US Intelligence Agencies To Americans Travelling Abroad: Trust No One, Use Burner Phones, They're All Out To Get You
from the just-because-you're-paranoid... dept
The Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) has been going through something of an awkward phase the last few years. The Office, which is a part of the White House, and is supposed to direct and coordinate various parts of the intelligence community, has been trying to figure out how to be more open and “transparent” to the public since the Snowden documents began flowing. Given that historically the intelligence community has focused on being as secret as is humanly possible, it’s not very good at this whole transparency thing. And sometimes it’s just really, really awkward. Just try (really) to watch this video it put out on Wednesday, telling US travelers abroad to fear everyone and everything.
That’s not to say that there isn’t some good advice mixed in there, but it’s mixed in with some ridiculous claims, an overreaching level of paranoia, and some incredibly bad acting. The basic premise, though, is that wherever you go, even if you’re visiting a US ally country, basically every person you meet has an ulterior motive, and it’s to get your digital stuff. The border patrol guy who welcomes you to the country clicks a button that says “INITIATE SURVEILLANCE” (literally) and apparently suddenly every living human being in this foreign country now knows to spy on Frank.
He checks into his hotel, and the person at the front desk is friendly, but apparently having been tipped off by border patrol to spy on Frank, she immediately texts his room number to a sketchy guy. We know he’s sketchy because he wears a leather jacket. When Frank heads out of his hotel room, he puts his tablet in the room safe, and as soon as he’s gone, Mr. Sketchy comes in and opens the safe and downloads everything. To be clear: hotels are not very secure and people get electronics stolen all the time. And, yes, if you’re a serious target, people may target your electronics. Of course, many of those people may actually work for the US government. Isn’t that part of how the NSA hacks into various global companies? It seems like this video is giving up more US procedures than anything else.
Then the video just gets weirder. A smug asshole shows up claiming he’s someone who “knows better” and tells Frank not to bring so many electronic gadgets with him. He actually recommends getting a burner phone and a throwaway email address for travel overseas. Yes, this is part of the same US intelligence community that has talked about how burner phones have created problems for its surveillance efforts, though which these days also is pretty good at connecting burner phones to individuals by merging various databases together. Smug guy also says not to post on Facebook (or, rather, “Friend Basket” in the video) that you’ll be travelling overseas. Now, that’s also not necessarily a bad recommendation, but it depends on context quite a bit. If the fear is that you’re alerting foreigners to target you, given the earlier paranoia in the video, it’s unlikely that those targeting you are finding out because of your social media posts.
Then, the paranoia goes deeper. Frank meets a woman and they agree to go for drinks. Smug Jackass basically says that anyone that friendly to Frank must be evil. Then, he reminds Frank never to send a work email, even though he’s traveling for work. And then he actually says: “Besides, who’s got time for work? You’re traveling! Get out there! Live a little!” Remember that literally a minute earlier, Smug Guy was berating Frank for doing exactly that.
Yes, there are certainly some people where this kind of thing applies to them when travelling abroad. But this video isn’t likely to help them, and it applies to a fairly limited population of people. Meanwhile, this video really kinda reveals the paranoia with which the US intelligence community lives. They spy on absolutely everyone, so they assume that absolutely everyone is getting spied on everywhere as well. It’s also somewhat bizarre that they’re pushing disposable email and burner phones on people while warning about terrorists using the same.
The key messages: the US intelligence community is creepy and smug, and they want you to be deathly terrified of anyone you encounter in a foreign country.
Filed Under: burner phones, odni, spies, surveillance, travelling, video
Comments on “US Intelligence Agencies To Americans Travelling Abroad: Trust No One, Use Burner Phones, They're All Out To Get You”
intelligence community logic
If an American truly loved America, they would never want to go anywhere outside America. (“There are foreigners out there!”) Therefore, anyone who travels outside America must hate America and therefore needs to be surveilled at all times.
