Famous Billy Goat Tavern Initiates Risky Trademark Dispute With Billy Goat Chip Co.

from the here-comes-the-blowback dept

Missing from far too many of the stories we post on trademark bullies is anything amounting to blowback. While it happens on occasion, the reason that trademark bullying works is due to the costs for any sort of defense, nevermind the cost that would be required to actually go on the offense against a bully. Still, that isn’t to say that when a trademark bully picks a fight that it cannot sometimes lead to a backfire.

That appears to be the risk Chicago’s famous Billy Goat Tavern now faces after it sued Billy Goat Chip Co., given the countersuit and factual response made by the chip company. Billy Goat Tavern filed suit in 2017, alleging that the St. Louis potato chip maker was infringing on its trademark with its name and logo, which uses the silhouette of a rearing billy goat. For what it’s worth, the tavern’s logo is completely different and features a fully detailed cartoon head of a goat, not a black outline like the chip company.

But based on the information in the countersuit, it seems there is much more factual information the tavern ought to have considered before filing its initial lawsuit.

Attorneys representing the Billy Goat Chip Co. filed a counterclaim this month arguing the chip maker was actually the first to use the “Billy Goat” mark in connection with packaged retail food and beverage products.

The suit stated Billy Goat Tavern’s trademark was limited to only “tavern and restaurant services” and was later applied to packaged retail food and beverage products when the tavern started selling items such as frozen burger patties and canned beer through third-party vendors in 2017.

Oops. While the Billy Goat is indeed famous, it is famous for being a tavern. It did not even sell any retail packaged foodstuffs until the past year or so and never had a trademark for those market designations until the same time frame. Billy Goat Chip Co., on the other hand, has been selling its goods for a decade and has the trademark registration to match. In its countersuit, the chip company blasts Billy Goat Tavern for being the trademark bully it is.

To compensate for its tardiness in entering the retail food/beverage products market, Billy Goat IP has undertaken a campaign of deceptive trade practices, false advertising, misusing trademarks, misusing registration symbols, and misusing the Billy Goat Tavern Marks … in an effort to improperly injure and damage Billy Goat Chip Co..

The upshot being that Billy Goat Chips Co. is asking not only for the trademark lawsuit to be dismissed, but is also asking for damages for the tavern’s false advertising and deceptive trade practices. Oh, and it is also asking the court to order the tavern to cease using the Billy Goat name for any packaged foods, the exact request the tavern initially sued over.

If the chip company wins, it would represent as clean a backfire from trademark bullying as I can remember. It would also be a helpful warning shot to other trademark bullies about what can happen.

Filed Under: , ,
Companies: billy goat chip company, billy goat tavern

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Famous Billy Goat Tavern Initiates Risky Trademark Dispute With Billy Goat Chip Co.”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
20 Comments
Anonymous Coward says:

I swear there’s a band of copyright lawyers touring across America right now; meeting with taverns, brewers and anyone else involved in the alcohol industry; offering their services to sue the crap out of anyone they like.

These stories are getting more and more common. It’s like the new thing now to sue people if you’re in the business of making or serving beer.

santosh kumar (profile) says:

digital marketing course in noida

Online structures consist of YouTube video, Facebook, Twitter, Interest, e-mail, web and cell. Digital Marketing is one of the fastest growing industries and it has been observed that an increasing number of human beings want to be a part of it.

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-web-development-training-course-institute-center-in-noida.php“>web development training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-web-development-training-course-institute-center-in-noida-city-center.php“>web development training course in noida city center</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

machine learning training in Noida sector 62

It is globally identified as a general in expert education. Before you take any step at being global expert, you first need to degree your wishes for it. SAP training is delivered the world over by way of authorized and depended on companions of SAP. Various advantages may be reaped from SAP education. These advantages can be reaped with the aid of an man or woman or an organization
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-machine-learning-training-institute-in-noida-sector-63.php“>machine learning training in Noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Email-Marketing-Training-course-in-Noida-sector-63.php“>Email marketing training course in noida sector 63</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

Digital Marketing Training Center in Noida Sector 16

The organisation need to cautiously accumulate the e-mail addresses that it will goal and shopping for the so-called "lists", which have been created for a totally special cause is a very awful method. Those lists of emails are going to be inexpensive and easier to find, however the pleasant is going to be immeasurably worse.

