What's More Important To Congress, Protecting Intellectual Property Or Banning Online Gambling?

from the tough-choices dept

The US might be getting a whole lot more than it bargained for when it casually passed a ban on online gambling by slipping the measure into a port security bill. It’s doubtful that the bill will have its desired effect, rather the practice will continue on shadier, less-regulated sites. Another problem, as several people have pointed out is that the bill may be in violation of WTO agreements. You can’t ban a foreign good or service that’s legally sold domestically, and since the bill carves out a clear exception for things like state lotteries and horse betting, that’s a problem. In fact, the WTO already ruled on this question, during a dispute between the US and the tiny island nation of Antigua. But in itself, flouting the WTO is not the big problem. See, Antigua, having won the dispute, has a right to exact penalties against the US. But what could Antigua do to really hurt the US? Tariffs and other restrictions wouldn’t work, because the US would hardly notice, and they’d just damage Antiguans anyway. But the country does have on eway to make the US take notice. As a retaliatory measure under the WTO, it could refuse to recognize US intellectual property. It could make itself a haven for pirated software and drugs. If the US thought that Allofmp3.com was a thorn in its side, imagine an Antiguan-based allofsoftware.com. It would create quite a stir, and make many industry players quite upset at the US government. It all doesn’t seem quite worth it, as Radley Balko put it in the above article, “because (Congressman) Bob Goodlatte thinks card playin’ is fer’ the devil.”

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “What's More Important To Congress, Protecting Intellectual Property Or Banning Online Gambling?”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

wow. that’s great. granted, i feel people should be compensated for their work. that’s why we have all the benifits and such in place. however i don’t believe that just because you are a {insert over paid profession here} you should be ENTITLED to millions every year. especially since you haven’t done any work in the past x years.

but i’m not familar with the WTO, our role and whatnot in it. can we drop from it? if we do, what would happen?

but if that’s more harmful than allofsoftware.com it’d be great, because then we’d have the entire business industry forcing the government to actually work for the masses!!!!!11!!

Anonymous Coward says:

Go for it

I say go for it. it’s time that congress gets a rude awakening. People who don’t understand technology and succumb to lobbyists deserve to have thier laws backfire. If only we were a true democracy (and not a representative democracy or republic), then we could vote on each law instead of electing people that seem to be easily corruptible…

James says:

Not that I agree with congress..

..but, you guys are missing the boat. You can’t vote on EVERY peice of legislation, you think things move slowly now?? And ever hear of a referendum, these are laws the voters vote on and pass in elections, so you do get some invdividual say.

That all said… yes the whole congressional system needs an overhaul, lobbyists need to be throw out and I hope this whole preaching morality bs (ie anti-gambling legislation these turkeys just passed) blows up in their face.

Anonymous Coward says:

Congress is a supreme example of a huge, Goldbergian machine that ginds and processes on without much thought or direction, rolling over the average man without a care, kinda directionless, until some huge corporation needs something from it; then its quickly and efficiently in action. Then it lurches and rumbles on to the next lobby. Kinda like the legal system, sort of a rich man’s playing field. And our taxes keep it moving. I’m simply disgusted with the whole system. Its plainly not for me to get involved in. I’m thinking about moving to Antarctica where I won’t be bothered by taxes, regulations, and people trying to sue me or get my vote.

Caribbean Resident says:

This bill will Destroy Antigua

This bill will Destroy the economy of the tiny island of Antigua, but of course the US couldn’t give two figs. Antigua’s economy was already gutted due to trade restrictions and a shift in trade preference for its agriculture. So in order to survive the country became a haven for offshore accounting and Finance, which many Online Gambling companies used.

That’s what was keeping the country afloat.

Not to mention the number of large firms with a high employment number that have been forced to close because of this. A lot of people are now out of jobs worldwide, and especially in the UK.

The WTO categorically ruled that the United States was in breach of its responsibilities under several treaties, the US said f*** you. Although it has used this same WTO to force others to accept its edicts and to force acceptance of US written Copyright agreements, manage and control Trade etc. Globalisation is fantastic, and everyone should engage in Free Trade, except the United States when it wants to protect it’s domestic industries.

In short, there is one law for the United States of America, and another law for the rest of the world. THe US is clearly in breach of it’s agreements and obligations under the same WTO that affords it successful trade negotiations, but there’s nothing the WTO can do about it, and the rest of the world must simply sit and suck it up.

dazcon5 says:

once again...

Once again the US government has basically said BITE ME to the rest of the world in an attempt to garnish votes.
Then they wonder why there is so much anti US sentiment.
Our congress/senate have basically put up a…
sign and businesses just started writing checks.
We need to vote out all the incumbents (at least 90%).
(gov) what the f**k do YOU want!!!
(me punching each in the face) POW
(gov) y, y, ye, yes
(me) quit selling us out to the corporates!
(gov) ye,..yes sir!
(me) GOOD… now get back to work you maggots!

doubledoh says:

Hm. Antigua, you say? I wonder if that would be a good place to live and run a tech company.

No. I’ve been in Antigua for over 4 years. All the tech & gaming companies moved to Costa Rica because the Antiguan govt grows more corrupt and greedy every year. And believe me, they already don’t respect Copyrights. Fake DVD’s are sold on tables in the middle of town, and the “Cable” that people subscribe to is just an almagamation of stolen satellite signals resold by a local crooks and croney’s.

Despite all this…the real estate market here is booming. If you want to make some money, invest in property on the island.

Anti. Govt. All the Way says:

Lets Revolt!!

Does anybody remember the good old days when people weren’t afraid to physically stand up to a corrupt (or even unpopular) government? I wasn’t around for them, and yet I feel we’re being pushed towards that kind of resolution. Online gambling being banned (and deemed a class C felony in Wash.) is just the tip of an iceburg that’s done way more permanent damage. Why are we allowing a bunch of greedy bastards to run our lives, when in a democracy, the voting public is supposed to dictate what is good for themselves? Even a blind man could see that online gambling isn’t as damaging as alcohol, high gas prices, or a war on terror that’s spawning more terrorists than we could ever kill. But, the government doesn’t seem to think that they can profit off of it, so they passed a bill, right under our f’ing noses to ban it. 1 million gun toting Americans on the White House lawn would get a point across, but noone is ready to man up and fight for the rights they claim to deserve.

Antiguanabroad says:

I would just like to comment on doubledoh’s post.

In 2004 the people of Antigua booted out the ruling ALP government for only the second time in almost thirty years (forty is you count Antigua’s period of Associated statehood). Now the current UPP government isn’t perfect, but to accused them of being worse than the ALP — as doubledoh effectly does — is just plain outlandish. No serious observer of Antigua believes that.

The companies that moved to Costa Rica and elsewhere, most of them anyway, did so before 2004.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...