Race Team Discovers That Parody Site Is Free Speech; While Drawing Extra Attention To Parody

from the 8-cylinders-of-funny dept

I've always enjoyed parody for its comedic value, not only in the obvious mocking of a parody's target, but in the oft-hilariously overblown responses from those targets. That said, when the target of parody goes legal, it usually dampens the fun a bit. For instance, when we begin losing a bit of comic strip humor in the form of parody because someone can't handle a band's lyrics showing up in Peanuts speech bubbles, someone is going out of their way to prove they can't take a joke. And when a cable company can't take a little honest ribbing and gets a hilarious YouTube video taken down, it's tempting to let one's temperature rise.

But then you hear the story of one website, supposedly the online presence of Generic Race Team, a motorsports racing group run by a mulleted dwarf with a penchant for booze and Pakistani storefronts. Confused? Well, it's all in good fun.

It's long gone now, but the Generic Race Team website and its associated Facebook and Twitter accounts were hilarious and scathing parodies of an actual racing team that runs Porsches in sports car racing called The Racer's Group, or TRG Motorsports. And when the parody site popped up, TRG began digging into who set it up.
And what got TRG's panties so bunched up that they had to go digging into a relatively unknown website's ownership? Well, to be fair, the mocking-phasers on the parody were site were set to "destroy." For instance, TRG's CEO, Kevin Buckler, is transformed into Devin Fuckler, the aforementioned mulleted little person. The site included "articles" about Fuckler's plans to open up a motorsport race shop in Abbottabad, Pakistan, surely a hotbed of auto racing. Also, the real-life Buckler's Sonoma winery, Adobe Road, was transformed into Terra Cotta Path, a fake winery that garnered the supposed accolade of being "voted 'wine'" by a local culinary group. It got funnier from there.
Emblazoned atop the home page of the website was a story dated May 1, 2011, headlined “Sam Standeround Named GRT Employee of the Year, 2011!!” The intended humor was obvious—a person who “stands around” was named employee of the year before the year was even halfway over. A picture of the purported Mr. Standeround showed him to be a portly man with a curly mullet haircut, cradling a delicate poodle-type dog. Farther down the home page was pictured the “crew chief of the week,” a crazed-looking man with his extraordinarily large mouth agape exhibiting his almost complete lack of teeth.

Appellants further argue that they were defamed by the website‟s inclusion of a fake sponsor, “Xtreme Super Awesome Eco Boost.” According to the (poorly digitally manipulated) picture of Xtreme Super Awesome Eco Boost, it comes with a pair of human testicles attached to the bottle.
So who was behind all the fun? Well, it turns out that it was Jason Medbury, who just happened to work for The Media Barons, who just happened to be TRG's marketing company, which doesn't speak well for Kevin Buckler's personal relationship skills. Anyway, Kevin and TRG were understandably not pleased with their own marketing firm creating such a scathing parody site. They would have been perfectly justified in firing The Media Barons. Unfortunately, they also went legal, claiming defamation (court document below). More unfortunately, two different courts have now tried to educate TRG's legal staff of what parody is and why it is protected by the First Amendment. Per the latest ruling:
Overall, the fake website created by Medbury was mean-spirited, offensive, and stupid. But it did not provide grounds for a legitimate libel claim. As was held in S.F. Bay Guardian, a case involving a fake letter-to-the-editor published in a parody edition of a newspaper, “[i]f a parody could be actionable because, while recognizable as a joke, it conveyed an unfavorable impression, very few journalistic parodies could survive. The butt of the parody is chosen for some recognizable characteristic or viewpoint which is then exaggerated. It is not for the court to evaluate the parody as to whether it went 'too far.‟ As long as it is recognizable to the average reader as a joke, it must be protected or the rather common parody issues of newspapers and magazines must cease to exist.” Since the average viewer would have recognized that the website was nothing more than a parody, it was not actionable as libel.
In the end, the website has unfortunately been voluntarily taken down, probably because it isn't great business strategy to have now well-known parodies of customers created by a marketing company on display. Still, it's nice to see the courts get parody right, and even admit that they shouldn't be in the business of judging humor.



Reader Comments (rss)

(Flattened / Threaded)

  1.  
    icon
    Ninja (profile), Oct 16th, 2013 @ 3:17am

    Overall, the fake website created by Medbury was mean-spirited, offensive, and stupid.

    Ah diversity. Over 7 billion humans in the planet, over 7 billion different tastes and opinions. Good thing that the court also gets it and doesn't let its own taste bias the case:

    It is not for the court to evaluate the parody as to whether it went 'too far.

    Epic win. And some free laughter. Would've been awesome if the parody was still up.

     

    reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

  2.  
    identicon
    Way Wayback, Oct 16th, 2013 @ 6:06am

    Anyone else noticed not as many sites being archived

    I went looking for the site at the wayback machine and couldn't find it. Unfortunately it looks like a lot of sites are making sure they are not being archived.

    Shame really because it was great to be able to go back and find articles that have been taken off live sites.

    There used to be a great DIY site that a back yard tinkerer had made. Something happened and he lost the domain and whoever registered it disallowed archiving. I went looking, hoping to save some of the tutorials and all of his wonderful projects that had been there were gone.

     

    reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

  3.  
    icon
    madasahatter (profile), Oct 16th, 2013 @ 6:46am

    Parody

    One of the most effective methods of exposing the foibles of the powerful and stupid is parody. Also, it is one of the forms of humor they hate because it mocks them in an obvious, often harsh, and many times very funny manner.

     

    reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]


Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Save me a cookie
  • Note: A CRLF will be replaced by a break tag (<br>), all other allowable HTML will remain intact
  • Allowed HTML Tags: <b> <i> <a> <em> <br> <strong> <blockquote> <hr> <tt>
Follow Techdirt
A word from our sponsors...
Essential Reading
Techdirt Reading List
Techdirt Insider Chat
A word from our sponsors...
Recent Stories
A word from our sponsors...

Close

Email This