Failed Company, Now Patent Troll, Sues Apple Over Transferrable Playlists For A Third Time
from the personal-troll dept
Remember the company Personal Audio? This is the complete flop of a company that claimed it tried to develop a personal audio player that never went anywhere, and now is nothing but a pure patent troll. It opened an empty office in East Texas, and actually succeeded in winning $8 million from Apple this summer for its patent (6,199,076) on an “Audio program player including a dynamic program selection controller.” It had also sued for a second patent (7,509,178) on an “Audio program distribution and playback system,” but had failed to convince the judge.
After winning the lawsuit (and both parties are appealing parts of the ruling), Personal Audio sued a second time, arguing that other Apple products also infringed the first (‘076) patent. That lawsuit was put on hold until the appeals on the first lawsuit were dealt with. But with the release of iOS5, Personal Audio has wasted no time in suing Apple once again, bringing the ‘178 patent back into the ball game. As the Patent Examiner blog explains:
The difference in the new case? It?s as simple as a USB cable. The patent in question is for an ?audio program distribution and playback system? that downloads playlists. At the time, the Apple products named in the first suit had to be connected to a computer to sync playlists using iTunes, and Judge Ron Clark of the Eastern District of Texas decided Apple did not infringe the patent despite the jury having concluded otherwise.
?The USB cable did not meet [the judge’s] definition of ?download,?? said Personal Audio lawyer Ronald J. Schutz of Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi. ?Apple argued that the USB cord turned the iPod into a dumb hard drive.?
But with the release of Apple?s new iOS 5 software, iPhones, iPods and iPads can sync playlists from iTunes over a WiFi connection instead of using a USB cable.
Because, you know, without Personal Audio around, I’m sure Apple would have never figured out a way to sync playlists over WiFi.