Malaysian Government Decides To Dump Its Terrible Anti-Fake News Law

from the UN-letter-writing-campaign-works dept

Malaysia’s government seized upon the term “fake news” as a way to silence coverage of internal corruption. The new law gave the government a way to steer narratives and control negative coverage, going beyond its already-tight control of local media. It would have worked out well for Prime Minister Najib Razak, who was facing a lot of negative coverage over the sudden and unexplained appearance of $700 million in his bank account.

Razak is no longer Prime Minister. His replacement, Mahathir Mohamad, claimed he would abolish the law if elected. Once elected, Mohamad walked back his promise, replacing “abolish” with “modify.” In the meantime, the law had already claimed at least one victim, a Danish national visiting Malaysia who made dubious claims on YouTube about police response time following the shooting of an activist.

UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression, David Kaye, had already officially complained to Malaysia’s government about its “fake news” law and the damage it would do free speech. The government appeared to have ignored this in favor of protecting itself from free speech. The outgoing prime minister may not have needed this “protection” following his ejection from the public sector, but the new boss seemingly was in no hurry to give up this new power over the press.

Surprise, surprise! David Kaye now reports the Malaysian government is dumping this terrible law, effective almost immediately. In a letter to Kaye, Malaysia’s UN ambassador states the government had reversed course on punishing fake news.

I wish to inform you that the new Government of Malaysia has decided to repeal the Anti-Fake News Act 2018. The process to do so has already begun, and a specific proposal is expected to be tabled during the upcoming Parliamentary session beginning on 16 July 2018.

This may be Prime Minister Mohamad belatedly making good on his campaign promise — one he had broken immediately after taking office by offering to “redefine” the law rather than repeal it. This is good news for Malaysian journalists (as well as Dutch visitors), who may now avoid jail sentences or fines for publishing stuff the government doesn’t agree with.

Filed Under: , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Malaysian Government Decides To Dump Its Terrible Anti-Fake News Law”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

Give Mahathir some slack

Mahathir Mohamad was previously Prime Minister for over 20 years and quite the authoritarian. He had Anwar Ibrahim, his erstwhile protege, jailed on trumped-up charges, did not tolerate dissent, etc. He rejoined politics at the age of 92 because of the corruption and malaise his laws had created after his retirement.

Once back in power, it looks like he was reliving his past with this fake news law, but now has fortunately repealed the law. He did release Ibrahim from gaol as he promised, let’s see how things develop. I think there must be some heavy cultural barriers for criticising authorities in S.E. Asia, this will take time to overcome.

Anonymous Coward says:

I looked at those Russian "fake news" posts.

and what I saw was a bunch of race baiting or similar, which was uniformly consistent with the kind of race baiting that is used by the mass media news in this country.

If they were doing it with a PAC it was perfectly legal, so sayeth SCOTUS and Citizens United v. SEC. Notably the race baiting that drastically increased by radio syndication expansion after the Clinton telcom deregulation, in my experience was way worse. It totally saturated rural areas, and was often broadcast during worktime in shops to employees who often had no alternative but to have that bullshit pumped into their heads.

IOW, the combined efforts of Bill Clinton and Rush Limbaugh make the Russian “Fake News” Conspiracy look like a bunch of pussies.

So all these flailing assholes in the news did by manufacturing a “Fake News” meme was empower third world countries with a tool they could use to opress their own citizenry, while remaining largely exempt from WTO sanctions. Because hey, if the Yanks can do it, so can we.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Older Stuff
13:30 A Reagan Judge, The First Amendment, And The Eternal War Against Pornography (63)
12:27 Yelp Asks Court To Stop Texas AG Ken Paxton From Suing Them For Warning Users That Crisis Pregnancy Centers Are Scams (51)
13:20 'Porn' Is A Human Right (58)
11:54 American Library Association Data Shows The Party Of Free Speech Is Doing More Than Ever To Silence Speech (83)
10:40 5th Circuit Decides To Rehear Jawboning Case Involving Disinfo Researchers, Realizes It Can't Do That Yet, Changes Mind Hours Later (8)
10:56 Federal Judge Says Fuck The 1st Amendment While Upholding Public University's Drag Show Ban (91)
10:39 White House, States Try To Convince Supreme Court In Jawboning Case (73)
20:09 Delaware State Police Pay $50,000 To Man Troopers Ticketed For Flipping Them Off (23)
09:36 Supreme Court Puts 5th Circuit Ruling On Biden Admin Jawboning Of Social Media Companies On Hold For Shadow Docket Review (41)
10:45 New Jersey Appeals Court Says Even Some Forms Of Harassment Are Protected Speech (27)
13:38 Another Day, Another SLAPP Threat From A ‘Wellness’ Influencer Against Someone Reviewing Their ‘Masterclass’ (16)
09:31 5th Circuit Cleans Up District Court’s Silly Jawboning Ruling About the Biden Admin, Trims It Down To More Accurately Reflect The 1st Amendment (40)
09:27 Court Tosses Arkansas Age Verification Law For Violating The 1st Amendment (16)
15:20 Texas Ruling Shows You Can't Regulate Online Pornography Like A Public Health Crisis (25)
13:30 Court Says Texas’ Adult Content Age Verification Law Clearly Violates The 1st Amendment (35)
12:50 State Governments Can't Resist The Siren Song Of Censorship (81)
10:50 Fifth Circuit Denies Immunity To Detective Who Arrested A Man For A Satirical Facebook Post (21)
12:44 Montana’s Response To Lawsuits Over Laughably Unconstitutional TikTok Ban Is To Say That TikTok Is The Equivalent Of ‘Cancer-Causing Radio’ (19)
09:25 ‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk Suggests He’s Going To Sue George Soros… For His Free Speech Advocating For Certain Laws (129)
10:47 Jordan's King Approves Bill That Criminalizes Online Anonymity, Publication Of Police Officers Names/Photos (14)
10:58 Kansas Cops Raid Small Town Newspaper In Extremely Questionable 'Criminal Investigation' (26)
09:22 Tennessee Teen Sues School For Suspending Him After He Posted Memes Mocking His Principal (15)
11:57 ‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk Files Obvious SLAPP Suit Against Non-Profit Critic (49)
10:58 Prime Minister's Brother Latest Victim Of Singapore's 'Fake News' Law (5)
13:45 Court: Injunction Blocking Florida's Anti-Drag Law Applies To Everyone Affected By It, Not Just Venue That Sued It (35)
09:31 How Would The GOP Feel If Democrats In Congress Demanded Details Regarding How Fox News Or The NY Post Made Editorial Decisions? (267)
10:46 Republican AGs Decide That Coercive Jawboning Is Good, Actually (When They Do It) (28)
10:49 Ninth Circuit Dumps Oregon's 'Surreptitious Recording' Law, Handing A First Amendment Win To Project Veritas (35)
10:52 In 303 Creative, By Happily Helping One Bigot, SCOTUS (Perhaps Inadvertently) Helped The Larger Fight Against Bigotry (168)
09:24 EU And Elon Battle Over The New Internet Regulations That Elon Himself Endorsed Last Year (14)
More arrow