NC State Senator Admits Broadband Companies Wrote His Bill & Says He 'Carries Water' For Companies

from the wow dept

Ah, North Carolina. A year and a half ago, we wrote about an attempt by the North Carolina state legislature to pass an anti-municipal broadband bill in the state. These bills have become somewhat common. Basically, cities that feel that giant broadband companies aren’t providing quality services often decide to build their own local offering. Since broadband is often a monopoly or a duopoly of critical infrastructure, having a local community create another option makes tremendous sense, when done right (though, admittedly, many don’t do it well). Yet, the big broadband players tend to spend tons of money fighting these community competitors, rather than actually providing better/faster services.

What was most interesting about the situation in North Carolina, however, was how blatant state politicians were in highlighting that it was really the broadband companies who were calling the shots. In our story from April of 2009, it was noted that when the state representatives sponsoring the bill were asked questions about it during a committee hearing, they asked Time Warner employees to answer for them. Think about that for a second. The sponsors of the bill couldn’t answer the questions, so they asked industry folks to answer instead. We had thought that was about as blatant as a politician could be in admitting that the bill was actually written by the industry and that the politicians didn’t even understand what they were sponsoring.

However, now it appears that a North Carolina state Senator may have taken that even further. Ars Technica points us to a local news report by WCNC, who asked bill sponsor Senator David Hoyle if the bill was written by cable companies:

When the I-Team asked him if the cable industry drew up the bill, Senator Hoyle responded, “Yes, along with my help.”

When asked about criticism that he was “carrying water” for the cable companies, Hoyle replied, “I’ve carried more water than Gunga Din for the business community – the people who pay the taxes.”

That’s going to look great on a campaign poster from a competitor in a future election. While none of this is surprising — the fact that lobbyists write the bills and politicians simply shuffle them forward — is nothing new, it is surprising to see a politician so willing to admit it. Perhaps he forgets that it’s not just the companies who pay taxes (and, for the most part, these big companies are really good at avoiding taxes), but the citizens of the state who vote for him (or not) who pay taxes as well. Flat out stating that he’s “carried more water than Gunga Din for the business community,” may make the citizens wonder whether he was elected to represent companies like Time Warner (not based in North Carolina) or the actual citizens who elected him.

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “NC State Senator Admits Broadband Companies Wrote His Bill & Says He 'Carries Water' For Companies”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
nasch (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re:

As I have said many times before, the hate on the LEFT is the real problem in America.

This is sarcasm, right? Please tell me you’re making fun of the people who think that the REAL problem is the other guys, and THEIR side is great and does everything right. I have a singking feeling you’re actually being serious though.

Chargone (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re: Re:

I’d argue that the problem is the Right, personally…

but that’s just because I’m of the opinion that the USA doesn’t actually have a viable and meaningful ‘left’ …

(certainly not if the polices they try to Export under a supposedly ‘left’ government are any indication…)

a less bias and humourous take, however, agrees with you. the problem isn’t that one side or the other sucks. it’s that the people believe that the current sides are meaningful and that either are capable of NOT sucking… and that such broad and all encompassing ‘sides’ make a scrap of sense in the first place.

Anonymous Coward says:

“I’ve carried more water than Gunga Din for the business community – the people who pay the taxes.”

This moron is forgetting the residents to pay property taxes, sales taxes, gas taxes, annual car taxes (paying tax on the same vehicle multiple times, for some reason. As if paying the sales tax at time of purchase wasn’t enough for these greedy mongrels).

I live in NC. Guess who I won’t be voting! And guess who I’m going to tell my wife, her family and everyone else that I can about this morons corporate ball cupping and total disregard for individuals. That’s right, David Hoyle! Have fun not getting elected, jerkoff!!

Chargone (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re:

… Come to New Zealand.

we get to pay taxes on our taxes :S

(there’s a tax on petrol to cover wear and tear on the roads, but because of how the GST (a consumer tax) works, it includes the petrol tax in the price, so you get taxed on that too. and now they’re introducing an emissions trading scheme, which amounts to an environment tax most of the time. the impression i get on that one listening to both sides is that it’s a nice idea, terribly implemented.)

Justin says:

Yeah to he11 with business

Screw businesses and all of the jobs they create, and the people that actually want to work for a living. Lets pass some legislation to put big oil, big pharma and the internet companies out of business.

Look folks, I know you don’t like to hear this but if the government were running your ISP A. It would be a monopoly still, except it would be the scariest ugliest kind imaginable. B. You would still be using dial up.

Politicians like to tell you they can fix everything so that you’ll vote for them. Honestly they fix nothing, because then where would their power be?

Brian (profile) says:

Re: Yeah to he11 with business

So umm where do you get this whole thing about how creating competition will somehow harm the market? It will create MORE jobs, and the only jobs it will harm are of those who fail to adapt and improve, they will fall to the wayside. This is how competition has worked in the market since the dawn of time. If you can’t compete you don’t get to stay in business.

Chargone (profile) says:

Re: Re:

i read a book like that…

it was unpleasent.

then again, most of the characters were slime and the main character was completely unaware that it could possibly be different.

he was also about to con a bunch of people into helping colonize venus Before terraforming it (necessary. someone had to be there to do the work to get the terraforming Done). (hey, he worked for an advertising company. what do you expect?)

Shieldzee (profile) says:

I live in Salisbury and we are very excited about getting this. Our ISP/Cable Company, Time Warner, provides pretty good service when it comes to phone and Internet, but the TV is horrible. HD shows freeze up, the screen pixelates, DVR’s will stop recording in the middle of the show. Also, customer service is abysmal.

It is important to note the the City Council lobbied both Time Warner and AT&T extensively to get them to improve their service, even offering to partner with them and both flatly turned the city down.

One other interesting thing to note is that Hoyle is not seeking another term. Any ideas where he will end up? TWC, perhaps?

Anonymous Coward says:

It takes more than one senator to pass a piece of plutocratic legislation like Hoyle pushed. Hoyle just introduced the industry-written bill, which he couldn’t even verbally defend. It took a commitee to bring it to vote. A state congress to vote it into law (I could be wrong, it could just be a commitee vote). It took an electorate to vote those monopoly-serving bums in there.

Why Hoyle isn’t in a jail cell in NC is the big question to me.

GeneralEmergency (profile) says:

A solution to this is a "By My Own Hand" amendment.

I have thought for some time now a good way to combat both “Crony Capitalism” and 1500 page long legislative horror stories is to implement a “By My Own Hand” amendment to the constitution.

By My Own Hand Amendment:
All bills submitted to congress shall be drafted in longhand English on controlled and logged serially numbered paper sheets provided by Congress in ink with pens held only by the hands of elected and seated members of Congress. The drafting of said bills may only be performed within two single exit 150 square foot Drafting Chamber rooms accessible only to members of Congress. Each Drafting Chamber will be provided by, guarded and monitored by the respective Sergeant at Arms of each chamber of Congress. With the sole exception of doctor prescribed medical devices, the respective Sergeant at Arms shall not permit electronic or mechanical devices within each Congressional Chamber’s Drafting Chamber.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...