(PS. We need a budget increase to cover all that surveillance…)
Reminds me of the "Travel Agency" in the Truman Show
This reminds me of the Travel Agency in the Truman Show, with helpful posters on the while reminding you of things like the danger of the plane being struck by lightning.
Its a trick I tell you, as only bad guys use burnet phones, this is a way to be able to put all travellers on a list.
/Conspiracy theory, I hope.
Re: Re:
No you are correct.
If people on list cannot_______________ (we’ll start with “come into our country”, but it could be anything).
Then the bigger the list the more people cannot_______________
Followed by, since so many people cannot do _______________anyway, we might as well get rid of _______________
It is the new workaround for that pesky constitution thingy.
US Intelligence Agencies To Americans in America: Trust us, you don’t need burner phones, only bad guys use encryption.
It’s a good idea to take a cheap burner phone anyway, lest border control thugs decide they’re going to rifle through and/or keep your main one.
The video is incomplete! Where’s the part where he returns to the US and gets his electronic devices searched and confiscated by the TSA while he’s given a thorough groping?
Re: Re:
Don’t forget that they will find his burner phone, him using a new/throw away email address and his devices might even have encryption on it.
Joking aside …. it may be a corny vid, but the advice is sound.
Re: Re:
The advice is a lot more sound while staying in the U.S. than when going abroad. And even when abroad, you are more likely to be spied upon by the U.S. services than any other party.
Re: Re: Re:
When going abroad you are more likely to get pick pocketed or have your baggage stolen.
One-Way logic problem.
There is a terrible problem of logic in humanity in general.
Burner Phones also protect the innocent from bad actors.
People searching for terms are not always ignorant of that term.
People desiring privacy does not mean they are up to no good.
The fundamental purpose of having privacy is that that you are not judged on things that are stupid.
Who if your favorite sports team?
What is your favorite food?
Favorite actors/actresses?
People harm others over the simplest of differences in opinion. The reason for privacy is to help keep the self safe. It is important to safety that everyone NOT know my habits, numbers, & private details. Conversely, it is important that my significant other does know them!
Information develops knowledge, knowledge develops power!
Re: One-Way logic problem.
Almost as if the framers of the constitution wanted us to be free from searches and seizures and to persue happiness through any and every method available…. If they were alive today, they would be labelled terrorists and would be on watch lists.
Re: One-Way logic problem.
Downvoted. You said ‘actors’ when you meant ‘people’.
Cliché ++
Re: One-Way logic problem.
I’m sure that someone out there thinks what you just posted is racist.
Scare tactics to keep people home?
This is amusing as if any non americans did this in America they would be charged with suspected domestic terrorism.
Since if you have something to hide you are clearly going to be targeted by the state.
Maybe they are trying to get Americans arrested in foreign nations for trumped up charges. keep them home instead of letting them go out and learn dangerous ideas.
Re: Scare tactics to keep people home?
That was my thought.
Don’t leave the propaganda bubble! And if you do, be a jingoistic jackass to insure you get robbed just on principle!
You can’t help but cringe when you see some of your countrymen abroad. I think that is true for every nationality though.
Re: Re: Scare tactics to keep people home?
Don’t most americans pretend to be canadian when they travel abroad though?
Re: Scare tactics to keep people home?
No, they want to arrest Americans who return.
Only spy-women chat up geeky Americans.
Other than the UK, and places where I could expect culture shock (e.g. Japan or Saudi Arabia) the paranoia and predatory behavior of the US’ agencies regarding me is far more worrying than most of the places I’d travel.
At the same time, if I had proprietary information (e.g. business secrets or client data), then of course it’d be sufficiently encrypted.
But I bet if it’s encrypted enough to keep the NSA out of my business, it’s probably encrypted enough to keep any other spies out of it as well.
It's not new, it's just how USG people think
In the 90s I used to go to UN-related meetings in Geneva a lot.
There was always a guy from the State Dept. there to watch over the “US delegation” (most of whom represented private firms).
