Documentary Filmmaker Has To Turn Over Some Footage To Chevron
from the not-so-shielded-after-all dept
Back in May, we wrote about a judge ordering a documentary filmmaker to turn over the footage that didn't make the film to Chevron. The documentary was about Chevron's alleged involvement in Ecuadorian rainforest pollution, and Chevron believes that some of the cut footage will help get a case that has been filed against it in Ecuador dismissed. The filmmaker tried to raise press protections, but the district court judge shot that down, saying that the material was not confidential (and, in fact, was filmed knowing it might be made public). The case was appealed, and the appeals court wasted little time in again telling the filmmaker to hand over footage, but the court also appears to have limited the scope somewhat:
- Berlinger has to turn over all footage showing (1) plaintiffs' counsel in Chevron's civil lawsuit in Ecuador, (2) private or court-appointed experts, and (3) current or former Ecuadorian officials;
- Chevron can only use the material produced for litigation, arbitration or submission to official government bodies;
- Chevron must pay for all reasonable costs incurred by Berlinger in turning over the footage; and
- The district court below shall maintain jurisdiction to address any disputes relating to the release of the footage.