RSS
Saying The DOS Microsoft Originally Used Was A Rip-Off Isn't Libel
from the talk-about-sore-winners dept
Back in 2005, we wrote about the case of Tim Paterson, the creator of QDOS (which was eventually sold to Microsoft and became the basis of Microsoft DOS -- and, with it, the Microsoft empire). Paterson was pissed off at author Harold Evans for claiming in a book that Paterson had ripped off Gary Kildall's CP/M. It really isn't disputed that QDOS was modeled on CP/M -- or that Microsoft (and Paterson) eventually won out in the marketplace. So it's hard to see what the beef is here, and as Slashdot points out, it appears the judge agreed. The judge tossed out the suit saying that there didn't appear to be any libel in what was said. Most of the statements were opinions, so they can't be shown to be provably false. Also, they found no evidence of malicious intent, which would also be needed in this case. In the end, though, this certainly seems like the case of a sore winner. Paterson's software was the one that went on to greatness, whether or not it was a rip-off over Kildall's stuff.
8 Comments | Leave a Comment..
- Georgia Lawmaker Looking To Make Photoshopping Heads On Naked Bodies Illegal
- Microsoft Finally Makes It Official That It Opposes SOPA.... As Written
- Demolishing The Reasoning Behind Senators Bogus Grandstanding Against Google
- Claims In E-Mail Sent Via Google Found To Be Opinion, Not Libel
- Proposal For UK Libel Reform Fixes Many Problems, Leaves Plenty Of Others
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
greatness?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Saying The DOS Microsoft Originally Used Was A Rip
I believe the judge who ruled in that case was wise because he was able to recognize a frivolous lawsuit and rightfully tossed it aside.
Ikey Benney
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Stating the obvious!
No one disputed that "fact" 20+ years ago when there was plenty of cross pollination between CPM and QDOS and later DRDOS, etc.
Thank goodness that folks can still (occasionally) state the obvious truth without fear of libel action!
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: greatness?
1. unusually or comparatively large in size or dimensions: A great fire destroyed nearly half the city.
2. large in number; numerous: Great hordes of tourists descend on Europe each summer.
3. unusual or considerable in degree, power, intensity, etc.: great pain.
12. much in use or favor: “Humor” was a great word with the old physiologists.
I think these meanings are all applicable to DOS and is Windows succors.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Although, I would call it an improvement upon CP/M - not really a 'rip-off'.
It doesn't even matter, really. Glad to see it tossed out.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Ripoff, homage or bkwd compat
The first few versions of DOS were certainly NOT an improvement on CP/M. DOS won in the marketplace for the same reason VHS beat Beta - nobody cared which was better, only "want did everybody else buy?".
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re: greatness?
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Rip-off
Personally I disagree with the Judge. The common use of the expression "rip-off" clearly connotes something which is illegal or otherwise improper.
[ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]
Add Your Comment