Police Arrest Researcher Who Showed E-Voting Machines Are Not Secure
from the this-is-concerning dept
A few months back, a research report came out noting that e-voting machines in India were not secure. I had seen it at the time, but considering how many stories we’ve seen of e-voting machines with security problems, I let it pass and didn’t write it up. However, the story has just taken a distressing turn. One of the researchers, Hari Prasad, who had obtained the e-voting machine from an anonymous source in the first place, has been arrested and taken into custody because he will not reveal who gave him the machine:
The police did not state a specific charge at the time of the arrest, but it appears to be a politically motivated attempt to uncover our anonymous source. The arresting officers told Hari that they were under “pressure [from] the top,” and that he would be left alone if he would reveal the source’s identity.
Prasad was taken from his home and driven to Mumbai, a 14-hour journey, where he is to be interrogated. Alex Halderman, who has done lots of research on e-voting machines over the years, and worked with Prasad on the research on the Indian e-voting machine was able to speak to him while he was being driven to Mumbai. Prasad worries that his arrest will create serious chilling effects on other security researchers, and plans to stand up to authorities to hopefully prevent such chilling effects from occurring. You can listen to excerpts from the call in the following YouTube video:
Filed Under: alex halderman, e-voting, hari prasad, india, security
Comments on “Police Arrest Researcher Who Showed E-Voting Machines Are Not Secure”
This gave me a great idea
Open source e-voting machines … End of problem
Re: This gave me a great idea
End of 1000% profit margins too. Therein lies the problem.
Re: Re: This gave me a great idea
Profit concerns on what essentially the primary activity of a Democracy….my, how delicious….
Re: Re: Re: This gave me a great idea
Next thing you know, they’ll be putting Goldman Sachs execs in charge of Treasury.
Re: Re: Re:2 This gave me a great idea
Ridiculous
Re: Re: This gave me a great idea
“End of 1000% profit margins too. Therein lies the problem.”
Boo Hoo. Computer manufacturers get away with 15% profit margins. The voting machine types will just have to deal with it.
Re: Re: This gave me a great idea
End of 1000% profit margins too. Therein lies the problem.
nah, the end of plausible deniability when it comes to rigging elections. that’s the big concern.
Duh...
You bet your ass he was arrested and they want to know who gave him the machine. If he was able to prove that they are not secure, the politicians that are taking advantage of it will loose their ability to skew the elections. You had to see this coming a mile away….
Of course they aren’t secure. They can’t be too hard for a politician to ‘adjust’.
Putting something like a password on it would confuse the average politician.
Re: Re:
Nah…they don’t want their pets getting into them…the password is…1……2…….3……4…….5…….
Re: Re: Re:
A guy I work with has that same combination on his luggage….
From india
Indian congress government is so screwed up and there is a planned scam going on otherwise why do you thing from almost 50+ years we have the same shitty government.
The entire country is controlled by an italian lady called chutiya gandhi (also the head of Indian congress government) who is trying to make his son the next prime minister. chutiya gandhi and her son or daughter none of them speak good national language and they control the country.
Wikileaks
Sounds like a textbook example of the sort of time you should have released your research from Wikileaks, so that the media could have gotten to it without risking government retaliation on the leakers and researchers.
Maybe he's lucky
that Warner Bros didn’t get to him first and sue him for calling himself Hari Prasad.
We just have to wake up and
Instead of he being awarded for the research, he is being punished and is really a matter of shame. Forget an award he should have been called to see how could we improve the system.
We just have to wake up and
Instead of he being awarded for the research, he is being punished and is really a matter of shame. Forget an award he should have been called to see how could we improve the system.
…and with luck, in the process, shame our politicians into doing the same.
Free Hari Prasad community page on facebook
A community page has been setup for the cause on facebook.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Free-Hari-Prasad/139185779456919
Its time to kill our leaders
Time for India and its corrupt leaders to die.
No longer can we trust our goverments.
Go forth my children, show no mercy, wipe them out, all of them.
India sleepwalking into dark age of civil liberties
India claims to be a great democracy but all the pillars are broken or missing.
What use is it to be called a democracy if citizens can’t question or analyze these voting machines which are susceptible to tampering ? Both Indian and non-Indian experts have shown that the EVMs are insecure (more at http://www.indianevm.com/).
Media Failure: The Indian media have largely failed to throw any light on these well known and documented EVM problems (Big media houses like the Times of India are chasing the “paid news” dollars, by which any politician or company can buy favorable coverage from them. Many of these media stories are planted and riddled with propaganda. See http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/08/world/asia/08iht-letter.html ).
Law and Order Failure: Police continue to make arrests under political pressure, and it is clearly stated to be the case in Hari’s case.
Judiciary: Judges being corrupt, judge/lawyers running in the same large families influencing outcomes, many corrupt judges being exposed (see http://judicialreforms.org/judicial_account.htm ), overuse of contempt provisions, long pendency of cases and so on makes Indian judiciary incapable of effective and timely justice.
Techology Laws: India is supposedly an infotech powerhouse, but look at the laws. The IT Act of 2000 makes even “annoying speech” a crime and is designed for abuse. There is no dearth of “iconic personalities” which will whither under any kind of scrutiny. States like Maharashtra are trying to bring in legislation that protects “iconic personalities” which would place many elite power players, kings and king makers beyond the reach of even fair comment. A new untouchability is emerging. The direction India is taking is retrograde. See http://www.cis-india.org/advocacy/igov/blog/information-technology-act (Aug 2010).
This goes on, but the Indian people are on a consumerist spree.
India is now sleepwalking into a dark age, from the point of view of civil liberties. There are lots of activists, but the police can be used to silence them one by one as the media stands by as a silent accomplice. Hari’s is a case in point.