RSS
Having Learned Nothing From ESPN Mobile Debacle, Disney Closes Disney Mobile
from the wash,-rinse,-repeat dept
Disney explored the MVNO concept for years, convinced that given the opportunity, people would rush out to buy Disney-branded mobile phone service. What's amazing is that in all that time, the company never bothered to figure out how to actually make a branded mobile phone service compelling. It started an MVNO based on ESPN, which failed spectacularly, despite dumping millions of dollars into it. You would think that, having failed once, the company would be careful not to make the same mistakes -- but apparently not. When Disney launched its Disney-branded mobile phone service, it seemed perfectly designed as something no kid would want to use. So, it came as little surprise that Disney seemed to follow the identical path of other failed MVNOs: launch hype, quick price cuts, desperate flailing, closure. We noted Disney Mobile was following that exact pattern nearly a year ago (up to the price cut point), but the service continued to hang on... though, it seemed pretty clear it was in trouble. Back in April it tried to paint a rosy picture of its users with a bunch of stats, but glaringly left out how many subscribers there were.
Given all of that, it came as little surprise that Disney completed the trek of the failed MVNO, officially shutting down the service after a year and a half. Apparently, the massive failure with ESPN Mobile didn't lead to any additional insight into how to sell mobile phone service. Given the variety of high profile MVNO failures in the US lately, can we finally put to rest the concept that was popular a few years ago that every brand would have its own mobile service? People don't want to buy mobile phone service from an entertainment company -- especially when it's ultra expensive and has little in the way of features that are actually useful. If entertainment brands want to go mobile, they should create mobile apps that can work on a variety of services, rather than wishfully hoping that people will completely switch over to a branded service.
Given all of that, it came as little surprise that Disney completed the trek of the failed MVNO, officially shutting down the service after a year and a half. Apparently, the massive failure with ESPN Mobile didn't lead to any additional insight into how to sell mobile phone service. Given the variety of high profile MVNO failures in the US lately, can we finally put to rest the concept that was popular a few years ago that every brand would have its own mobile service? People don't want to buy mobile phone service from an entertainment company -- especially when it's ultra expensive and has little in the way of features that are actually useful. If entertainment brands want to go mobile, they should create mobile apps that can work on a variety of services, rather than wishfully hoping that people will completely switch over to a branded service.
I have an app...
Top 5 Reasons Why Mobile Analytics Is Important
How My First Game Made $28,623
I have a business...
The Future Of Commerce Will Combine Your Social Network And Mobile Device
To Understand The Data Move It Closer
I’m looking for research...
Why Data Is The New Oil, With Dan Foreman Of Lumi Mobile
Who Are App Developers?
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
Who would want that?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
It had some neat features
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
Fascist Corporate Mouse Stumbles Again
You called it ! The foolish mouse didn't listen ! You were right ! You told 'em so !
Serves them right ! Ha HA !
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
That sums up the old, closed corporate mentality these companies still have. The observation you made is painfully obvious to any marginally attentive biz person. I gurantee there were some underlings telling the "man" to do just what you suggest.
I'm assuming they ignored other companies problem with this biz model because "we can do it better" w/o anything to back it up.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
Kind of like Y2K prompted companies to upgrade their hardware and systems.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
MVNO
the latest mvno pipe dream is Blyk - their bright idea is to market a fixed group of handsets along with a free tariff of 43 minutes per month along with 217 free sms text messages - as long as they are willing to receive at least 6 ads per day sent to their phones. This brilliant idea will be marketed to college students who we know never use more than 43 minutes per month. of course after you use your 43 minutes you can "top up" your account with pre-paid minutes - does that mean you still have to watch the advertising? as the father of a university student I pulled out her latest bill and did some simple math. I took an average of her monthly minutes - subtracted the 43 from the number and then multiplied that by what it would cost to top her up with blyk minutes. And wouldn't you know it - just like wi-fi calling - it would cost me 3 times as much with blyk as it does under my current calling plan. am i missing something here?
I would love to have been in on the pitch meetings to the VCs.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
Disney Closes Disney Mobile
[ reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]
Add Your Comment