"Again, if someone were to complain to your car dealership/bank you got the car loan from that they saw a car with your licence plate driving on their private land, you'd be livid if the dealership/bank just repossessed your car (or sent engineers out to limit its max speed to far below the legal speed limit). You'd have been punished with no opportunity to dispute."
It boils down real simple.
ISP is punishing customer because of claims of illegal activity. Illegal activity is easy to prove as there will be Court documents of your conviction. No conviction? No illegal activity.
"Occasionally viewing or reading a brutal or sexual scene seems largely harmless, at least for grown-ups. But saturating ourselves with any set of images seems likely to mold our minds along particular channels."
This is why there are no full time jobs rating tv shows, games, books etc...Not one human being is capable of multiple exposure to the things we aren't allowed to see, read etc...
From the extortionists', we bring you more from the list of Six Strikes non-defenses.
"The specific objections here: irrelevant, lacks foundation and/or personal knowledge, hearsay, speculation, argumentative, assumes facts not in evidence, improper characterization of evidence, improper authentication of document."