Every Friday he’d tell us to let State know everywhere we went outside our hotel over the weekend – not for infosec reasons, but because it’s a “foreign country” and we could get into all kinds of trouble. We could get arrested and have no rights, not like at home in the US.
This was in Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe. Far safer than any place in the US – the main danger was overdosing on cheese.
But I think they really meant it.
There’s something about the mentality of people who go to work for the US government – they really, truly, think all them furriners in nasty, terrible places like Switzerland, the UK, Austrialia, Japan (Japan!) are lawless hellholes without Good Old Fashioned Merican Democracy where people will be skinned alive for blinking at the wrong time.
It’s a kind of paranoia and fear of the strange.
But it’s real, and sincere.
Re: Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
That is how I’m going to think of Switzerland from now on.
Re: Re: Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
It’s really a very nice place. Perhaps the most civilized place on the planet.
Re: Re: Re: Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
well, shit, how comes we ain’t bombed the shit out of’em by now ? ? ?
the nerve, showing us up, and all…
Re: Re: Re:2 Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
No American was able to find it on the map.
Re: Re: Re:2 Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
3 words: numbered bank accounts
Re: Re: Re:3 Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
Re: Re: Re:3 Switzerland, the child-proofed chocolate-coated rubber room of Western Europe.
“3 words: numbered bank accounts”
$ words: ENCRYPTED numbered bank accounts
(fix that for ya)
Re: It's not new, it's just how USG people think
Sounds like cult style brainwashing to me. “The world is out to get you – you are only safe here with us!”.
Re: Re: To be fair, this attitude was more valid when visiting the second world during the Cold War.
The Soviets were just as worried about capitalist plots as we were about communist plots, and there was an intense spy game going on where tourists and businessmen with useful connections were attached and then influenced to do their part in collection.
Both sides had their own dirty tricks and both sides had little respect for the subjects they’d bribe or extort.
In the spook sector, it’s industrial espionage that is renowned for being particularly nasty. Nations often recognize they have to live with each other, but rival companies would love nothing better than to see their competitors buried underground and the earth under their factories salted.
Re: Re: Re: To be fair, this attitude was more valid when visiting the second world during the Cold War.
Nations often feel that way too (bury and salt), they just realize they can’t get away with it without immense cost and risk to themselves.
The same goes for companies operating under the rule of law – much as they might like to obliterate their competitors, they can’t get away with it.
Re: It's not new, it's just how USG people think
From a corporate standpoint in the 1990s, I got similar lectures as well – especially design engineering work. Had an ex-CIA spook talk about how Air France planes were bugged and similar stories about hotels in London and elsewhere, with the governments in the region passing off ‘trade secrets’ to corporate entities in their borders. Older folks in the lectures would joke about earlier warnings of the ‘stereotypical Japanese Tourist’ taking photos of everything. Trouble is, there is a grain of truth to these stories – there is a degree of spycraft that occurs every day, from the mundane to the exotic. If anyone is in Washington D.C. – take a visit to the International Spy Museum to get an idea.
Re: Re: It's not new, it's just how USG people think
Sure, industrial espionage is as old as industry, and espionage is as old as states (or older).
But the warnings we got in the ’90s weren’t much about that – it was mostly “you’ll be arrested on made-up charges and have no rights”, etc. They made as if they were genuinely concerned with our safety.
In Switzerland.
(As far as I know, nobody took their advice, and did as they pleased on weekends without telling anyone. We chuckled about their nannying…privately.)
Re: Re: Re: It's not new, it's just how USG people think
Depending on the company, some of them had legit concerns – given the reliability of some client nations. Heck there is a good article about a fellow by the name of Max who works as a naval ‘repo-man’ when people and assets run a foul with the locals:
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/29/world/americas/maritime-repo-men-a-last-resort-for-stolen-ships.html
Re: Re: It's not new, it's just how USG people think
Kind of like in this video when they imply that there are surveillance cameras inside your hotel room. In Europe (I assume, though it didn’t say where he was). Where they freak out about privacy regularly.
