Supreme Court Justice Kennedy Teaches Wrong Lesson On Freedom Of The Press

from the except-for-when-it-comes-to-supreme-court-justices dept

You would think that a Supreme Court Justice (and the people who work for one) would know better than to tell any sort of news publication -- even a high school newspaper -- that he needed to approve any articles written about a speech he gave, but that appears to be exactly what happened with Justice Anthony Kennedy and a recent speech to Dalton High School students in Manhattan. The people who work for Kennedy are now trying to claim that this was just to make sure the quotes were accurate, but those who work for the school paper say they were under the impression they needed full approval of the article first. It's amazing that whoever made the request (whether Kennedy himself or some staffer) didn't realize how bad that would look, especially from a Justice who has always been a strong proponent of strong First Amendment rights...

26 Comments | Leave a Comment..

Too Much Free Time

by Mike Masnick

Wed, Oct 24th 2007 9:42am

A Modest Proposal: Don't Try To Censor Students Who Have This Thing We Call The Internet

from the only-positive-stories-around-here... dept

Way back when I was in high school, I wrote for the school newspaper, and occasionally we had some problems with either the paper's "advisors" or the administration not liking something that went into the paper. While we were able to get plenty of stuff published, there were occasional arguments. The best we could do at the time was complain -- and eventually some of us started a non-school-sanctioned paper to allow us to be more free. That, of course, was in the days before the internet was widely available. These days, things work quite differently. Romenesko points us to the somewhat ridiculous story of a principal confiscating the school newspaper and demanding that the students write more "positive and uplifting stories" after he freaked out about a student's attempt to mimic one of the most famous pieces of satire: Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal. Apparently, the principal didn't get the satire of the piece, which proposed executing all of those who score in the bottom 25% on an IQ test. Of course, in censoring the paper, the immediate response is pretty much what should be expected these days. The editor of the paper resigned and posted the whole ordeal to Facebook, where it spread quickly, not only making the principal a laughingstock for not recognizing a clear homage to Swift, but it gave the actual column much more attention -- even to the point that the major newspaper in Atlanta, the Atlanta Journal Constitution, republished the student's modest proposal within its own pages. Now that's a positive and uplifting story.

30 Comments | Leave a Comment..

Search Techdirt

And now, a word from our Sponsors..

15% off discount for Techdirt Readers

Popular Posts

Poll

Add Techdirt RSS To Your Reader

Subscribe to Techdirt's Daily Email Newsletter

Older Stuff

Wednesday
5:26pm:	Profitable 'Pay Us Or We'll Sue You For File Sharing' Scheme About To Send 30,000 More Letters (20)
4:46pm:	UK Police Arresting People Just To Add To DNA Database? (18)
4:01pm:	Funny How Those In Favor Of ACTA Are Against Treaty Providing More Access To Content For Vision Impaired (6)
3:15pm:	Advertising As Content: Newspaper Raising Newsstand Prices For Thanksgiving Papers With Black Friday Ads (11)
2:14pm:	Are Entertainment Industry Tactics Working? (50)
1:00pm:	Photographer Compares Microstock Sites To Pollution And Drug Dealing (45)
11:48am:	If Movie Piracy Is Really A Problem, It's Hollywood's Fault (77)
10:27am:	If Google Visitors Are Worthless, It's Only Because Newspaper Execs Don't Know What They're Doing (37)
9:01am:	Multitasking Is Our Main Activity (15)
7:33am:	Greed vs. Due Diligence: Another Case Of Startup Fraud? (4)
6:01am:	Anti-Piracy Group In Spain Fined For Bad Faith Actions Against File Sharing Systems (13)
3:55am:	ABA Journal's Patent Application To Score Interview With USPTO Boss David Kappos (18)
1:44am:	Can Universities Make Sure That Drugs Based On Their Research Are Licensed Reasonably? (19)
Tuesday
9:21pm:	Companies Realizing That Content Is Advertising Via Web Series (12)
7:01pm:	Could You Prove That The Government Was Watching You Illegally? (38)
4:56pm:	Reuters, AP Refuse To Cover Cricket Matches Over Restrictive Press Accreditation Rules (21)
3:21pm:	Comparing File Sharing To Payola: Could Have Had That Promotion For Free (34)
1:56pm:	Jury Says Fictional Character Can Be Libelous (28)
12:44pm:	Spam King Alan Ralsky Gets Four Years In Jail (28)
11:39am:	Publishers Getting The Wrong Message Over eBook Piracy (39)
10:28am:	Calling For An Independent Invention Defense In Patents (27)
9:12am:	Microsoft Tries To Silence Revelation Of Bing Cashback Flaws; Leads To Revelation Of Other Problems (43)
8:03am:	Don't Blame Facebook For Some Kids Beating Up Another Student (61)
6:46am:	Hulu Telling Sites To Stop Embedding So Much (44)
5:00am:	Once Again, If The Gov't Has Data, It Will Be Abused (42)
2:53am:	As Expected, Social Networking Generation Running For Office Face Their Permanent Record Online (32)
12:55am:	IMAX Sues Cinemark For Building Competing System... While Being An IMAX Customer (14)
Monday
10:26pm:	Filmmaker Allowed To Use The Name Rin Tin Tin To Describe Rin Tin Tin (6)
8:25pm:	Senators Begin Questioning ACTA Secrecy (32)
6:34pm:	Brazil E-Voting Machines Not Hacked... But Van Eck Phreaking Allowed Hacker To Record Votes (15)

Quick Links

Current Insight Community Cases

Supreme Court Justice Kennedy Teaches Wrong Lesson On Freedom Of The Press

from the except-for-when-it-comes-to-supreme-court-justices dept

A Modest Proposal: Don't Try To Censor Students Who Have This Thing We Call The Internet

from the only-positive-stories-around-here... dept

Which Internet Concern Worries You The Most?

Techdirt's Daily Email Newsletter

Wednesday

Tuesday

Monday

More