China Turns From 'Pirate' Nation To Giant Patent Troll
from the what-goes-around,-comes-around dept
The West’s constant push for stronger patent protection in agreements like TPP and ACTA is based on the belief that they will then be able to deploy their supercharged patents against the rising economic might of China. What this completely overlooks is the fact that China will be able to turn the self-same strengthened patent regime against the West by acquiring patents and suing Western companies. Techdirt has already reported on how China is providing financial incentives for its companies to file huge numbers of patents overseas. Now it has taken another step in bolstering its patents strategy against the West by setting up a company called Ruichuan IPR Funds. Here’s a press release that the site Citizen Outreach has issued on this move:
With China’s creation of Ruichuan IPR Funds, imagine the assault that U.S. companies will face. Reports are that this government-sponsored troll has been seeded with $50 billion to acquire patents that will be used in actions against U.S. companies. Inasmuch as trolls aren’t sticklers for the quality of the patents they purchase, Ruichuan IPR Funds will be able to build a massive arsenal for use in harassment litigation.
China will now be in a better position to manipulate markets, handicap the overseas competition, and push itself to the head of the pack in the global patent wars.
A little hyperbolic perhaps, but essentially correct — and completely foreseeable. The Chinese government’s move is part of a larger story that recapitulates America’s own evolution from a “pirate” nation that fuelled its industrial revolution by ignoring the law and appropriating Western Europe’s patented ideas, to one using the same legal instruments against European companies.
Follow me @glynmoody on Twitter or identi.ca, and +glynmoody on Google+
Filed Under: china, competition, innovation, patent troll, patents, trade agreements, trolling
Comments on “China Turns From 'Pirate' Nation To Giant Patent Troll”
The great economic and political delusion of the 21st century is that we will shift most of the world’s manufacturing to china allowing them to grow an immensely strong and powerful economy and then they will play by all the rules that western societies have built up over the centuries.
Re: Re:
Actually, it sounds like they’re playing EXACTLY by our rules. We just always assumed we’d be further ahead for some reason.
Re: Re: Re:
That depends on who you mean by “We.”
So basically the Chinese government just set up their own version of Intellectual Ventures?
Maybe it was the belief that just because the United States has the lion’s share of the world’s lawyers, that it will be the country dominating the international patent-troll game.
Of course lawyers are just hired guns, and will be more than willing to take China’s money to submit frivolous patents and file extortionary lawsuits. It’s “the American Way.”
Damn those Chinese for copying our trolling techniques!
Re: Response to: Anonymous Coward on Oct 20th, 2014 @ 12:15pm
It’s unfortunate that Intellectual Ventures et al took what many online commenters suggested as a joke and didn’t opt to patent the process of patent trolling when they had the chance. You reap what you sow.
I love it , Maybe we’ll see Patent Wars I hope copyright wars will follow …soon, maybe ..just maybe, they’ll sue each other out of existence.
Re: Re:
The scary bit is to follow.
You know the part where private corporations can sue a government for damages regarding rejected patents etc? And how the US is trying to get that into all treaties?
Imagine a world where China owns patents involved in just about everything. One of their private corporations then has the power to overrule pretty much any other country on the planet on pretty much any topic.
Don’t like melamine in your baby formula? Well, the FDA can’t do a thing about it, because preventing China from selling their patented melamine-included baby formula in the US would cause irreparable harm to their private corporation that specializes in developing and producing the formula.
Think about it.
Re: Re: Re:
Don’t like lead in your toys? Well any ban prohibiting a Chinese manufacturer from selling us products potentially containing lead until they can reasonably show the problem has been fixed will be subject to these disputes because they could cause irreparable harm to the business.
The best way to induce change in the patent system is to get another country to beat us at the game?
Woah woah woah woah now, what do you mean the US is infringing on all of China’s patents? We can’t have that going on then.
Re: Re:
then if we change Patent laws, the company can sue the US government with ISDS provisions!
I think this could be a blessing in disguise.
Maybe, just maybe when the Chinese government is at your door with a ram, ready to bust it open, meaningful changes to the law will be made.
One can only hope.
@william
There one problem regarding meaningful changes. The US has imposed that total perverted patent system on a lot of other countries through international treaties… even if the US wants to change it, they simply can’t (do it easily).
Re: Re:
Couldn’t they do it about as easily just through another set of international treaties?
Re: Re:
They can easily. Congress has the power to cancel or modify those treaties.
Re: Re: Re:
Power and Spine are two very different things. They may have the first, but they seem to sorely lack the second.
Re: Re: Re:
That would be costly, what with the huge Corporate Sovereignty penalties that would result in.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
1) That just more treaty terms to be canceled out by congress.
2) There is also the problem of collecting against a nuclear armed bully.
What goes around, comes around.
It can be useful
May be for once it will clear the mind of politicians who are too weak to make a useful patent reform.
I can only laugh
Maybe we’ll get saner patent legislation when the big players are being eaten alive via their own bullying tactics.
the phrase “Karma Bloody Karma” comes to mind
TPP
This is why China was not invited into the TPP negotiations. The USA knows that China is one country that will push back when absurd US laws are extended overseas via the TPP. Better to sign up some country like Chile or New Zealand that can be pushed around.
So go China – troll away! But please file all your ridiculous patent claims against US companies, while sparring those smaller countries from grief. If China does this, they’d be doing the world a favor, even if few yet realize it.
Re: TPP
I think what may happen is that US courts would declare many Chinese patents invalid if they attempt to enforce them. The Chinese government would retaliate by declaring US patents invalid. The losers would be the smaller and weaker countries without the strength to stand up for themselves.
maybe china will do the us a favor,
SHOW the us government software patents are useless.
And they just encourage legal extortion via patent trolling.
They do nothing to help innovation or grow the economy .
And china was the country that forced microsoft to publish its android patents which will allow other
mobile phone companys to work around them or to challenge them in court .
Maybe china is not stupid enough to
adopt stupid us laws on patents ,corporate
whistleblowers ,
which only help large companys or encourage patent trolling and increase drug prices .
What other large country seeks to force other countrys to adopt its laws ,apart from the us?
Just to make sure I’ve got the general idea of how the USG has been helping out over the past decade or two…
Our patent system could wind up letting China hold US based R&D hostage through patents held on component technology.
Any US-developed tech that happens to escape China’s control won’t be trusted by anyone anyway, thanks to the NSA’s collect-it-all overreach.
Even something novel and secure could result in massive lawsuits by corporations based in friendly nations via ISDS, if it could potentially harm their future profits in some tangential way.
Yay, progress!
Yes, let’s all fear the long history of Chinese inventions.
Let’s start with… um well… wait, uh… maybe you can go first here? Please?
Re: Re:
There is gunpowder, rockets (fire arrows) and movable type for a start.
Re: Re:
What does number of patents have to do with level of inventiveness.
Anyways here is a list of Chinese inventions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_inventions
Re: Re: Re:
Interesting, but it sort of drives the point home that it’s been many centuries since China has been able to be considered an “inventive” society.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
I’m not sure what makes a society an “inventive” one, but I do find it interesting that there’s quite a lot of talk in business journals lately about how China is becoming an “innovation powerhouse.”
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2014/02/06/its_official_china_is_becoming_a_new_innovation_powerhouse
http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303819704579320544231396168
I’m not commenting on whether or not that characterization is accurate (I have no way of knowing), but there does seem to be a lot of people who disagree with the notion that nothing innovative comes from China.
China becoming an innovative country probably would start a patent war but maybe this will also encourage Western countries to push further more when it comes to innovations. A blessing in disguise indeed.