Law Enforcement Agencies Scramble For Pricey Cell Tower Spoofer Upgrades As Older Networks Are Shut Down

from the losing-the-tech-arms-race-to-slow-moving-service-providers dept

The surveillance device that dare not speak its name (thanks, FBI!) is on its last legs… or at least one version is. Cyrus Farivar at Ars Technica reports that law enforcement agencies are moving quickly to avoid being locked out of the cell tower spoofing racket.

Documents released last week by the City of Oakland reveal that it is one of a handful of American jurisdictions attempting to upgrade an existing cellular surveillance system, commonly known as a stingray.

The Oakland Police Department, the nearby Fremont Police Department, and the Alameda County District Attorney jointly applied for a grant from the Department of Homeland Security to “obtain a state-of-the-art cell phone tracking system,” the records show.

The Stingray is Harris Corporation’s most infamous product. But the original version has its limitations. While the nation’s cell phone carriers have largely moved on to 3G/4G networks, Stingray devices without optional upgrades haven’t. All they can access is 2G, the default connection when nothing better is available. Those looking to capture cell activity on 3G and 4G networks will need to purchase Harris’ “Hailstorm” upgrade… which also means they’ll need to start generating paperwork and asking federal and local governments for funds. The problem with these actions is that they have the tendency to expose those in need of new capabilities.

Other locales known to be in the process of related federally-funded upgrades include Tacoma, Wash.; Baltimore, Md.; Chesterfield, Va.; Sunrise, Fla.; and Oakland County, Mich. There are likely many more, but such purchases are often shrouded in secrecy.

FOIA requests have turned up some information, but much of it is redacted and many more requests have been refused or ignored. With the federal government itself instructing local law enforcement to cover up its acquisition and use of tower spoofers, the FOIA process becomes even more of an uphill battle.

Law enforcement can’t be happy to see 2G networks being switched off. When you’re in the untargeted dragnet business, 2G is a willing supplier of “business records.”

2G networks are notoriously insecure. Handsets operating on 2G will readily accept communication from another device purporting to be a valid cell tower, like a stingray. So the stingray takes advantage of this feature by jamming the 3G and 4G signals, forcing the phone to use a 2G signal.

What’s considered a criminal act when performed by a civilian is just SOP for law enforcement. The same can be said for the fake sworn documents (warrant requests, subpoenas) obtained to cover the use of these devices. The manufacturer with the most devices in use is no better than the agencies it sells to. When approached about this scramble for upgrades, Harris Corporation borrowed the NSA’s Glomar.

“We do not comment on solutions we may or may not provide to classified Department of Defense or law enforcement agencies,” Jim Burke, a spokesman for Harris, told Ars.

The timeline for 2G shutoff is still vague. Verizon says “by the end of the decade.” AT&T says 2017. So there’s still some time for law enforcement agencies to avoid being bypassed by the slow rollout of network upgrades. But between now and then, these agencies need to put together nearly $500,000 just to stay current. And as usual, as much as possible about the process will be obscured, because otherwise the terrorists criminals win.

“Once that’s disclosed then the targets of the technology will know how to avoid it,” [Alameda County Assistant DA Michael] O’Connor, the assistant district attorney, told Ars. “Once the bad guys understand how to beat it then they will.”

It seems like all the bad guys would need to know is that the technology exists and is being used and just stay off their cell phones. But in this day and age, being completely unconnected while away from home is untenable, if not nearly impossible. Communication is key in criminal enterprises, and the steady disappearance of pay phones doesn’t leave them with many options. O’Connor completely overstates the “exposure” danger and follows it up with this:

“It can’t easily be resolved—the public’s right to know, the Fourth Amendment rights of people who might be subject to this kind of analysis and the needs of law enforcement to keep sources confidential especially in a day and age when the bad guys have acquired considerable technology that is turned against good guys.”

One: if it can’t “easily be resolved,” why not err on the Fourth Amendment/public knowledge side, rather than on the cop side? Two: the bad guys’ “considerable technology” isn’t lapping law enforcement’s. This ridiculous claim has been used as justification for warrantless cell phone searches, and it failed to move the Supreme Court justices. Pushing this narrative now just makes the pusher look like the sort of credulous rube who would put together a Powerpoint presentation on food-trucks-as-terrorist-vehicles.

The bright side here is that more paperwork is being generated… which eventually means more of the public will know their local law enforcement is scooping up their location/connection info (most likely without a warrant) at any given time and is not above killing their network to do it.

Filed Under: , , , , , , , , ,
Companies: harris corp.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Law Enforcement Agencies Scramble For Pricey Cell Tower Spoofer Upgrades As Older Networks Are Shut Down”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

How to shut down 2G on your phone

On Android: dial *#*#4636#*#* (*#*#INFO#*#*). When you press the last *, it will go to a hidden settings screen. Choose the first option. Scroll a bit and you’ll see a mode selector. Choose “WCDMA only” and congrats, your phone will now use only 3G (there should be other options there for you LTE users). This setting is lost on reboot, so don’t forget to do this every time you turn on your phone.

DogBreath says:

Re: Re: does not want a cracker

Who does the police think they are? Nixon?

I don’t remember giving the police presidential powers. The FBI, CIA, NSA and other clandestine agencies that can not be mentioned without a free one-way trip to an undisclosed blacksite, yes. I absolutely remember giving them the power, but it was immediately redacted from my memory because that is what they told me. But the police? I don’t think so.

Don't Spy On Me! says:

Fake Cell Phone Towers

A security company selling Samsung Galaxy S3s with enhanced encryption says it has found 19 ‘phony cell towers’ located throughout the United States.

Customers using the Cryptophone 500, sold by ESD America, have detected signals from transmitters masquerading as cell towers that, if a cell phone connects to it, can track the phone’s location or leave data on its operating system vulnerable to attacks.

A map released by the company shows hits for these fake towers in New York City, Chicago, Dallas and Los Angeles. ESD America’s CEO, Les Goldsmith, told Popular Science one tower in Nevada was found near a government facility out in the desert. …

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...