Sony Music Exec: The Internet Is Full Of Opportunities & Not A Problem; Intransigent Collection Societies, However…
from the more-people-getting-it dept
We’ve detailed a few times the ridiculous standoff in Germany, where the incredibly aggressive music collection society GEMA is involved in a big lawsuit against YouTube for posting videos with music in them. YouTube has done licensing deals with collection societies around the globe, but GEMA refuses to even sit down to start a conversation until after the lawsuit happens. Because of that, all GEMA music in Germany is barred from YouTube entirely. This leads to some situations in which totally licensed videos are banned in Germany. This has been going on for years and years with no change.
GEMA, of course, says that it’s doing this to “protect” the artists. But as I’ve pointed out in the past, many, many artists in Germany don’t believe that at all. In the past we’ve noted that GEMA tried to ignore Creative Commons licenses as well as barred members from offering their music for free (two years ago, when I was in Germany at a music conference, I had multiple artists explain to me they had an “official” website where they would “sell” music to keep GEMA happy… and an “unofficial” website where they’d offer their music for free. The whole thing is crazy.
In fact, it’s gotten so crazy that apparently even the major labels are getting sick of it. TorrentFreak has the news of a top Sony Music exec, Edgar Berger, who runs their international business, talking about how the internet hasn’t been a problem at all, but has created tons of new opportunities. The ones creating the real problems for the industry? GEMA. Because the music is blocked “to protect the artist,” it appears that the labels and artists are missing out on large revenue checks from YouTube’s ContentID…
“There is absolutely nothing to complain about. The Internet is a great stroke of luck for the music industry, or better: the Internet is a blessing for us,” Berger said.
“You can not blame the Internet for harmful excesses. On the contrary. It has brought us tremendous new opportunities,” he added.
But with these new opportunities come new rivals from an unexpected corner. According to the Sony boss, music rights collecting agencies are now preventing innovation in certain countries.
In Germany, for example, most YouTube videos by Sony artists are blocked due to the music rights group GEMA, and not because Sony wants it that way. When asked why Sony’s music is not available on YouTube in Germany, Berger responded bitterly.
“It’s not because of us. You must direct this question to the German collecting agency GEMA, they licensed the copyright very restrictively.”
Quite a contrast from the “old” story, right? Here’s a situation in which technology and business model innovation via Content ID are creating massive new revenue opportunities for the entertainment industry — and the old school system of excess protectionism is denying them that revenue.
Filed Under: collection societies, edgar berger, germany, internet, music, opportunities
Companies: gema, google, sony, youtube
Comments on “Sony Music Exec: The Internet Is Full Of Opportunities & Not A Problem; Intransigent Collection Societies, However…”
OK Sony, now you’re complaining about overly restrictive licensing and copyright. Weren’t you one of the ones that helped create this situation in the first place? Oh, you were? Oh well, boo…hoo…cry me a river and all that.
Anything Sony says should be taken with a salt quarry.
White is black, up is down, and we have always been at war with Eastasia.
On the other hand, I really enjoy watching Sony having to deal with the same bs the rest of us do. *munches popcorn*
Wow.
If even *Sony* thinks you’re a bastard…
Wow.
Just wow.
The whole chorus...
*(clears throat)
(cue accordion music)
Everything you know is wrong
Black is white, up is down and short is long
And everything you used to think was so important
Doesn’t really matter anymore
Because the simple fact remains that
Everything you know is wrong
Just forget the words and sing along
All you need to understand is
Everything you know is wrong
Everything you know is wrong
If you’ve never heard this song, drop everything and look it up on youtube.
In fact, I’ll save you the trouble.
He's gone
Oh yeah, this guy is going to be out of a job by next week. You cant just speak the truth like that, and you for SURE cant paint the internet as some kind of blessing to the music business. I mean, you’re pretty much taking your life in your hands by spouting off like that. Expect either a “scandal” on this guy or a suspicious “car accident” in the near future. Remember, the talking points are “piracy”, “stronger enforcement for the artists” and “extending copyright” and thats ALL you should be talking about.
He's gone
…Adam Curry, is that you?
Sony does it and it’s fine. a company does the same thing on Sony’s behalf and it’s wrong. apart from some of the money collected going to the other company, the difference is what, exactly?