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-Devops-training-institute-in-noida.php“>devops training in center noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Blue-Prism-training_Course_institute_noida_delhi.php“>blue prism training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-Cloud-Computing-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-15-16-18.php“>cloud computing training in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/big-data-hadoop-training-institute-noida-delhi-ncr.php“>hadoop training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-python-training-institute-in-noida-sector-15-near-metro-station.php“>python training in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/SAP_SCM_SD_SRM_Training_in_Noida.php“>sap sd training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-linux-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-62.php“>linux training center in noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Email-Marketing-Training-course-in-Noida-sector-15.php“>Email marketing training course in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-openstack-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-15-16-18.php“>openstack training in noida sector 15</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

Digital Marketing Training Center in Noida Sector 15

Once the organization has the customers’ facts and the emails are sent, they can maintain song of wrong e-mail addresses, views at the website of the business, wonderful and negative critiques in addition to boom within the income. Information approximately clicks according to link, how many people have read the emails and what is the demographics the campaign had reached can be vital.

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-machine-learning-training-institute-in-noida-sector-62.php“>machine learning training in Noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 64</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-AWS-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-63.php“>AWS training institute center in Noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/course/Best-Android-Apps-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-15.php“>android training center in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 18</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

salesforce training in noida sector 15

The cloud global is coming up with new technologies sometimes to ease how corporations meet up their dreams and boost up profit era. Salesforce training could turn out to a awesome assist given that organizations are simply depending on the CRM for dealing with business activities and accelerating earnings technology. Learning to handle Salesforce is possibly to poise numerous outstanding opportunities for career development.

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-Devops-training-institute-in-noida.php“>devops training in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Email-Marketing-Training-course-in-Noida-sector-62.php“>Email marketing training course in noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-Devops-training-institute-in-noida.php“>devops training in center noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Blue-Prism-training_Course_institute_noida_delhi.php“>blue prism training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-Cloud-Computing-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-15-16-18.php“>cloud computing training in noida sector 15</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

salesforce training in noida sector 18

They will always assume you to treat them with the utmost professionalism and unsurpassed care. It is quite sure that presenting customized recommendations, services, and satisfaction to a client base that counts as much as lots or millions might be a difficult undertaking. Well, you’re fortunate sufficient with the advanced technologies that permit you to attain out to hundreds of thousands of customers with equal perfection.

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/big-data-hadoop-training-institute-noida-delhi-ncr.php“>hadoop training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-python-training-institute-in-noida-sector-15-near-metro-station.php“>python training in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/SAP_SCM_SD_SRM_Training_in_Noida.php“>sap sd training center in noida</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-linux-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-62.php“>linux training center in noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Email-Marketing-Training-course-in-Noida-sector-15.php“>Email marketing training course in noida sector 15</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

salesforce training in noida sector 62

They will always assume you to treat them with the utmost professionalism and unsurpassed care. It is quite sure that presenting customized recommendations, services, and satisfaction to a client base that counts as much as lots or millions might be a difficult undertaking. Well, you’re fortunate sufficient with the advanced technologies that permit you to attain out to hundreds of thousands of customers with equal perfection.

<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-openstack-training-institute-center-in-noida-sector-15-16-18.php“>openstack training in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-machine-learning-training-institute-in-noida-sector-62.php“>machine learning training in Noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 64</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-AWS-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-63.php“>AWS training institute center in Noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/course/Best-Android-Apps-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-15.php“>android training center in noida sector 15</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 18</a>

honey1994 (profile) says:

salesforce training in noida sector 63

With the distinction of contemporary technologies, businessmen without problems find themselves among a community of lots and hundreds of thousands of clients. But what if you have to be depending on the delight and needs of simplest one purchaser? Will you continue to misplace statistics? Will you still take into account referring them to extraordinary departments to get answers to their questions? Will you stop striving for offering services or products that own the highest fine?

<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-AWS-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-62.php“>Best-AWS-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-62.php</a&gt;
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/Best-data-science-with-machine-learning-training-institute-in-noida-sector-63.php“>machine learning training in Noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://www.webtrackker.com/salesforce-lightning-training-center-institute-in-noida-sector-15-16-3-18-63-62-64.php“>salesforce training in noida sector 62</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Email-Marketing-Training-course-in-Noida-sector-63.php“>Email marketing training course in noida sector 63</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-AWS-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-64.php“>AWS training institute center in Noida sector 64</a>
<a href="http://webtrackker.com/course/Best-Android-Apps-training-institute-center-in-Noida-sector-63.php“>android training center in noida sector 63</a>

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...