Long Trail Brewing Sues East Coast Apparel Company Over 'Take A Hike' T-Shirt
from the seriously,-take-one dept
The last time we checked in with Long Trail Brewing, the Vermont brewery was busy fighting a Minnesota brewer that had dared to put a stick figure of a hiker on its beer can. It seems that rather than basing its trademark legal expeditions on any real or potential customer confusion, Long Trail views trademark law as a vehicle for monopoly and lawsuit-driven income. Long Trail is certainly not alone in this view, unfortunately, but it does have a penchant for taking this sort of thing to ridiculous lengths.
Such as going after an apparel company for a simple t-shirt using an incredibly generic phrase, for instance. Long Trail has initiated a trademark lawsuit with a company called Chowdaheadz because the latter dared to make a shirt with the phrase “Take a hike” on it. As the filing explains, Long Trail has trademarked the phrase for its use and has sold apparel with the phrase on it.
8. Long Trail is, and it has been since the 1990’s, engaged in the business of selling apparel and other products under the trademark Take a Hike. Since late last century, Long Trail has continuously used the trademark Take a Hike in connection with its apparel, beer and other products.
9. Long Trail has expended and continues to expend a substantial amount of resources using, advancing, and promoting its trademark Take a Hike and the products and services with which it uses the trademark.
10. Long Trail is engaged in a variety of socially and environmentally conscious efforts in the Vermont community and has used its trademark Take a Hike in support of those efforts.
Apparel is indeed among the trademarks Long Trail has for the phrase. However, on so common a phrase as “Take a hike”, one imagines the bar for customer confusion is quite high. That is all the more so when the target for an infringement suit, in this case Chowdaheadz, uses the phrase in a way that calls nothing about Long Trail, or any other beer for that matter, to mind. Long Trail can and does attempt to drive the point that its use of the phrase on a number of mediums has created a public association with the brewery… but that’s ridiculous. Nobody traveling to the Chowdaheadz website and perusing the cornucopia of apparel it has there, and then coming across the following t-shirt, is going to somehow conclude that there is any association with Long Trail.
If you can find customer confusion in that t-shirt, you’ve got a brain malfunction. It’s also worth noting that there are roughly a zillion companies out there with “Take a hike” t-shirts, so why Chowdaheadz has been singled out for this legal action is puzzling. For its part, Chowdaheadz says it isn’t backing down. In its response to Long Trail’s initial threats, its legal team said:
While we appreciate that your client has used “TAKE A HIKE” on clothing and miscellaneous items for many years, we must point out that the phrase itself appears in every English-language dictionary in publication, and has been in widespread public use since at least as early as 1809. It is the epitome of the type of common, generic phrase that should not be monopolized by a single owner.
To illustrate this point, representative examples of clothing items for sale with the phrase “Take a Hike” on them are attached to this letter. You will note that Google retrieved listings for 642,000 such items in 0.46 seconds. You may also note that my client’s item appeared as the top search result, while, in contrast, your client did not appear at all.
It’s hard to see how a claim of either genericide or that the phrase was generic prior to Long Trail’s registration won’t be seen to have merit. In other words, Long Trail risks losing its trademark entirely by being the bully. I’m struggling to see how this was anything resembling an intelligent business decision by the brewery.
Filed Under: beer, clothing, take a hike, trademark
Companies: chowdaheadz, long tail brewing
Comments on “Long Trail Brewing Sues East Coast Apparel Company Over 'Take A Hike' T-Shirt”
"How dare you do it better than us!"
You may also note that my client’s item appeared as the top search result, while, in contrast, your client did not appear at all.
I suspect that that might be the main reason for the lawsuit. The target’s product is more successful than the products offered by the one suing, and they must be punished for it.
It’s a stupid lawsuit that has the potential to backfire and invalidate the trademark(which never should have been granted in the first place), but when considered a knee-jerk response to someone else doing better than them it does make at least some sense.
Re: "How dare you do it better than us!"
Irrelevant. Much more important than the web search ranking is the law company ranking. This isn’t Timbuktu.
If you succeeded once, do it again!
Not that I disagree with “How dare yoiu do it beter!”, but…
These guys have been successful once being trademark bullies and trolls, so they are trying it again.
Hopefully a good judge will toss it and award attorney’s fees for the trouble.
Re: If you succeeded once, do it again!
Attorney’s fees would be nice, but what really needs to happen is for them to lose the trademark. ‘Take a hike’ is absurdly generic, the idea that a single company should have the legal rights to it and be able to sue others for using it is ridiculous.
Re: Re: Creating unique marks
What ever happened to having to spell common words in a unique way to be able to get a trademark? Such as “Kamera Korner” or other misspellings of words. You shouldn’t be able to trademark common words or phrases.
Re: Re: Re: Creating unique marks
Tell that to Apple (both Apple Computers and Apple Records and their already well-acquainted lawyers). And can you imagine what would happen if a nerf ball company printed “Windows compatible” on their products?
Re: Re: Re:2 Creating unique marks
Depends on whether they sell window frames or not.
Re: Re: Re:3 Creating unique marks
People selling lactose-free milk do not need to deal in lactose-intolerant slaves to be allowed to advertise their milk.
In my youth, we played quite a bit with windows incompatible balls, over the years racking up quite a bit of window pane bills. The ball companies were not really colluding with the window companies even though driving their profits.
Re: Re: Re: Teik a Haik! lol
Agreed, the mark should be tossed as well as the suit!
I get so tired hearing this company suing that company all the time over moronic garbage that is preclusive to protecting trademarks and copyrights. Its a fucking wonder America gets anything done at all.
Boy, Long Trail sure does engage in a lot of activities. Too bad making good beer is not one of them
Re: Sue your way to success!
It’s the new business model…make a crappy product, sue the competition, profit when they pay you to go away …. see also East Texas, copyright trolls and crappy films!
Has this brewery sued the Park Service et al. yet for daring to run the Appalachian Trail?
Re: Re:
And have they sued Duluth Trading Co. Because Duluth’s "Long Tail" t-shirt style sounds just sooo similar to "Long Trail?"
I think Long Trail Brewing should change their name to
“Monster Long Trail Brewing and take a long walk off a short pier after which they could take a hike and step off.
Never heard of them... Until now...
Re: Never heard of them... Until now...
But… I never heard of Long Trail Brewing…
Not in the entire time I’ve been drinking beer…
I’ve heard the the phase “Take a Hike”.
I’ve been telling people to “Take a hike” since the 70s…
So now the first time I hear of this brewery, it’s in regard to them suing someone over a common phrase…
This is a great way of getting people to know your brand… Look like a greedy copyright trolling bunch of douchebags.
Duh
Let’s tell Long Trail to “take a hike”
Re: Duh
I wondered how many comments would be needed before we took this path…
They should have gone the Randazza-Snark path and told them explicitly to “Take a Hike” in their response letter – lets hope it happens in the court fillings 🙂
Just more proof that Google is evil!
I would suggest going to their FB page and letting them know how you feel.. These guys are a joke:
https://www.facebook.com/longtrailbrewingco
Seriously?
I think Long Trail forgets that they are a “Brewing” company not an “Apparel” company. Stay in your lane!
That shirt certainly confused this customer
Because it clearly says “Take a Hake”. What does a scenic mountain vista have to do with hake? That’s no place for a fish.
(BTW, Chowdaheadz. If you use that argument in your defense I expect a fee.)