US Intelligence Agencies To Americans Travelling Abroad: Trust No One, Use Burner Phones, They’re All Out To Get You
As opposed to Americans staying at home, where they can trust their government…wait…never mind.
Not that far off
Agree that this article/video does incite paranoia but it really isn’t that far off. Have fun but be smart.
Beyond Irony
This is so far beyond irony that it’s gone all the way around full circle and come back and double up on itself. If this were true, it would be *because* of the US’s excessive policy on surveillance in the first place!
That's good advice...
for foreigners coming to America as well… sigh
Re: That's good advice...
Exactly! except for the “as well” part
Re: Re: That's good advice...
And the “foreigners” part…
Re: That's good advice...
Better advice for foreigners coming to America
Dammit Frank!
Who leaked our plans for surveillance of foreign nationals entering the US next year!!!
So, those burner phones, where from ?
This is preparation for Step 2:
“I’m from the government and I’m here to hand you your very own government-issued burner phone to keep you safe when travelling. You can be absolutely sure this burner phone is safe to use and free from nasty foreign malware! Enjoy your trip. Rest assured we will be doing all we can to watch over you and keep you safe!”
They are basically just assuming the foreign gov’t works how they do.
Welcome to the United States my friend…
After reading the article, this is exactly the impression I came away with. They are asking you to protect your digital possessions in a way that would cause themselves a few problems.
There is a reason that the public does not trust it’s government here in the US and this article puts it on display between the lines. This is the level of paranoia functioning at present in the US, by our government.
Go to canada ,when you come back get your phone, laptop taken off you ,or get detained at random for doing nothing wrong .
Heres the truth ,the european tourism industry is just a front,for marxist spys ,Get smart the movie is a documentary .
Meanwhile in the real world the nsa is free to spy on
anyone including the european parliament or the german
chancellor or any private company .
No one in europe is innocent or is just trying to do a
job or bring up a family .
Why would any american try to travel any way ,
just go to disneyland or hollywood .
Maybe the nsa assumes every other country runs a
a massive surveillance network
with 1000,s of employee,s .
This is only the first step in the plan...
1. Convince Americans traveling abroad to use burner phones and throw away e-mail addresses.
2. Track phone calls and e-mails.
3. Upon re-entry into the US, arrest Americans for being dirty rotten terrorists (they are using burner phones and fake e-mail addresses, so they must be guilty).
4. Increase Terrorist arrest statistics and request double the budget due to the huge increase in domestic born terrorists..
5. Profit… chaching
Not bad advice within the country as well.
It’s great that the foreign hotel has US outlets, how convenient!
That's almost impressive
They managed to fit that much projection into a single video, that takes some real skill.
‘We do all of this(or at least we would if we could), so we’re sure that other governments do it too. As such you should absolutely protect yourself using methods that would get you treated and/or investigated as a suspicious individual if you did it here, because Only Criminals Have Anything To Hide.’
Pretty much all the ‘advice’ given would be much more fitting if told to someone crazy enough to want to visit the US.
Don’t bring your actual phone, it’s one whim away from being stolen and searched.
Don’t bring your electronic devices, laptops or whatnot unless you want those stolen and searched as well.
Be careful about using unsecured connections for anything valuable, there’s any number of agencies that like to grab anything and everything they can, just because they can.
Re: That much projection into a single video
It’s so over-the-top and obvious projection…I wonder if that was the intent.
Did some Snowdenish wise guy in the USG script and produce this to implicitly ridicule USG policy (and warn foreigners)?
Or am I ignoring Hanlon’s Anti-razor (Never attribute to beneficence that which is adequately explained by incompetence)?
Re: Re: That much projection into a single video
If you look at the video in terms of what the filmic community like to call “Production Values”, you have to go with the latter. It’s a crapfest.
Teenage kids on Youtube do far better. All the time. I’m embarrassed for my country.
And make sure you use encryption on everything!
Oh, wait.
