LiveJournal Accused Of Redirecting Links, Swiping Affiliate Fees
from the trust-issues dept
You may or may not remember, many years ago, that one of the “tricks” used by adware was to hijack affiliate fees. Basically, the way it would work is that the adware would watch where you were clicking, and if the URL was for an online store that had an affiliate program or affiliate link, the adware would swap in its own adware account info, allowing the adware company to collect the affiliate fees rather than the company/individual who actually earned it. Sneaky.
However, now there are some claims that popular blog/community site LiveJournal is doing the same thing itself. Shawn Tutt points us to a story claiming that LiveJournal is redirecting outbound links from users such that they appear to strip any affiliate codes and add LiveJournal’s own affiliate codes to a long list of popular e-commerce sites. It’s hard to think of a better way to piss off a bunch of your own users than to replace their own affiliate codes with your own. Once people started complaining about this, it looks like LiveJournal stripped out the code. Still, it does raise some really big trust questions about LiveJournal, if it thought this was a good idea in the first place.
Filed Under: affiliates, links, livejournal
Companies: livejournal
Comments on “LiveJournal Accused Of Redirecting Links, Swiping Affiliate Fees”
less nefarious
on links that did not have an affiliate code, inject your own. leave those that had one alone. i wouldn’t mind a setup like that.
Re: less nefarious
on links that did not have an affiliate code, inject your own. leave those that had one alone. i wouldn’t mind a setup like that.
That was allegedly what the code was supposed to do, but it was poorly implemented, according to someone at Livejournal. (I can’t find this immediately, it was buried in a comments thread.)
StackOverflow
The popular programming help site StackOverflow.com does this as well, but before they started they asked the users about it and got approval from most of the larger contributors.
Addendum
Addendum
(Frickin’ hell!)
*AHEM*
From the vichan.livejournal.com link provided in the article:
‘[info]marta has posted some information saying the code was supposed to add “this link came via lj” affiliate info to non affiliated links — the link would go to exactly the same place it was supposed to, but there would be information added saying that the link had come via LJ — which makes a lot more sense (and sounds thankfully less sinister) than hijacking people’s links and taking them to advertisers, but didn’t work as expected. It’s still being scrapped.’
Amazon is Not Amused
http://shatterstripes.livejournal.com/1067252.html?thread=9179636#t9179636
Quote from thread:
“Amazon replied to me with a form letter. The summary is:
. Thanks for telling us.
2. Anybody who lost revenue (or believes they lost revenue) due to affiliate hijacking should let us know via the Associate Program contact form. We’ll fix it.
3. We Are Not Amused.
4. And for obvious business reasons, we can’t tell you exactly what we’re doing. But thanks for the tip-off, we’re probably doing something. Maybe.
hich is pretty much what I expected, although #2 was a bit of a nice surprise.”
Unbelievable if this was any other industry there would be legal action. I’ve used them before for my groom wedding speech site but I’ll think twice now.
I’ve heard these tales before but naively did not believe them.
Hmm that’s weird – I’ve used them in the past but never had anything like this ever happen to me! I hope it’s sorted out soon because I really love livejournal and I find it hard to believe that they been involved in shady stuff like this.
John from mother of the groom dresses
...
“How can we piss off our users today?”
“I know, let’s convert all their affiliate links to our own…”
“Jim, you’re a legend, have a raise…”
*facepalm*
LiveJournal Accused Of Redirecting Links, Swiping Affiliate Fees
Hi admin.
This accusation to LiveJournal is definitely untrue and no basis!
The truth will prevail ...
but it will be better that it prevails at the right time