Shhh…shhhh…shhhh…shutup people! Watch! Watch them! They’re learning! We’ve proven that they can learn! Is someone documenting this? Can we repeat this result?
How’s the rootkit business these days sony?
This article was a nice break from the tedious lecture of the latest Playstation 3’s license agreement which I started to read 11 days ago and which Sony asks me to wholly read and accept before moving on playing that game with great reviews which I bougth. If all goes well, I have only 17 more days of reading before I can decide whether I accept the agreement. (By the way, what happens if I don’t accept?)
Re:
Correction… The war is being fought in Eurasia. Nice name btw. 🙂
Re:
Perhaps if they see the error of their ways they can make changes to the betterment of their business as well as society of a whole. Not to mention their customers world-wide.
The whole chorus...
Curse you! I just spent 45 minutes on YouTube watching Weird Al videos.
He's gone
I mean, you’re pretty much taking your life in your hands by spouting off like that. Expect either a “scandal” on this guy or a suspicious “car accident” in the near future.
Woah. I distrust the music labels as much as the next guy buuut…. not if the next guy is you, apparently, because that seems a little over-the-top. I wouldn’t be surprised if an exec lost their job over something like this, but I don’t think Sony’s at the point of offing people with suspicious car accidents.
Re:
Your PS3 kills a puppy. You wouldn’t want it to kill a puppy now would you?
Re:
You see–what they’re really mad at is–“How dare anyone use our own weapons against us”. This is to be expected, soon enough it will be impossible for anyone to create anything out of fear that someone will come along and bludgeon them with copyright/patent infringement suits or gouge them with ridiculous licensing fees.
Re:
Middlemen do not like middlemen taking some of their middleman fees.
Re:
“By the way, what happens if I don’t accept?”
You have a very cutting-edge paper weight
Re:
Sadly it doesn’t seem like their learning anything. It looks more like them whining, “Someones trying to take too big a piece of our pie”. When they start saying that we need to start loosening copyright/licensing restrictions across the board then I’ll agree that their learning.
Re:
Velociraptors.
Re:
What did that puppy ever do for me!?
The whole chorus...
And you are better off for it.
Re:
“Perhaps if they see the error of their ways”
I was laughing so hard, i didn’t read the rest.
Edgar Berger
Edgar your days are numbered at Sony if you think that way.
Re:
They moved from the root kit business to getting hacked and giving out customer info business.
Cause we all know that customers dont mean shit to sony, they would rather spend more money on DRM then security.
Edgar Berger
Or he’ll get praised by making sony seem like a mere douchebag compared to the colossal douchenozzle that is gema.
Re:
To them, DRM is internet security.
Re:
the puppy urinated on your best shoes to show its love for you!
Re:
Agreed.
I shed not a tear for Sony (especially for Sony).
First thing that popped into my head was the scene/line from Cool Hand Luke that G&R used in Civil War:
“What we’ve got here is failure to communicate. Some men you just can’t reach. So you get what we had here last week, which is the way he wants it. Well, he gets it. I don’t like it anymore than you men.”
Couldn’t happen to a nicer company (although UMG is catching up fast).
Nina Nailed It
GEMA = German Entitlement Music Authoritarians
Does this guy *really* work for Sony?!?
A music exec uttering such heretical drivel is almost too good to be true, but a music exec who works for Sony?! That is too good to be true. Mike, are you sure you didn’t invent this guy in your mom’s basement?
Awwww. Poor Wittle Sony Exec
Duzza wuzza gotta wittle bitty headache from someone ELSE acting the way Sony has about entewtainment distwibution. Awwwww.
The whole chorus...
I sure hope “Don’t Download This Song” and “Stop Forwarding That Crap to Me” were a part of that medley.
So what good is a copyright if the owner of the copyright has no control?
Instead of looking at how GEMA might have screwed up I’m going to accuse Nina Paley of being responsible for all of this. Sita Sings the Blues, chubby, two-faced, cultureless, broadbrush, etc buzzwords.
[/sarc]
The whole chorus...
“Drop everything, leave Germany, and look it up on youtube.”
FTFY
The whole chorus...
It’s funny. I even cannot look up this video because it is blocked by YouTube! Thx to GEMA you *** * ****.