Do Travel Sites Charge More If You Tell Them You're Rich?

from the clever-pricing dept

One thing that really irritates savvy shoppers is when they discover that somebody else got a better deal than them. This is likely to occur on airplanes, as airline-pricing algorithms tend to be opaque and highly variable. That’s given rise to new sites which try to anticipate when the airlines will offer various prices. One consequence of this so-called price discrimination is that companies are likely to pursue personal information on its shoppers so as to anticipate the highest price a given shopper is likely to pay for an item. But while customers are understandably miffed when companies harvest their personal data, is there anything wrong with less invasive forms of price discrimination? One traveler discovered that an online comparison engine listed different prices for the same hotels depending on how the search was conducted. If the searcher wanted results listed from highest to lowest (presumably an indication of their wealth and their desire to stay on top-rate hotels) the listings for a given hotel turned out higher. People may not like this, but that’s not necessarily the right response. Variable pricing allows the price-insensitive to subsidize the price-sensitive shoppers that put in the effort to find a good deal. Of course it’s a catch-22, by exposing these methods, companies are likely to change them.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Do Travel Sites Charge More If You Tell Them You're Rich?”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Adam (user link) says:

travel savings on ultimate search engine.

Power Search metasearch technology takes you to over 200 different sites to give you results. it work great!! Also there is a way to sign up adn become a travel agent of your own and recieve huge discount on travel. to find out more. Email me and we can get you travel agent credentials so you can travel at wholesale prices!!!

Mike Mixer says:

This is a return to haggling

The truth is that this is a different form of an old art in merchandising called the haggle. In the old days a vendor had his customer right in front of him so he used visual cues to estimate how far he could push the price and still make a sale. This new way is just as valid and has nothing to do with subsidizing others who are not as wealthy, it does have everything to do with selling the most product you can for the most money you can make. There is no dishonesty in

this process, just two people making a deal.

Anonymous Coward says:

Current trends mean that no two people will pay the same price for the same products in the future…

Coca-Cola tested vending machines in 2000 that raised the price of a Coke on hotter days…

Grocery loyalty programs are also a good example… If you are silling to sacrifice your privacy (shopping patterns), you can pay less than your neighbor. And if you buy Coca-Cola every week without fail… don’t be surprised if your neighbor (a Pepsi fan) gets Coke coupons in the mail and you don’t.

aReader says:

Apply same model to customer service

I know a couple of banks that uses a customer service model where the level of service is proportional to the amount of money in your bank accout. When you call a bank and enter your account number, your wait time and the person whom you will talk to (India vs US) is decided based on how much money you have in your account.

Nonesuch says:

Re: Apply same model to customer service

When you call a bank and enter your account number, your wait time and the person whom you will talk to (India vs US) is decided based on how much money you have in your account.

Giving preferential treatment to people who’ve already given you money is ethical, and a good business practice — charging prospective customers more based on their percieved ability to pay is, IMHO, unethical, borderline illegal.

It just makes sense to give better service to customers who have given you more business — but if my bank charged me higher fees than somebody who had less on deposit because they felt I could afford them, I wouldn’t stand for that.

jeff says:

i already don’t fly on my own dollar BECAUSE of stuff like the airlines’ pricing methodologies. americans are getting to numb, when an industry does shit like this, you boycott it and they either shape up or sink, the government can only bail their asses out for so long…or, you can be a pussy and put up with it. you’ve always got a choice. like the choice to not pay a few hundred dollars for a space that’s narrower than your hips, shorter than you sitting down, and you only get to be in for a few hours. oh and don’t forget the 3 peanuts you get to savor…assuming some defect on the plane isn’t allergic to peanuts, of course. THEN IT’S TIME TO BREAK OUT THE FIESTA MIX, WOO HOOO!!

personally, i like taking trains.

Michael (user link) says:

Its working so well

It amazes me that others are looking to the failing airlines as a business model. When an airline goes under there is a sense of ‘they got what’s comin’ to ’em’ form the public. If I ever tried to run a business like these fools, I’d be laughed out of the marketplace:

Customer: “Yes, we would like to purchase your service at the price you quoted”

Me: “I’m sorry, that price is no longer available”

Customer: “You quoted me the price five minutes ago”

Me: “Yes, that was the old pricing. At this time, the cost of the service has gone up 50%”

Customer: “F*ck you”

Me: “That’s what I was hoping to do to you. Oh, by the way, that last quote is no longer available. It has gone up again. You better purchase now… Hello, hmm, we seem to have gotten disconnected”


Any business model where the customer is treated like a stooge, should be put out of business by the would-be customer.

Celes says:

Comparison shopping

Perhaps a way around this is to look at the websites of the individual hotels/airlines/etc you are considering directly, rather than relying on a travel site. Although travel sites are useful, they don’t always offer the best deals (for hotels, anyway, since that’s the industry I have the most experience with). At least a few of the major hotel chains have an agreement/policy that states that the rate you receive from the hotel’s website/reservations line will ALWAYS be the same or less than rates you receive through these travel sites. And the hotels don’t ask you how you want to sort the results…

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...