India The Latest To Think About Kicking People Off The Internet Based On Accusations Of File Sharing

from the guilty-until-proven-innocent dept

A few months back, we pointed to a discussion looking at how three countries with some of the biggest movie industries outside of the US — Nigeria, China and India — all were thriving, despite massive “piracy.” As you looked at the details of each, it showed how each industry had been adapting to a marketplace in which some of the content was widely available, but were still figuring out ways to make money (i.e., you can compete with free). However, because competing with free actually involves work, it should come as no surprise that some are seeking to implement government protectionist policies.

Gautam John points us to the news that a “High Level Committee on Piracy” in India, put together by the Indian government has come back with a variety of suggestions including a “three strikes” plan that would kick users off the internet based on accusations (not convictions) for unauthorized file sharing. There’s also a suggestion that would appear to make theater owners somewhat liable for customers camcording movies. They also support preventative detention of potential pirates — a ridiculous idea that has been put in practice in some areas of India already — and which the US entertainment industry has encouraged. Yes, this is detaining people who might make an unauthorized copy. Welcome to pre-crime, India-style. About the only suggestion that isn’t massively damaging to individuals’ rights is the idea that filmmakers “make piracy unviable” by offering their movies at more reasonable prices and in more ways, so that people are more willing to go with legitimate options. They probably should have just stuck with that suggestion and left the rest alone.

Filed Under: , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “India The Latest To Think About Kicking People Off The Internet Based On Accusations Of File Sharing”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Dark Helmet (profile) says:


“all were thriving, despite massive “piracy.” As you looked at the details of each, it showed how each industry had been adapting to a marketplace in which some of the content was widely available”

I’m addmittedly ignorant of daily life in those parts of the world, but what is the prevelance of personal computing in those areas? I would imagine that the abundance of PCs here in the States is a large contributing factor to the “success” of “piracy”. Are these other countries valid comparisons?

PaulT (profile) says:

Re: Question...

I’m not overly familiar but my understanding is that there’s much more of a physical pirate market rather than the digital one. There’s certainly a tech infrastructure and some areas with high PC ownership (the places where tech jobs are being outsourced to, for example) but I’d imagine it varies wildly depending on where you are. So, it’s comparable as piracy is high, but not directly analogous as the distribution methods are different.

It’s also my understanding that there’s much less of a legal market, especially for non-local product. Legal copies are often either too expensive for the average person or not easily obtainable. I often see Indian gamers complaining about how difficult it can be to obtain certain games or systems as they’re not part of the core Japan/North America/Europe/Australasia markets – and even the latter two tend to get screwed over on a regular basis with regional controls. I’d imagine that it’s the same story with DVDs and music, especially outside of the local Bollywood/Bhangra/whatever genres.

Again, I might be mistaken, but that’s the impression I’ve gotten over the years.

Anonymous Coward says:

I look forward to....

…. The point at which this kind of thing comes into force in the US and a good percentage of it’s citizens get incarcerated, crashing the government and economy with overspending for the prisons to hold them all……

Oh, wait…. might that be a bit unconstitutional? Just as well principles only apply to one’s own interests in one’s own backyard rather than being, well you know, universal.

Next time I’m in the US i want to see the declararation of independance document to see if there really is a bit in brackets crossed out after “We hold these truths to be self evident” that says “(except when it costs us money)”. I’d not heard of it, but I’m assuming it’s there……

Of course it’s not just the US so much as corporations and they’re global and all largely the same.

out_of_the_blue says:

"still figuring out ways to make money..."

Okay, they’ve figured it out! And surprise, it’s the same way as in the US, UK, Japan, and Europe, by getting gov’t to increase enforcement through arbitrary and draconian measures. As I’ve said, copyright “theft” benefits gov’t by providing more rationale for a police state; politicians are bribed by endorsement from popular movie stars (and their money), so it’s *inevitable*.

Next: “competing with free actually involves work”, YES, but one way you advise, selling geegaws in connection with bands, requires the existence of *workers* who actually produce the low-cost / high-resell items. If you mean self- advertising and promoting, well, that’s *light* work, and it’s not *new*, been used for at least a hundred years in the mass entertainment field, and the main components are still *luck* and willingness to prostitute oneself.

india>bangalore says:

i have every hollywood movie which has been rated 7+ in imdb from and and all the training IT certification video training materials like CBT nuggets, trainsignal and VTC. I do all this in the office because my crappy 1mpbs connection is not enough to do all this at home and none of what i have downloaded was available in india and indians always want to try before buy…that is just in our genes and culture….if i wanna buy a DVD then before that i wanna watch a dvdrip for free (not just the trailor).if i wanna buy a 1kg of sweets then i wanna taste a bit of it before i buy…

Salvadesswaran Srinivasan (profile) says:

The real state of piracy here..

Online piracy is thriving here, although physical media is being punished quite severely. This is the state in Tamil Nadu, where the ruling party has at least two movie production and distribution houses (which almost always spew out crap).
We don’t have as high a level of PC penetration here, and prices of Hollywood DVDs are quite absurd. Several local companies have taken the initiative to bring out original DVDs of some good movies, old as well as new, at a dollar or so (INR 35-40, actually is 85 – 90 cents). If this approach is followed, then people will buy Hollywood DVDs and not just stare at those packs in the store.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...