Also, these things never happen in the US possibly more than anywhere else, at all.
Get your free burner phone here
Heh, come to Tasmania and you could receive a free burner phone. One that tracks every movement 😉
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-05-13/tasmanian-tourist-tracker-provides-limitless-insights/7410254
The more people are afraid, the more funding they get.
Fortunately for everyone, their definition of traveling abroad is going more than 10 meters from your front door.
That’s why Doomsday Preppers received money from the federal education budget, and was only closed down after it was decided people were learning too much…………………
tin foil hat
So if the US government both believes that foreigners carrying burner phones and emails are potential terrorists, and advises Americans traveling abroad to carry burner phones, does that mean it will willingly permit other countries to arrest American visitors carrying burner phones as potential terrorists?
I can’t help imagine this being the thought process of the knuckleheads who decided this propagandist junk was a good idea.
“It’s an outrage! Americans might be letting foreign governments mine their data when they’re abroad!”
“How dare they? Mining American data and holding onto it is our job!”
Well, I certainly learned something I never knew..
At 4:15, the traveler is informed that foreign intelligence services “often operate in other countries”.
Really? Foreign intelligence services operate in other countries? I’m just saying, I learned something there..
Pot and Kettle
How do they know this is happening to US tourists?
They do not. This is simply how they treat foreign tourists themselves and they project their own behaviour on other states.
Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
If anyone has been paying attention to sites like Krebs on Security, then pre-paid credit cards would be a good idea as well: http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/09/whos-behind-bluetooth-skimming-in-mexico/
Re: Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
Aren’t pre-paid credit cards the ones that will get drained by asset forfeiture in Oklahoma?
Re: Re: Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
Yep.
The only thing that’s anything like safe is Bitcoins. Memorized in wetware.
And even those can pop out under waterboarding…..
Re: Re: Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
Nice try on attempting to shift the topic – but no. When it comes to Americans travelling abroad – there are precautions that need to be taken, period.
As for the attempted misdirect – there is a greater likely hood of an American Tourist getting robbed or killed than a Foreign Tourist getting stopped by a State Trooper after committing a traffic violation:
http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/04/world/missing-american-student-italy/
Re: Re: Re: Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
As for the attempted misdirect – there is a greater likely hood of an American Tourist getting robbed or killed than a Foreign Tourist getting stopped by a State Trooper after committing a traffic violation:
I don’t know if you believe otherwise, but your reference to one such incident does not prove your claim.
Re: Re: Re:2 Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
You are correct, multiple incidents should be cited. The three below are from three countries that have been in the news the last couple of years:
Mexico: http://www.forbes.com/sites/doliaestevez/2016/01/20/state-department-renews-travel-warning-for-large-parts-of-mexico-103-americans-killed-in-2015
Brazil: http://www.businessinsider.com/american-tourist-gang-raped-and-beaten-on-transit-van-in-rio-de-janeiro-2013-4
Great Britain: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/10/25/american-student-slashed-in-london-police-eye-muslims-patrols.html
Re: Re: Re:3 Hm... Burner Phones and Pre-Paid Credit Cards is a good idea
That still says nothing about how likely it is compared to some other event, only that it happens sometimes.
Re: Re: Re:3 statistics and rate per tourist
The US State Department should have statistics regarding reported crimes against US travelers.
Compare that to say rate of civil forfeiture cases against travelling Canadians in the US.
0.9/10 on IMDB
I love how the American tourist is portrayed as a bumbling, doughy chucklehead and the smart guy as a smug know it all asshole that you just want to punch in the face. Then there’s the stereotypical ruggedly handsome spy-thief with uber-tech… and the ever so hot evil receptionist/elevator chick…
Come on Murica, this is embarrassing…..
I never considered how thoroughly paranoid this stuff sounds when you’re someone of absolutely no interest to foreign intelligence. Huh. That being said, some of it’s still good advice if you visit a country where American’s are likely to be targeted.
Re: Re:
Like the U.S.A.