RSS
Juliet vs. Juliet: Did Someone Forget To Tell Hollywood You Can't Copyright An Idea?
from the romeo-vs.-romeo dept
A few years back, we wrote about the oddity of Hollywood studios often paying newspapers or others for "the rights" to a particular news story. But, there's no legal reason why you need to do so (with -- potentially -- a few exceptions for the more modern concept of publicity rights) in most cases. That's because a news story is based on facts, and you can't copyright facts. You also can't copyright an idea. Now, there are plenty of good reasons why movie studios do pay for such "rights" even if they don't need to. For example, by licensing the rights, they also get access to certain people who know the story better than others. It also can lend an air of legitimacy to the movie. However, perhaps one reason why studios license the rights to an idea or a news story is because they don't even realize they don't have to.
That's the only explanation I can come up with for the ongoing lawsuit between two movie studios over who can make and/or release a movie about people seeking advice in love by leaving letters at the supposed gravestone of Juliet Capulet (of "Romeo &" fame). Apparently, two separate studios made movies on the topic, and one is suing to stop the other from releasing the movie.
There's Summit Entertainment, who is releasing a movie called Letters to Juliet, which they made after licensing a book by the same name, that told the story of the letters left at the gravestone and of a girl who responds to one of them. But then there's EPV Enterprises, who is asking for Summit's movie to be blocked, noting that it's working on a "Juliet" movie itself, called Dear Juliet -- which it licensed from a group called Club di Giulietta, who has (in real life) been responding to those letters.
While the two movies may be based on the same premise, it sounds like they're very different in terms of the actual story. And we've certainly seen similar movies come from multiple studios around the same time (Antz/Bugs Life, Dante's Peak/Volcano, Deep Impact/Armageddon, The Illusionist/The Prestige, etc...). While Summit says it's working to settle the lawsuit before a ruling is reached, it seems likely that it should prevail in any lawsuit as well. You can't copyright facts or basic ideas -- and it doesn't look like these two movies are the same -- just built off the same idea.
That's the only explanation I can come up with for the ongoing lawsuit between two movie studios over who can make and/or release a movie about people seeking advice in love by leaving letters at the supposed gravestone of Juliet Capulet (of "Romeo &" fame). Apparently, two separate studios made movies on the topic, and one is suing to stop the other from releasing the movie.
There's Summit Entertainment, who is releasing a movie called Letters to Juliet, which they made after licensing a book by the same name, that told the story of the letters left at the gravestone and of a girl who responds to one of them. But then there's EPV Enterprises, who is asking for Summit's movie to be blocked, noting that it's working on a "Juliet" movie itself, called Dear Juliet -- which it licensed from a group called Club di Giulietta, who has (in real life) been responding to those letters.
While the two movies may be based on the same premise, it sounds like they're very different in terms of the actual story. And we've certainly seen similar movies come from multiple studios around the same time (Antz/Bugs Life, Dante's Peak/Volcano, Deep Impact/Armageddon, The Illusionist/The Prestige, etc...). While Summit says it's working to settle the lawsuit before a ruling is reached, it seems likely that it should prevail in any lawsuit as well. You can't copyright facts or basic ideas -- and it doesn't look like these two movies are the same -- just built off the same idea.
I have an idea...
Finding Co-Founders in a Recovering Economy
Founders, Funders, Farmers, Fools, And Family
I’m looking for policy...
Policy Resources: Software Patents
Developers On Patents: Five Employees, Six Lawyers
I’m looking for research...
Why Data Is The New Oil, With Dan Foreman Of Lumi Mobile
Who Are App Developers?
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
But...
Copyright apologists, please tell us all how these situations are BETTER WITH COPYRIGHT than without. Please. We all want to know.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
haha on americans
and them corporations will also soon see that no one will buy
IT hardware will stop
ISPS will shut down and verizon will tank badly when ACTA gets done.
open source will be only thing that grows until they pass they ANTI FREE-SOFTWARE TRADE TREATY
music and movies will not get adverted and we the people will just do without
were sick a this stupidity
corporations should have person rights removed
ITS the ONLY way to SOLVE this once and for all before a revolution and rioting begins.
they want one keep it up.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: But...
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Dammit...
And we all know if they win and manage to block the other film they will then brag that their movie is better.
EPV is run by cowards...
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Contrary to popular opinion, this IS good.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Somebody should tell these guys that their Romeo and Juliet "idea" which they have taken from Shakespeare was actually copied from Arthur Brooke’s narrative poem The Tragical History of Romeus and Juliet, published in 1562 (2 years before Shakespeare was even born).
Oh, and Arthur Brooke apparently translated his poem from an Italian novella written by Matteo Bandello sometime earlier.
Wasn't copyright created to encourage innovation...?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Anyone want to do a low budget movie ?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Good & Bad
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Contrary to popular opinion, this IS good.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Common movies get release all the time
I think the issue here is a stall tactic whereby one studio is trying to hold the other back long enough to get their version of the theme out to theaters alone instead of having direct competition for viewers. Given two movies of the same type at the same time the viewer-ship will likely split. Whereas if they come out staggered, the first movie will likely get the 'full' audience for this type of movie and the second release will get a residual audience (those who like the theme type and are not already tired from the first movie release).
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
commonality of ideas
I have no problem with that. After all, someone once said "there are only 7 stories in the world".
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
It's the Striesand Effect Used For Good
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
umm
yes they corrupted the original story, but ALL of them were written before.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Anyone want to do a low budget movie ?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: haha on americans
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Add Your Comment