Raising Some Questions About Smoking Gun Sex Offender Profiles On MySpace

from the anyone-check-if-it's-actually-real? dept

Last week, there was a story on News.com about how Connecticut’s Attorney General, Richard Blumenthal, who’s been on quite a crusade to “protect the children” from social networks, was demanding MySpace hand over info on sex offenders registered on the site. This seemed a bit odd, because MySpace and other social networks had already agreed to weed out the accounts of various sex offenders. Yet, as the article noted, an investigator (who was involved in a separate legal battle with MySpace) happened to find profiles of registered sex offenders still on MySpace including (gasp!) some who even used their own mug shots as their photos. Yet, as Sean Garrett points out, the whole thing seems pretty questionable. Why would a sex offender trolling the site for kids use their own mugshot — and equally creepy descriptions that are pretty clear tipoffs. The whole thing seems quite likely that someone found the sex offender page and set up a fake MySpace profile.

Of course, it’s possible the page was actually put together by the sex offender in question, but it doesn’t look like anyone actually bothered to confirm that it’s real. Instead, it’s being used as a political prop by politicians and reporters of the horrible type of people found on MySpace. As Jim Harper notes, will Richard Blumenthal be investigating the reincarnation of Elvis Presley on Facebook next?

No one’s trying to downplay the serious issue of sexual predators, but study after study after study has shown that the issue has been blown way out of proportion by politicians and the press who seem to love creating moral panics so they can claim they’re “protecting the children.” It’s as if they stop thinking and all skepticism goes out the window the second anyone claims that sexual predators might be on social networks — despite the fact that studies have shown the best way to combat the rare cases when children are approached by such miscreants is better education. Children who are educated on the risks are quite good at avoiding such contact. Yet, that doesn’t make for such great headlines and probably doesn’t help Attorneys General when it comes to re-election time.

Filed Under: , ,
Companies: myspace

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Raising Some Questions About Smoking Gun Sex Offender Profiles On MySpace”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
A Sex Offender says:

I’m a sex offender. I was 18 and had a 15 year old girlfriend. I made a mistake, whatever.

I have a MySpace. I’m 30 years old now, and the only people on my friends list are my friends in real life and coworkers from work. What’s the harm in that?

Just because a sex offender has a myspace, doesn’t mean he’s trolling for little kids.

Even if he was, wouldn’t you want to let him keep the account so that you could see if he’s doing something?

Also, the “mug shot” on the registry, is nothing but our drivers license photo. So it’s possible that it could be the person using it.

There’s an easy way to fix the “predator” problem on myspace, here it is:
1.) remove friend counts so it’s not a competition to have the most friends
2.) If a 40 year old wants to be friends with somebody under 18, make it so that the child has to be the one to initiate contact.

That is, don’t let me being 30 even request friendship with a 15 year old. If the 15 year old wants me as a friend, make it so they have to know me in real life and actually request to add me. Then, it wouldn’t be possible to even talk to children on the site, and the only girls that would get raped are the ones who actively seeked out older men.

It’s simple.

Sex Offender Issues (user link) says:

Moral Panic and Mass Hysteria


Yes, it’s pure hysteria, a moral panic. Many have used the 50,000 online predators, and they admit, the number came from Chris Hansen, who pulled it out of thin air, because it’s one of those “magical” numbers that is not too much and not too less, it sounds good.


Eisenhans says:

More Panic More Hysteria

It would seem that the only thing that sustains politicians and the main media these days is moral panic and artificial hysteria about all sort of dubious dangers,Y2K WMD and the biggie Global Warming,all of which produce massive industries and truckloads of cash. One can only wonder what will happen when they can turn the “Protect The Children” thing into some sort of moneymaking exercise.

John says:

It already is

It already is a huge moneymaking exercise. Think of all the money the GPS manufacturers are making. There are tons of “Family Watchdog” type sites that have sprung up and charge a nominal fee for a free service (anyone can use their state’s registry for free and find the same information that sites like Family Watchdog charge for). Sex offenders must pay for all of their treatment, polygraphs, and monitoring, which often amounts to hundreds of dollars a month. Another interesting thing to consider is that the registry NEEDS all of the low-level offenders on it to keep it going. Neighborhoods need to look like they have “Sex Offender Chicken Pox”, even if most of them are what many people would consider low level offenders. People see the “chicken pox effect” and get scared and think they need to have a registry to keep track of all the “dangerous sickos”. Without the low level offenders, it would be “one guy here…another guy way over there” and there wouldn’t be a need for the whole god-forsaken thing in the first place.

Anonymous Coward says:

I believe in giving people chances and choices but if a sex offcnder is registering on this or any other site they he still needs help because they are not over the sickness. Theu are given the opportunity to get back on the bad strick that they are trying so hard to stay away because alot of the people ob myspace or othersites advvertise them self as older and sexualy exploded. Howevver if a sex offender falls for this tupe of advertisement then they still need some serious help. My advice is if you are a sex offender stay off the sites if you arfe being true to yoursrlf and family. and friends no wil trust you if you put yourself in those situations.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...