Drew Stephenson's Favorite Techdirt Posts Of The Week
from the good-news! dept
About a week ago I put a comment under an article about the DOJ abusing its powers mentioning that I was thinking of stopping reading Techdirt as it was getting too depressing. However I kept reading and I'm glad I've done so as this week has seen some much more positive stories, and in a week of worsening recession, continuing corruption and ever escalating global violence, I'm going to focus on the good news.
We've got a new policy for Washington Police about how to handle photographers. It would be nice to see something similar spreading across a few more forces, both in the States and in the UK.
Over 1500 organizations and 50,000 people have signed the Declaration of Internet Freedom. I'm very interested to see how this pans out in the long term. It feels a bit like this could be a test of "The People vs The Vested Interests", the key question being, will this document make a difference?
It's possibly not the done thing to say that one of my favorite posts is an aggregated one, but the collection of links about the future of assisted vision was fantastic and I get the chance to link to my favorite Sheldon comic. In all these little ways, we are becoming closer and closer to cyborgs, and I for one welcome our new robot overlords...
Of course it wouldn't be a good week on Techdirt without a story of someone trying something new and clever on Kickstarter. In another new turn-up I think this is the first time we've seen something like this without the usual trolls and their "it'll never scale / work for everyone / last / work for people without a major label background" arguments. Perhaps the message is getting through?
Staying on innovation in music, the news that an app is being developed to aggregate smart-phone concert footage shows that not everyone in the industry is trying to shut down bootleg content. Similarly the release of The Humble Music Bundle is another example of a company trying new things.
Moving back onto legal matters, and stepping away from copyright to other aspects of IP, we have two more good-news stories. The first is that Judge Posner has decided to give the patent system a kick, and the second is a simple lesson in how to send a cease and desist letter without being an asshole
I used to share a house with a bunch of Norwegians, they were all really good people as were (as far as I can tell) all their friends. So in many ways it's no surprise that Norway continues to show us the right way to deal with terrorism.
I'm going to finish with a story that may not be an obvious candidate for a good news story, especially given some of the comments from our regular critics. However the news that Michael Rossato-Bennett is running a Kickstarter campaign to fund his film Alive Inside just serves to remind me that, despite the problems highlighted in the article, and despite this being an area of life that people still shy away from, there are people doing great work out there transforming lives.
Watch that trailer video again, go on, you know you want to.

Re: Re:
successful troll is successful...
Not that it was really trolling, just a bit of sarcasm.
6/10 must try harder.
(untitled comment)
I can't believe you didn't invite me!
Oh wait, you wanted smart people?
Sorry! As you were ;¬)
Re: Re: Rights database projects are already underway
UK is looking at this too as part of the current consultation: http://www.ipo.gov.uk/types/hargreaves/hargreaves-copyright/hargreaves-copyright-dce.htm
bringing it into line with europe
Hmm, I remember arguing with one commenter about the meaning of "limited" in copyright a few months ago. They argued that there would be no further expansion of copyright and the last one was just to bring the US into line with the rest of the world.
Oh look, here's that same argument again, expanding individual rights against the public interest.
Glad that I was proved wrong so quickly...
... oh no, wait.
Re: This article is irrelevant because ...
The only mistake you've made in your parody Milton is to actually remain coherent throughout.
9/10
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
"The only real question is "how much more would they have made otherwise (by pushing on DRM, or raising prices, staying away from bundles, etc)?""
Or how much less?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Finally!
Funny. Wrong, but funny.
Re:
Sweet!
Re: Re: Re: Re:
I think it's a Heinlein book where he says "a gentleman is someone who says 'thank you' to his robot".
Re: Not the same
I finally found a decent analogue / digital analogy the other week.
Our work place provides free coffee from vending machines - it's not very nice but it's hot and caffienated and that's what important.
But they also have vending machines that sell cold drinks and you can pay for coffee in the shop downstairs (but you can't compete with free! sorry, I'll move on).
The analogy comes into play on this story because the vending machines don't accept £2 coins. These have been in use for about 15 years. The other day I wanted a coke and the only cash I had with me was a £2 coin.
But because the vending machine company hadn't updated the machine to take £2 coins they didn't get their money and I went and got a free coffee instead.
I wanted to pay for something but their decision not to update their transaction system meant that I went and got a free alternative. I wasn't happy, they weren't happy.
Doesn't that sound familiar?
Re:
You know that people don't care what something costs to produce right? Either it's price is equal to or lower than its value (in which case they'll buy) or it isn't (in which case they won't).
If we're just talking about competing on price - which we were.
But again, 7 billion people on the planet, that's a long way towards infinity to me.
Re:
Exactly, you're not just buying the coffee, you're buying that 5 minutes break as well, and that "let someone else do the dishes" moment...
Re: Re: I really shouldn't have to say this...
Yeah, I've been sucked in a couple of times. You're right though, it's counter-productive now. Report and ignore all the way.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Sad state of things
disagree with this entirely. If he's been asked to stop and continued I would suggest that, if it were the UK, this is "death by misadventure" though I have idea whether other countries have this concept.
Re: Re:
Yep, both Sweden and the UK have a disappointing recent history of bending over to the US in cases like this.
Like or loathe Assange, you're being willfully abstruse if you can't see that he has reason to fear the absence of a fair trial.
If he even gets a trial at all.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
surely that would be hitlerium? Ht perhaps? With a half life of 28 years?
Re: Re: Re: Re: about law
aargh! my eyes!
Re: Re: Re: about law
....must...resist...
Re: Re: Re: Same point as before
Ah, I did not understand this. I retract my criticism. Haven an insightful each. Thank you.
Same point as before
I can ask my friends not to tag me in certain scenarios, I can't do the same with an automated system.