The Governator Wasting More California Taxpayer Money Over Unconstitutional Violent Video Game Ban

from the how-much-money-needs-to-be-wasted? dept

Last month, California was the latest in a long list of states who discovered that passing a ban on the sale of violent video games violates the Constitution. This shouldn’t be a surprise. More than 10 states have passed such laws and every single one of them has been thrown out. Any state still trying to pass such a law is clearly just wasting taxpayer money so some politicians can claim (incorrectly) that they’re “protecting the children.” It looks like California’s Governor Schwarzenegger is joining the crowd of wasteful grandstanding politicians. He’s appealing last month’s ruling and making a bunch of factually incorrect statements in doing so. First, he claims that “many studies show the link between playing ultra-violent video games and violent behavior.” That’s incorrect. The studies that people like to cite have all been debunked, as the interpretation usually doesn’t follow from the data in the studies. Furthermore, the real world evidence that violent crime rates keep dropping as violent video games get more popular should raise plenty of questions concerning any claim of the opposite. Second, the Governor claims “we protect our children from buying inappropriate movies and ought to be able to protect them from buying inappropriate video games as well.” That’s nice, but it all depends on who the “we” is. It’s true that kids cannot buy certain movies, but that’s based on a voluntary system, put in place by the movie industry — and not a government mandated one. That’s the key issue here — and Schwarzenegger is being misleading by claiming that the voluntary agreement in the movie industry is the equivalent of a gov’t-backed plan.

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “The Governator Wasting More California Taxpayer Money Over Unconstitutional Violent Video Game Ban”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Wig says:

What is "inappropriate"?

Last I checked, the majority of the ‘inappropriate’ movies weren’t rated so because of their violent but because of their sexual nature… Face it: a movie showing some nudity will more likely be rated PG than a movie where someone is violently killed.

Hey, maybe ‘they’ just want to tell you whatever they feel will get them that bit of popularity/publicity they seek at that moment.

Except… ‘they’ are not making themselves popular with parents that actually think about these issues: who actually do some parenting in educating and guiding their children how to deal with violent games (and violence and sexuality in general for that matter). ‘They’ only make themselves popular with the those parents that are foolish enough to believe that everything will be ok if you give enough control to the goverment. The ability to make a descision for yourself and, as a parent, for your children must seem too big of a problem for them.

Maybe a law needs to be passed that denies these parents the right to have a kid? You know… to “protect that kid from the stupidity of its parents”?

The infamous Joe says:

Re: What is

Except… ‘they’ are not making themselves popular with parents that actually think about these issues: who actually do some parenting in educating and guiding their children how to deal with violent games (and violence and sexuality in general for that matter).

So, he’s hurting his popularity with you and a few hundred other people, huh? 🙂

If the “save the children” tactic didn’t work, they wouldn’t do it. Scorn should be placed more on the people who fall for (and thus, indirectly, encourage) this type of campaigning and less on the political action figures who see something that will work and use it. (Not saying they’re in the right, just that solving the issue from the bottom up would be more effective)

DIAF says:

passively pissed

Ummm…. so this censorship crap has gone too far. Been gaming since I was three. I have played every violent game out there. Been cappin Nazi’s for years, demons, zombies…etc. I have yet to harm another human (but I can still dream, right?)

My daughter is now 3 months old. I have grown weary of politician douche bags attempting to legislate what clearly is a parental choice. Here’s an idea, STAY OUT OF OUR LIVES GOVERNMENT. We can handle just about any situation without your intervention, and usually better than you ever could. That’s my daughter. I feed her, clothe her, and care for her. I will chose what she consumes, not you. Not ever.

TheDock22 says:

I don't get it....

I thought video games already had ratings and restrictions. When I bought Grand Theft Auto I was carded because the lady though I was under 17 (nice flattery, but she was waaaay off). Heck I got carded buying the game strategy guide for Grand Theft Auto. Then again, maybe it’s a store by store thing.

barren (profile) says:


I love the irony of this. We are supposed to be tolerant of other peoples beleifs and values in todays world. The government sponsors countles organizations promoting moral responsibility and tolerance…then turns around and gives us the FCC and all the organizations behind it. A story cannot be told without some kind of obstacle for the hero to overcome. There has to be conflict of some sort or all we will have are stories about people who get up, go to work, and come home to sleep. Interesting. So, we have the government preaching tolerance at us, while being intolerant to our varying beliefs and values, as well as regulating what we can and cannot see and hear. So much for the constitution. Heil FCC!!!!

edward says:

The Gap Between Natural Intelligence and Artificial Intelligence

There is far way to go for the gap between Natural Intelligence and Artificial Intelligence filled, or close to be filled, trust me or not

1. Where is the natural intelligence coming from? What is the essence of intelligence?

2. What is the key difference between life and matter? What consciousness? Shall modern Artificial Intelligence be built upon life, or matter, or both?

3. Natural intelligence can be either very rational or very passionate, how shall robotics model passion, or spontaneousity?

4. Incremental Learning is one of major characteristics of natural intelligence, how shall robotics model Incremental Learning?

5. How will robots evolve from individual-based, to team-based, to community-based, and to society-based ? Will a Third Life like Second Life appear in the future?

6. Business-wise if robots start to replace us both at work and at office, how will it impact our traditional business model since the inception of market economy?

7. How shall we deal the situation when the Artificial Intelligence of robots to surpass natural intelligence of human being? How to address robot security?

For more details, please check
Frontier Blog at –

Freedum (user link) says:

Liberalism lives!

Remember Arnold was and is a very liberal politician, regardless of his party affiliation. The dems Always think that they know better, and want to control every little nook and cranny of our personal lives.

I say leave me alone, and I’ll leave you alone. Mess with my stuff or my loved ones, we have a problem. What you do in your home is your business. If you or your kid commits a crime, you go to jail.

Stop telling us what to say, think, do, or enjoy.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...