Magic Hat Brewery Sues West Sixth Brewing, Claiming 6 Looks Too Much Like 9

from the mmmmm-beer dept

You may recall that years ago Anheuser-Busch applied for a trademark on the number 312, having bought out Goose Island Brewery, who had a beer by that name. The catch is that 312 is the area code for most of Chicago, where Goose Island was based, and that seems like a sort of funny thing to trademark. But, strange as that might seem, at least AB didn’t then go around suing the pants off of anyone who used any further permutation of that number.

In what’s a first for me, Brig C. Mccoy shows me an instance where one brewery with a trademark on a single digit has sued another brewery over a completely different digit.

A lawsuit filed May 16 in U.S. District Court charged that West Sixth began selling beer, ale and brewpub services in 2012 using color, trademarks and designs “that closely resemble and are confusingly similar” to the designs used by Magic Hat for several years.

And if you look at the side-by-side comparison picture, you can see exactly what they mean. After all, Magic Hat #9’s logo is maroon, yellow and orange, with a trippy stylized number 9 and a star. The offending logo from West Sixth’s amber ale is brown, tan and silver, with a non-stylized number 6 merged with a circle and a star. In other words, they’re almost nothing freaking alike in any way.

The only basis for the suit appears to be that 6s and 9s are kinda similar (as in opposite of one another) and there is some incorporation of a circle and a star somewhere. And that, friends, is a shitty basis for a trademark suit. Seriously, look at the picture and tell me if you could possibly confuse the two. If you say yes, there’s a good chance you recently had a lobotomy.

West Sixth appears to agree.

“They’re claiming that we intentionally copied their logo, and that has caused them “irreparable harm,” enough that they’re asking for not only damages but also all our profits up until this point (little do they know that well, as a startup company, there wasn’t any, oops!)”

West Sixth logos were created by a professional design firm in Lexington called Cricket Press that has “a long history of fantastic and creative logo designs. … Our logo contains neither a ‘#’ nor a ‘9.’”

The lack of a # is actually kind of key. As West Sixth points out on its own website, the trademark in question includes the “#” sign, so the fact that their beer doesn’t have it is pretty damning by itself. But, even beyond that, the focus on different numbers is just ridiculous.

Look, within the confines of a beer can or bottle, there’s only so much you can do with a logo. That said, here’s a fun experiment you can do at home (assuming you’re of legal drinking age). Find someone who has never tried either of the Magic Hat or West Sixth beers in question. Sit that person down at a table with a case of both beers in front of them. Ask them if they are under any illusions that the two brews are distinctly different because of the logo. When they say, “Of course not, you idiot, and why did you kidnap me from the Stop & Go?!?”, ask them to slam one of each beers. Rinse, repeat. Exactly how many double-slammed-beers do you think this person would have to go through before they can’t tell the difference between a 6 and a 9?

Filed Under: 6, 9, beer, numbers, trademark
Companies: magic hat brewery, west sixth brewery