the “Civil Order”)—requiring the School District to disclose a redacted version of the CEN report—nor the criminal court’s August 3, 2018 order (the “Criminal Order”) in any way limited the Sun Sentinel’s ability to publish the report’s contents. Indeed, to have done so would have constituted an unconstitutional prior restraint.

By posting an improperly redacted version of the CEN report to its website for public download, the School District itself may have failed to comply with the court’s orders. In any event, there is no dispute that the Sun Sentinel lawfully obtained the report from the School District’s website and the information sought to be shielded by the redactions. Under such circumstances the law is clear: a First Amendment right to publish firmly attaches and no contempt proceeding may lie.

The motion points out the court never restricted what the paper could publish. Any court-ordered redactions were the responsibility of the school district, which was being sued for refusing to release the report at all. The in camera review conducted determined what could and couldn’t be redacted by the school board. It had nothing to do with the Sun Sentinel, which was only the recipient of a document ordered to be produced. The paper acquired the document lawfully — as did anyone else who downloaded the version with the faulty redaction. It was under no legal obligation to withhold information the school board meant to withhold, but didn’t.

Even though the school district claims it handled everything correctly in regards to the Parkland school shooter, the Sun Sentinel points out in its editorial there are a handful of details that show school administrators mishandled situations involving a volatile student.

School officials didn’t properly advise Cruz of his legal options when he was faced with removal from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School his junior year, leading him to give up special education services.

When Cruz failed to file the required written rejection of special education services, school officials nudged him, writing it up for him to sign.

The district “did not follow through” on Cruz’s subsequent request to return to the therapeutic environment of Cross Creek School for special education students.

The contempt motion looks like nothing more than a punitive move by the school board to punish a news outlet for exposing its mistakes to the world. If this anti-SLAPP motion secures a ruling in favor of the paper, the board’s attempt to punish the news outlet for publishing lawfully-obtained documents will put taxpayers on the hook for the paper’s legal fees.

Filed Under: , , , , , , ,
Companies: broward county school, sun-sentinel

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Broward County School Board Gets Hit With Anti-SLAPP Suit After Trying To Punish Paper For Exposing Its Redaction Failure”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Hero says:

SunSentinal: “We are committed to digging into all aspects of this tragedy and the issues it raises for our community. We believe that a well informed public will find solutions.”

Broward County School Board: We are committed to providing a safe and educational environment for students, except in cases where we fail to do that.

DannyB (profile) says:

There is a lesson to be learned here

If anything can be learned from this redaction failure it is that software makers need to be more careful in the design of their user interface.

A software feature that allows you to draw black bars over text while leaving the text intact should be clearly labeled as Redaction Tool.

That will enable the world to more fully benefit from redacted documents.

Anonymous Hero says:

Re: There is a lesson to be learned here

A software feature that allows you to draw black bars over text while leaving the text intact should be clearly labeled as Redaction Tool.

Do you mean it should NOT be called Redaction Tool? The whole point of this article is that they drew black bars over text and left the text intact, i.e., they failed to redact it.

That Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

One does wonder how many times we’ve never learned a shooters motivations b/c we’re protecting “their” privacy by not releasing the documents that show a long history of the board failing to follow their own policy or state & federal law because its easier to just pass the buck to society to deal with.

They screwed this kid repeatedly, didn’t do much of what his needs & the law required and they really really don’t want people to see how their actions contributed to an isolated child becoming more isolated & more despondent & angry. Someone might try to lay some blame at their feet for that happened… while he pulled the trigger everytime they failed him they put another bullet in the clip.

Isn’t it neat how they can hide their actions behind a cloak of we never knew nothing…

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Older Stuff
09:29 Canadian Court Upholds 'God Given Right' To Give Your Obnoxious Neighbor The Finger (26)
13:37 Appeals Court Says Nope To Florida Governor's 'Stop Woke' Law, Denies Request To Lift Injunction Against It (22)
12:04 Setting 1st Amendment Myths On Fire In A Crowded Theater (157)
09:18 Is Gavin Newsom Attacking Walgreens For Its Choices Different From DeSantis Attacking Disney? (142)
10:48 Fifth Circuit Passes Up Opportunity To Correct Ruling That Said Gov't Retaliation Against Protected Speech Is Fine (9)
12:06 Another Day, Another Blatant Attack On The 1st Amendment From The Florida GOP (125)
09:34 New DeSantis-Endorsed Florida Bill An Outright Attack On The 1st Amendment And Free Speech (106)
09:21 Getting Kicked Off Social Media For Breaking Its Rules Is Nothing Like Being Sent To A Prison Camp For Retweeting Criticism Of A Dictator (243)
05:26 It's Time To Codify The 'NY Times v. Sullivan' Standard Into Law (57)
12:11 Free Speech Absolutist Elon Musk Pulls Down Documentary About India PM Modi (26)
10:43 Appeals Court Judge Suggests Hate Speech Shouldn't Be Protected In Decision Against Students Expelled For Bigoted Social Media Posts (40)
09:30 Saudi Government Narrative Control Efforts Now Include The Jailing Of Wikipedia Administrators (61)
15:36 Court Reminds St. Louis City Council That Blocking Taxpayers On Social Media Violates 1st Amendment (15)
13:28 Yes, Elon Musk Is Fucking Up Twitter; But No, The Government Has No Business Getting Involved (118)
10:50 Congress Is About To Make This Post Telling You When To Celebrate SCOTUS Justice Birthdays Illegal (47)
10:44 Actual Free Speech Matters, Elon Musk's Understanding Of It Puts Free Speech At Risk (210)
12:03 The First Amendment Needs To Protect Everyone (Even Homophobic Web Designers) To Protect Anyone (248)
10:45 First Circuit Trims First Amendment, Upholds New Hampshire's Criminal Defamation Law (10)
12:48 Court Tells Florida Town That Law Forbidding Resident's 'Fuck Trump' Sign Is Unconstitutional (19)
12:26 Iowa City Officials Prove They Aren't Fascists By Arresting An Activist Twice For Calling Them Fascists (13)
09:42 Elon Musk's First Move Is To Fire The Person Most Responsible For Twitter's Strong Free Speech Stance (311)
10:50 Brazil's Governments Amps Up Anti-Free Speech Tactics Ahead Of National Election (12)
12:18 Saudi Arabia Imprisons An American Citizen For 16 Years Over Critical Tweets (22)
15:31 Some Good News: Planet Aid Agrees To Pay $1.9 Million To Settle Its SLAPP Suit Against Reveal News (1)
12:23 Turkey Still Thinks It Hasn't Jailed Enough Journalists, Add Prison Sentences To Its 'Fake News' Law (3)
09:31 John Stossel Loses His Pathetic SLAPP Suit Against Facebook And Fact Checkers (91)
15:53 Vietnamese Government Pushes Plan To Restrict Dissemination Of News Stories By Social Media Platforms (17)
10:43 California Governor Signs Bill Forbidding The Use Of Rap Lyrics As Criminal Evidence (12)
10:45 The Onion Files Hilarious Amicus Brief In An Important Case, And Actually Makes A Key Point In The Best Way Possible (23)
09:31 There Are Real Threats To Free Speech Everywhere. Cancel Culture Is Far Down The List (340)
More arrow